Introducing: Clan War Tournaments!

I would like to see clan tournaments BUT there is one big problem. That is getting 16 clan at the same lvl to start a tournament it already can take a while to find one clan to war against imagine what it would be like if it war 16 clans against each other? It would take probably AT LEAST a week to even start the tournament and then another 4 weeks to finish it. No one would join these tournaments because in the week that you are waiting, you could do 3.5 wars there would be no profit to clans so no one would join in these tournaments therefore all they would do is take up server space. Unfortunately this is just something that is a good idea but just can't be added sorry.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 1234213

I would like to see clan tournaments BUT there is one big problem. That is getting 16 clan at the same lvl to start a tournament it already can take a while to find one clan to war against imagine what it would be like if it war 16 clans against each other? It would take probably AT LEAST a week to even start the tournament and then another 4 weeks to finish it. No one would join these tournaments because in the week that you are waiting, you could do 3.5 wars there would be no profit to clans so no one would join in these tournaments therefore all they would do is take up server space. Unfortunately this is just something that is a good idea but just can't be added sorry.

---

Appreciate the feedback!

I noted this potential issue in the OP and feel that there are (always) solutions to issues such as this so don't give up on the idea too easily : )

I have a really solid solution to suggest that I still need to add to the OP ASAP. The matchmaking for Tournaments could be set up as so:

When a clan searches for a Tournament, instead of the tournament starting the moment all 16 clans are matched, the tournament could begin on a specific day the following week. This would allow the matchmaking system ample time to find 16 well matched clans, and in the mean time each clan can do regular wars without worrying about interruption : )

Hope you like that solution! If not, let me know any suggestions you have to improve this and please consider this idea and solutions to its problems before voting no! Thanks again.

Feel free to share why you voted against this idea! It will help the idea improve : )

this idea is awesome. it may be a little to complicated tho. great work overall

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by razoradam

this idea is awesome. it may be a little to complicated tho. great work overall

---

Thanks!

If I knew how to make pictures I'm sure they would make the OP better :/

Great idea! Im a strong supporter of this!

Look bro its an amazing idea but why we cant start another tournamemt :/ u should change it bro :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by broknock

Look bro its an amazing idea but why we cant start another tournamemt :/ u should change it bro :)

---

Hmm that's an option but I figure it wouldn't be a big issue since clans can do regular wars until the tournament ends!

Thanks for voting please provide feedback as well if you don't mind! : )

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Excalibur28

Great idea! Im a strong supporter of this!

---

Thanks very much! It's not the best idea out there but I think it's be fun :p

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by iDANglin

Appreciate the feedback!

I noted this potential issue in the OP and feel that there are (always) solutions to issues such as this so don't give up on the idea too easily : )

I have a really solid solution to suggest that I still need to add to the OP ASAP. The matchmaking for Tournaments could be set up as so:

When a clan searches for a Tournament, instead of the tournament starting the moment all 16 clans are matched, the tournament could begin on a specific day the following week. This would allow the matchmaking system ample time to find 16 well matched clans, and in the mean time each clan can do regular wars without worrying about interruption : )

Hope you like that solution! If not, let me know any suggestions you have to improve this and please consider this idea and solutions to its problems before voting no! Thanks again.

---

Yes! Also, it doesn't have to be 16 clans. Maybe 14 or 12 would do as well.

I like this idea, but I think that 4 weeks is way too long. I would suggest 1-2 weeks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Isaacium

Yes! Also, it doesn't have to be 16 clans. Maybe 14 or 12 would do as well.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FlyAutumn

I like this idea, but I think that 4 weeks is way too long. I would suggest 1-2 weeks.

---

Heard thanks!

Seems quite common for feedback to be reguarding these two parts of the idea so I'll work to fix it when I have the time in a couple of days. Thanks again!!!

Like the idea talk to Steve about it

Fantastic idea.. will love to take part in the clan wars!! This is going to be great fun if included..

This is a great idea I would love to see implemented, however, I agree that the time is too long. Also, there could be a problem with not being able to hold enough war loot if you got the tournament and last war bonus at the same time.

EDIT: I also think many clans would have trouble keeping all/most of thier members for a whole month so is it a new war lineup each time or...?

how do we get to know if this idea will be used in the game or not?

Thanks for the feedback guys! I'll change the time frame this event would take place and shorten it. Hopefully you all prefer the change when I do it here tonight or tomorrow. Thanks again!

Great idea i hope they do some kind of tournament

I love the idea! Would add a great spice to the game. I just want to make one adjustment which is that there should be multiple times for the tournament, ex: One setting for an 8 day tournament, 2 days for each war just like normal, another 16 day war, one war each four days, and another just like the one you suggested. Hopefully this gets added!

I had a similar idea. I think it should cost each member x amount of gems per clan and the clan that wins gets the total gems from all the clans in the tournament

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by XxscottxX

I had a similar idea. I think it should cost each member x amount of gems per clan and the clan that wins gets the total gems from all the clans in the tournament

---

I think its bad, gems are pretty much money based unless you get them from removing stuff. I would understand if it would have cost participation gold but gems just sounds greedy.

I like the sound of 8 clans a bit more, search times should not be that long like that (I think) and the duration would be shorter. But really awesome idea it sounds a lot of fun and quite competitive

Superb idea, it would make clan wars more challenging... But before they keep this they should fix the war search problem first si that teams participating should be evenly matched.

That's all i have to say... Im speechless

the only adjustment i would make is either never ending ... or do a day break in-between wars.

then a tournament would only take 8 days or 12 days=]

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EnderRoundtable3

the only adjustment i would make is either never ending ... or do a day break in-between wars.

then a tournament would only take 8 days or 12 days=]

---

Ok say that you're clan is just getting started out with a pretty good success after starting it a few days ago. You then decide that it would be a good idea to start your clans first tournament (let's say at least amount of time being 12 days). So, turns out a few days into your tournament after your clan has one the first match, you realize there are so in clan issues you need to fix, turns out its to late to do anything about it, your clan is a bust. So this brings up the question what can you do now?

Of course there are some options:
1. Forfeit button (Forfeit tournament).
2. Set higher standards for war (Instead of at least 10 vs. 10 maybe at least 25 vs 25 or something like that).

And there are other issues as well. Let's now say that the alternative route to your clan is it isn't a complete bust but after the first round when you win you lose members, and instead of a 45 vs 45 for example you then end up with a 40 vs 40. Unfortunate this is unfixable it seems like, at an individual players prospective at least.

Of course there is the option of doing something that doesn't involve players that may fix this (Maybe clan village), but this has its own issues and it's been suggested before, but yet SC hasn't added this in yet :/


Just trying to bring up the issues that would need to be resolved to this idea :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by iDANglin

Hey all! So after participating in a couple dozen wars with my clan, Pacific Group, and doing my usual playing too much CoC and being on the forums, I've been wondering what the next feature addition should be that I haven't already seen suggested. Some amazing proposals have already been made, including Mastermind's ideas and others' ideas for daily/weekly/monthly quests and for a more personalized in game profile with more stats. I'd like to make another suggestion related to Clan Wars, Clan Wars Tournaments! The sound of this idea is not super impressive or imaginative at first I know, but I'd like to share what I've come up with. Hope you like it! The short concept of this idea is in red, details are in green. If you find possible issues with this idea, refer to the bottom of this post which discusses possible solutions to mentioned issues. If you think of an issue with this idea that has not been addressed please comment! Please hold your vote until after considering the idea fully! If you can't read, I'm sorry.

Clan Wars: Tournaments!

-16 clans participate in a Single-elimination tournament.
-4 week long event. One war per week until eliminated.
-Week 1: 1st set of wars begins the moment all 16 clans are matched and put into the bracket.
-Week 2: 2nd set of wars begin between the 8 winning clans.
-Week 3: 3rd set of wars begin between the top 4.
-On week 4, the top 2 clans war for gold (1st place) and silver (2nd place). The other 2 clans who lost in week 3 also war for (bronze) and 4th (maybe next time!)
-Along with the usual loot bonus for each war win, the top 3 clans are awarded a tournament loot bonus according to their placing! The rest of the clans also receive a very small tournament loot just as you get from losing a war.
-Each war won in the tournament will be added to the clan's "Wars Won" stat. A new stat "Tournaments Won" could be added.


Clan Wars: Tournament Details:
-When a clan decides to partake in a Clan Wars Tournament, a co-leader or leader presses the war button just as if to start a regular war
.http://i61.tinypic.com/rb0g7k.jpg
-If the clan is not currently in a war, the co-leaders/leader will see the option to start a war and another button to start a tournament.
-If a clan is in a regular war, they cannot start a tournament until after the regular war has finished.
-The war map in a tournament is the same visually with the exception of an extra page that shows the tournament bracket. So when a player presses the War button, he/she can view the page of his/her clan's base map, the page of the enemy base map, and also the new third page of the war bracket.
-Once a clan is in a war tournament, each weekly tournament war's prep day will begin at the same time of the same day each week (ex: War tournament is matched on Tuesday at 6:00pm. All 4 wars will be on Tuesday at 6:00pm.)
-Clans may still take part in regular wars during a tournament. However, only one war may take place at a time.
-Clans cannot start a regular war during a weekly tournament war.
-Clans may start a regular war after their weekly tournament war has ended.
-Clans will no longer be able to start a regular war if the next tournament war begins within the next 48 hours.
-Maintenance breaks add time to when the next tournament war will begin to avoid war overlapping.
-When a clan loses a tournament war, that clan cannot start another tournament until after the current one has completely concluded. The button "Start A Tournament" will be replaced with "View Tournament" until the current tournament is done. The only exception is if your clan loses in the semi-finals as that clan still wars during the last week for 3rd or 4th place.

- BONUS LOOT: After each tournament war, clans will receive the normal bonus loot, win or lose. After the last week's wars have concluded, an additional bonus will be given as follows:
-1st place: 15% of the bonus loot received in all wars in the tournament
-2nd place: 10% of the bonus loot received in all wars in the tournament
-3rd place: 5% of the bonus loot received in all wars in the tournament
-4th-16th places: Small bonus x amount of wars won

- BONUS LOOT EXAMPLE: iDANglin's clan finishes their first clan tournament! In EACH war won, iDANglin earned 800,000 gold, 800,000 elixir, and 4,400 dark elixir in from war bonus loot. Here is how much of a tourney bonus iDANglin would receive depending on his clan's placement:
-1st place: 4 wins= 480,000 gold, 480,000 elixir, 2,640 dark elixir.
-2nd place: 3 wins= 240,000 gold, 240,000 elixir, 1,320 dark elixir.
-3rd place: 3 wins= 120,000 gold, 120,000 elixir, 660 dark elixir.
*Note: These bonuses would be given with the loot of the last war. For example if iDANglin's clan came in first, iDANglin would receive 1,280,000 gold, 1,280,000 elixir, and 7,040 dark elixir upon winning the last war.

Participation Regulations: Rules for participating in a Clan War Tournament are similar to regular wars. When viewing the clan roster, another symbol exists for tournaments next to the symbol for regular wars.
-The current symbol for a player's regular war eligibility is of two swords crossing in front of a shield. The symbol for tournaments will be a (insert your awesome symbol idea here and in your comment).
-Tourney symbol is non-existent if the player is an extra member at the bottom of the clan.
-Tourney symbol is grey with a red loading bar if the member has a regular war or tourney war in progress in another clan.
-Tourney symbol is a shiny bronze if the player's clan came in 3rd place in the last tourney and the member is eligible.
-Tourney symbol is a shiny silver if the player's clan came in 2nd in the last tourney and the member is eligible.
-Tourney symbol is a shiny gold if the player's clan came in 1st in the last tourney and the member is eligible.
-Tourney symbol's color stays until placing in the next tourney.
-During a Tournament war, both symbol's will disappear until that war is over. This means that a player cannot be participating in a regular war in one clan while participating in a tourney war in another clan.
-Only one war can take place at a given time by a player or a clan.
-Again, a player and clan can participate in regular wars between the weekly tourney wars. With 5 days between the end of one tourney war and the beginning of the next, a player/clan can squeeze in 2 regular wars between tourney wars!
-If a clan has been knocked out of a tourney, that clan and it's members cannot participate in another tourney until the current one has concluded. HOWEVER, the clan and its members can participate in regular wars, even during the times of the tourney's other wars. This means that clans can still war almost continuously regardless of tournament performance!


Known Issues With This Idea: (Need Ideas To Fix These Ideas!)
-To make the tournament fair, the matchmaking would have to be at least as tight of parameters in searching for potential clans to match with as in regular clan wars. This means that matching all 16 clans together would take much longer than regular Clan Wars on average
-Possible solutions:
-Have the option to search for a Tournament only available at certain times of the week so that clans are searching at the same times.
-When a clan searches for a Tournament, instead of the tournament starting the moment all 16 clans are matched, the tournament could begin on a specific day the following week. For example let's say Tournaments start every hour. Your clan begins a tournament search on Monday at #:##. No matter the time of day, the matchmaking system will determine a set day and time after all 16 clans have been matched up. The determined starting time would be at least a couple of days ahead of the moment the matching is completed. This would allow the matchmaking system ample time to find 16 well matched clans, and in the mean time each clan can do regular wars without worrying about interruption. This means that no matter how long the matchmaking takes, clans can continue warring as they please with no complications!


Your feedback would be appreciated! I'm looking forward to communicating with you forumers to help me improve this idea. Especially looking for help with creating pictures to help make this and my other idea threads easier on the eyes since I know there's a lot of text! Thank you for reading :D


Thanks for helping me improve my thread:
Dan93
Isaacium

And everyone else who commented!

---

Good Idea!

I love this idea from first I came into clash.
I wrote two posts from it, today and yesterday.
I think if we have leagues instead of tournament is better.
means all clans match with each other.

-we have 10 clans in league.

-leagues just start in first day of each month. (only in first day of each month the button of Search League is available.)

-each clan have 9 match in league. (we have 9 week in each league.)

-each week take 2days, and we have one day rest between weeks. (each league take 27 days.)

-we don't have normal clan wars among leagues. just if a clan not in a league can have normal clan wars.

-if a clan enter in a league, they have 2 new pages in clan war part. one of the pages shows the ranking table of the league, including 10 clans and their points and ranking. they can see each clans page by clicking on their record in the table. second page show the detail of the all matches in league. Results, scheduling and ... will be show in this page.

-each win in league have 3points and loos 0 points. for draw 1 or 2 points for each clan.
at end if 2 or more clans have equal point, the difference between earned and loos stars of those clans in all wars could specified the better clan.

I hope in future we have more exciting clash of clans!

Wow oh my gawd that was so epic! Glad somebody bumped it so i can read

nice idea .. looking forward to it.. moderators of supercell, we hope not to miss this thread

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jtkeating

This is a great idea I would love to see implemented, however, I agree that the time is too long. Also, there could be a problem with not being able to hold enough war loot if you got the tournament and last war bonus at the same time.

EDIT: I also think many clans would have trouble keeping all/most of thier members for a whole month so is it a new war lineup each time or...?

---

No Problem.
I give an example: if tournament start for clans with 40 member, we have 2plan for this problem:
1- we can fine those clans that members leaves from their, and carry on all wars with 40 member.
2- we can have dynamic system, for example after leaves some members, clan A will have 38 members, this clan can participate in wars with 35 members with other clans.

Bump..... Yw :)

@ Any SC representative, why isn't some version of this not been implemented yet? And where are the clan war leaderboards????

Awesome idea. But I can see challenges for SC to produce a decent matchmaking method for it. Since clan on clan wars already suffer from taking to long or getting even matches the setting up of a tournament would be that much harder.

Great idea. I was also propsoing one. I didnt know there was already one existing topic.
Anyway, see my suggestions.
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...an-tournaments.

I think it will be much exciting if it is scheduled per month or twice a month. Clan leaders should be submitting entry if they would want to join. (And leader will choose who among the members to join,unlike on the war. In a war, everybody should be joining, imagine that your country is in a war, will you left them behind???)
Like tournament of other games, preschedule instead of making it like war search.
Also, the system should have ample time to match the entries/clan. There will be different division depending on the strength and sizes of the clans.
Another one is, i think finishing the torunament for 1 month is too long.
I think 1 week should be enough.
1 round round per day so at maximum there will be a 128 clans per division.
In case of less 128 clans in a division, there will be some clan waiting (i forgot the term in a single elimination match)
And maybe 1 attack per member, while 2 attacks for the leader or maybe a designated clan hero.
Also,this way an active clan will most likely match with another active clan in the 3rd or 4th round onwards.
SC may decide that there will be an entry fee to join the tournament. Gold, elixir or maybe gems.
But of course there should be a bonus loot for the champion clan. Perhaps gems as well.
Another thing, maybe two kinds of tournament one base on atack and defense power, while the other base on trophies ( i think that would be fun, if a clan doesnt want that kind of match up, they can just decide not to join)
Let me know your thoughts.

I like the idea of clan war tournament. It adds excitement and new challenge to veteran players. I just have 1 point to discuss about it . It would be to long for a tournament to last 1 or 2 months . It is better if a round of 16 clans winner advances to the next round be played every 3 days so that it would take only 2 weeks for it to finish. Then you can rest after the tournament and not to engage in any war or tournament. Tournament win record is also nice to be seen on your clan record together with war win record. The more tournament chanpion record you have the better standing your clan have.

Good idea and i like it. Only the time spend is the issue for me 1 or 2 months for tournament will be too long. 2 weeks would just be enough for me and if the clan wants another tournament they can join again or if they want just 1 war its their option to choose.

Hope supercell can make this . I know they can

Is the op still playing?

This is a great idea with good details and I would love to see something like this added in an update soon to make wars a lot more fun and competitive. I think 1 war a week for all clans in the tournament would be perfect because a tournament loot bonus might be overused if it you could do tournaments in less than a month. My suggestions on this are you have buttons on the side of the war map during every tournament war-even if youre not in Week 2,3 and 4- to watch other wars in the tournament. So, for example, in Week 1, you might be War 2, and you have buttons on the side of the war map to watch wars 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8-Although, this might be hard for SC to make. In Week 2, you are War 1, and can watch wars 2, 3, and 4. In Week 3, you are eliminated from Tournament but can still watch Wars 1 and 2 and in Week 4 you can still watch War 1. I think also you can't do other wars during a Tournament because that'd be too complicated for SC to make happen, and if you are eliminated from a Tournament you still can't do a war, which is the price you pay for being eliminated, and the risk you take when doing a tournament. I agree with pretty much everything else you said.

Hi guys, I found this thread which is a good idea.

Earlier i just posted a thread on CoC Championship. Its like football (soccer as for American) FIFA World Cup or Chess FIDE world title's format.

The idea is to have it quarterly, half yearly or yearly event. This to spice up the current season league, Top 3 clans league and Clan Wars league.

Here is my thread on it,
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...=1#post3187589

Your honest feedback is much appreciated, thank you in advance. :)

Great idea. I definitely like the idea of having it start a certain so there is ample search time.

I still absolutely love this thread and it needs to be implemented! SUPERCELL!!!

Its fine, but you need to add consequences so people dont always do tournaments

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nobody17

Its fine, but you need to add consequences so people dont always do tournaments

---

The down side is there is a bigger chance of losing. I think it is well balanced.

Is this the kind of thread you guys were wanting?

i cant read.

This sounds awesome! You put a lot of great ideas together on this and the only thing I would suggest is to cut the number of clans in the tournament to 8. The tournament could take place over six days ( one day for preparation and one day for war for each of the three rounds). I actually just posted about this on another thread, but I think 8 clans could be matched up better ( and probably more quickly) than 16

This is a great idea. Right after mastermind's quests haha.

I haven't been on this forum like I used to. Thanks for the replies everyone! I'll update and change the OP when I get the chance!!

Do you think it could be possible for the tournament's winner to receive a small gem reward?

Bring a great post out of the grave

Good job with this thread. Very well explained. I hope this will be implemented into the game.

the only thing i would change is it taking a month for the tournament to finish. two wars per week would be better, then it would only take 2 to 3 weeks instead 4 to 5. in a month our clan could gain or lose 4 to 6 players and that would be significant in the final round of tournament if we had lost a top player, or had a few people that could not attack becuase they were no longer in the clan. or new members not being able to war would discourage them from staying in our clan. either way i am 1000% for this idea! more pressure, more loot more coc!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dan93

Bring a great post out of the grave

---

Lol thank you Dan. I suppose I should fix this idea as I said I was going to do over half a year ago.. Lol!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Katsukic7

Good job with this thread. Very well explained. I hope this will be implemented into the game.

---

Thanks! Appreciate it. This idea needs some changes, especially with this upcoming update. The wars should probably be back to back.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CaptainBowhay

the only thing i would change is it taking a month for the tournament to finish. two wars per week would be better, then it would only take 2 to 3 weeks instead 4 to 5. in a month our clan could gain or lose 4 to 6 players and that would be significant in the final round of tournament if we had lost a top player, or had a few people that could not attack becuase they were no longer in the clan. or new members not being able to war would discourage them from staying in our clan. either way i am 1000% for this idea! more pressure, more loot more coc!

---

I completely agree with you! I will make some improvements here hopefully later today!

Ill bump this,

some logistical issues with how long it takes and how it matches people up but the general idea of a clan war tourney that any clan can participate in is really interesting! in order to get around the searching issues they could have it so that you can search for a war and a tournament simultaneously.. then if a war is found the tourney search keeps going untill you are placed, after all 16 have been placed all are locked out of the ability to start new wars and 48 hours later the tourney starts (giving time for any active wars to expire)..

this way you can have a search that may take a few days to complete that doesnt tie the clan down the whole time waiting for a tourney while still letting them happen frequently.

of course once a tourney is on nobody can war till it is over.. part of the punishment for losing the clan tourney is you are locked out of war for the duration :p this will offset the gained loot by the winners with the lost loot of not being in a normal war by the losers.

Supercell please make this happen!

Amazing idea. However I would shorten the length of the ttournament Two weeks of tournament. Two attacks a week.

Also in current clan wars the clans have to be similar in strength however for the tournament they don't have to be as much similar only maybe just a little bit similar. Of course we can't have a clan full of th lvl 7's go against th lvl 10's but maybe a clan full of th lvl 7's can go against a clan half th lvl 7's and half th lvl 8's.

why not just make one pre war set up time for the whole tourney, goes like this:

day1: Prep Day
day2: war between clans at bottom of latter
day 3: war between winners of first round
day 4: war between winners of second round
day 5: war for 1st 2nd 3rd 4th

Now the whole tourney is less than a week (could add day 6 and 7 depending on size of tourney?) the winning clan gets most loot, everyone else gets some multiplier of loot based on placement of the clan war, and have a round robbin where on day 3 4 and 5 the losing clans from each of the previous days war eachother for bottom placements. if the loot is balanced right the total gains overall should be similar to just normal wars (maybe a touch higher) but with the losing clans below 3rd place getting less than if they had just normally warred and the winning clans getting more.. also exp would be involved now and based on placement.

I think this is a logical next step for the clan war system and would be tons of fun!

I think I said I would update the OP about 9 months ago to make improvements... Fail! Sorry all, I'll make changes to it asap

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kmsoji

Ill bump this,

some logistical issues with how long it takes and how it matches people up but the general idea of a clan war tourney that any clan can participate in is really interesting! in order to get around the searching issues they could have it so that you can search for a war and a tournament simultaneously.. then if a war is found the tourney search keeps going untill you are placed, after all 16 have been placed all are locked out of the ability to start new wars and 48 hours later the tourney starts (giving time for any active wars to expire)..

this way you can have a search that may take a few days to complete that doesnt tie the clan down the whole time waiting for a tourney while still letting them happen frequently.

of course once a tourney is on nobody can war till it is over.. part of the punishment for losing the clan tourney is you are locked out of war for the duration :p this will offset the gained loot by the winners with the lost loot of not being in a normal war by the losers.

---

Thanks for your thoughts! I was already planning on changing the details around, particularly the length of the tourney. Especially now with clan levels it makes way more since to have the wars back to back, and maybe even with shorter prep days and war days to appeal to those that want to war faster?

Bump... Always loved the idea of it, and for the smaller clans there will be issues, as well as the wait time for the tourney. Besides that, great idea:thumbsup:

This ideas looks very interesting. Quite do-able. It would be long, and a bit complicated, probably it should be reserved for high level people / clans.

Maybe if qulifying clans could select 10 representatives, and the tournaments were all 10x10?

Everyone in the tournament should be able to see every battle. Indeed, just let everyone see every battle.

i really hope this idea works!

good idea , but I think it can't work and here is why:
1)how long would it take for supercell to match 16clans like a whole day? Two days?
2)with just clanwars there already a lot of mismatches.
imagine how this would be with 16 clans...
The range between the best clan and the worsth would be to big ..
sOrry for my english but you know what i mean

Online poker plays both normal and turbo games....if your clan is "casual" about wars then one a week would work, but if your clan is "hyper active" in the war department then back to back works, leaders could choose... And instead of loot bonus for overall win maybe give gems to the clan otherwise superb idea

Still hoping for this to become a feature. I'll be as interested in the game as I was when clan wars first came out if this is added!

I would do this, but a reward *COUGH* GEMS *COUGH* would need to be in it. Also clans with the same level should fiht clans the same level.

That sounds like a marvelous idea. I know I'd be up for it

Couple points:

The time is WAY too long in the tournament, especially given how many players can leave clans and come back at any time.. If you have a meltdown or something over a month you could be hosed. Anyway, if I were to implement it, I would have it be an opt in/opt out type thing that always starts at the same time, and each tournament would last a week. Basically, you'd opt into the tournament on Friday (whether you're in a war or not doesn't matter, see timeline idea). Everyone would opt into the tournament with 30 players, because multiples of 5s between 10-50 is just way too many possibilities and would really screw up matchmaking. Then, Supercell is going to add up the offensive and defensive rankings of the 30 selected players at, say, midnight on Saturday morning, and then go down the list in terms of strengths from top to bottom.. weighting the top more heavily than the bottom so people don't manipulate matchmaking with low TH4s whose attacks aren't needed to increase their odds of victory. Some formula similar to what they use now, but obviously it'd have to be modified. Anyway, you have two days to prepare and get to see the bases of all of the bases in your bracket during prep day. The CC troops you insert would stay for the duration of the tournament, and of course you will not be able to see the attacks done on your opposition in later rounds. Anyway, round of 16 on Monday, round of 8 on Tuesday, round of 4 on wednesday, and then one last prep day on Thursday for the finals, and then the finals on Friday. Once you're eliminated, you're able to do regular wars, and all clans who have opted in can finish their war on the tournament prep day.

Thanks for all the replies! I apologize for neglecting this thread for a while. I meant to edit the OP (especially the length of tournament times) about half a year ago. I suck lol. I'll try to get around to changing it soon since this thread is still catching attention. Thanks again for your feedback!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by thebuch4

Couple points:

The time is WAY too long in the tournament, especially given how many players can leave clans and come back at any time.. If you have a meltdown or something over a month you could be hosed. Anyway, if I were to implement it, I would have it be an opt in/opt out type thing that always starts at the same time, and each tournament would last a week. Basically, you'd opt into the tournament on Friday (whether you're in a war or not doesn't matter, see timeline idea). Everyone would opt into the tournament with 30 players, because multiples of 5s between 10-50 is just way too many possibilities and would really screw up matchmaking. Then, Supercell is going to add up the offensive and defensive rankings of the 30 selected players at, say, midnight on Saturday morning, and then go down the list in terms of strengths from top to bottom.. weighting the top more heavily than the bottom so people don't manipulate matchmaking with low TH4s whose attacks aren't needed to increase their odds of victory. Some formula similar to what they use now, but obviously it'd have to be modified. Anyway, you have two days to prepare and get to see the bases of all of the bases in your bracket during prep day. The CC troops you insert would stay for the duration of the tournament, and of course you will not be able to see the attacks done on your opposition in later rounds. Anyway, round of 16 on Monday, round of 8 on Tuesday, round of 4 on wednesday, and then one last prep day on Thursday for the finals, and then the finals on Friday. Once you're eliminated, you're able to do regular wars, and all clans who have opted in can finish their war on the tournament prep day.

---

i greatly appreciate your comment, thank you! I shortened the tourney time (finally). I will add details about CWC contents and Opting in/Opting out.

YAAASSSSS, Supercell should add this.............................................. .....though this thread is 1 year old and is still not in the game. Your idea has little hope;(

Not to bag your idea its kinda great but, after the work they have put into clan wars like the perks ect i think this would take the shine out of regular clan wars and would make it alot harder to find a war to begin with. Perhaps there would be a way around this but in my opinion it is probably a too big a project to add to the game :-/

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JollyRogdawg

Not to bag your idea its kinda great but, after the work they have put into clan wars like the perks ect i think this would take the shine out of regular clan wars and would make it alot harder to find a war to begin with. Perhaps there would be a way around this but in my opinion it is probably a too big a project to add to the game :-/

---

Appreciate it! When I made this thread a year ago I figured it was way too early for something like this to be implemented. Even though I haven't been trying to keep this thread alive, it somehow is, which leads me to believe that the idea is applicable. Even though the idea is old now, Clash could still implement it I think. As for it being harmful to regular wars, you are into something there. This game has so many players and clans though that I think it is very do-able. There are possible solutions to this concern as well. For instance if tournaments make regular wars harder to match, tournaments could take place less commonly, such as once a month at a certain time.

They'll put this in the game with that many agrees.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kimbap

They'll put this in the game with that many agrees.

---

Thanks I sure hope they do at some point! If they do it could be soon or in a year lol. Who knows

You have my vote :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AnthonyVince

You have my vote :)

---

Appreciate it!

Amazing idea, I love it :D
But the time is too long, and too many clans in the tournament , maybe cut it back to 8 clans per tournament? Or the option to have a 8 or a 16 or a 32 (I know that is a lot, but I'm just throwing out ideas) clan tournament.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheCoveredMan2

Amazing idea, I love it :D
But the time is too long, and too many clans in the tournament , maybe cut it back to 8 clans per tournament? Or the option to have a 8 or a 16 or a 32 (I know that is a lot, but I'm just throwing out ideas) clan tournament.

---

Having different size options would be nice : ) as for the time in general, the wars are actually shorter, catering to the more active war clans that would want quicker wars anyways : )

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by iDANglin

If this idea was added as is, clans could still do normal wars in between each weekly tournament war : )

---

if this was the case, then yes... I would be completely for it. We war consecutively without any hassle apart from maybe 1/2 changes in the line-up. I wouldn't think it to be fair if someone didn't get to participate in wars for a month because they are away for a weekend? At least this way we could opt them out of the tournament, but still in CWs?

Also (and I'm sorry if it's been already mentioned, but I'm not reading 11 pages!), i know SC don't like to hand gems out, but like the trophy leagues: could 1st, 2nd and 3rd get 300, 150 and 50 gems respectively??

finally, with the introduction of clan levels... Maybe some extra XP and something visible on the shield representing tournament wins??

Correction... 19 pages!!

one more thing as i JUST read page 18... I think the tornament should only last 1 week BUT there shouldn't be a button to pick and choose when you do a tournament. There should simply be a place where a clan can opt in/out of the next tournament... It will say something like "CW tournament matchmaking begins in 18d 6hrs" and then however it works has a day to split up the clans into FAIR groups of 16/32 whatever...

1. You have to put a limit on clan war tournaments maybe like 2 a month so no one keeps starting them to get bonus loot.
2. 16 clans seems too many, maybe like 8 instead?

great idea, hopefuLly it will be implemented, add a whole new aspect to wars

Just like a football league system, nice......16 clan vs 16 clans with slipted team minimum maybe clan players join atleast 10-15 members in each clan.....after each seasons they select the top clans and put them into the final clan war season of 16 top clans to fight the championship.......much more fun...

I really like it.

It may be covered but there is a bunch of pages and I dont have time to read it all right now. The clan castle probably will not be able to hold all the winnings for some players. Maybe It should go into storages. or just fill you CC completely automatically for all clan members.

Sounds great all for this!

In my opinion, this would be the best idea on clash of clans since the actual addition of clan wars. I love every aspect of it. The only turn off with it is if you lose first round you have to wait till the tournament is over to start a new one. But really you'd only join a tourney if you have confidence in your clan right? So I think you have a great idea! I hope to see it in the game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by slawrence22

In my opinion, this would be the best idea on clash of clans since the actual addition of clan wars. I love every aspect of it. The only turn off with it is if you lose first round you have to wait till the tournament is over to start a new one. But really you'd only join a tourney if you have confidence in your clan right? So I think you have a great idea! I hope to see it in the game.

---

Maybe have a losers bracket so you don't have to do nothing.

Clan war tournaments is a great idea. I know that supercell is hosting a Nordic war tournament later this year which is gonna be live streamed.

I've been a fan of this thread and the idea for a while now. One thing I would like to point out though that could make the idea a little more sharper per say.
So I was reading over the thread and I realized something. It would make it a lot more of a competition if all 16 of the clans were active. And you would expect that hopefully. But then that also bring up the question, what if it isn't like that? Where all the clans that you were matched up against weren't active (even possibly your own).
Then I came up with an idea myself. It's kind of like the "You need 10 players to participate in a regular clan war" sort of deal, or even more like when a wig creator has a certain limit on the amounts of posts you have before requesting a sig. But instead of that I came up with the idea of a certain limit you could put on for the amount of wars a clan has been in to make sure they're an active clan.
This way you know that it won't be a wash or too easy to beat of a clan. Or if you're on the other end of it, then it won't be a complete failure on your part when considering the people you had in your clan.
Thanks for reading this, hope it gives you a idea off of what I was saying above.

The main issue in this kind of wars is the long time you need to be available for war. Also it will impact the upgrading of the village.

I think the idea to have monthly competition for all clans where the clan which got best maximum number of stars should be the winner, and they should be rewarded some GEMS. note: if the war is 10 player and then got 30 stars that means they are better then war of 20 player and they got 40 stars.

Great idea but if a clan loses in the first war and they can't join a tournament for another week would they just have to wait it out or could they do normal wars still?

Also matchmaking would be terrible unless they had set times. I'm thinking like every week by a certain time you must decide if you are going to be in a tournament next week, the matchmaking system would then pair up all of the clans who said they wanted to participate in it making there be less mismatches.

I wonder if a 8 clan war would be better because then they could do the normal 1 day prep/1 day attack and it would also give more even matchups.

Can't believe this still isn't in game

This will be amazing! more a challenge for your clan!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by iDANglin

Thanks guys!

---

yeah its very interesting!!!!))))))))

I like the idea, couple suggestions. (I'm sure have been repeated )

duration should be shortened a bit, maybe instead of 16 clan tourney swap for smaller more frequent 4-8 clan tournaments .

The players selected for the tourney are obviously locked in and unable to be subbed out.

Clans can view only the scores of other battles going on.

Tourney winner should be of best WIN record. NOT accumulated stars. ( saw suggestions )
some wars come down to the wire and some bases are ignored in order to win, also some battles just produce few stars.

This would make my favourite game 10 times better really hope it get put in

Yes!!! I support this idea

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Avery99

I've been a fan of this thread and the idea for a while now. One thing I would like to point out though that could make the idea a little more sharper per say.
So I was reading over the thread and I realized something. It would make it a lot more of a competition if all 16 of the clans were active. And you would expect that hopefully. But then that also bring up the question, what if it isn't like that? Where all the clans that you were matched up against weren't active (even possibly your own).
Then I came up with an idea myself. It's kind of like the "You need 10 players to participate in a regular clan war" sort of deal, or even more like when a wig creator has a certain limit on the amounts of posts you have before requesting a sig. But instead of that I came up with the idea of a certain limit you could put on for the amount of wars a clan has been in to make sure they're an active clan.
This way you know that it won't be a wash or too easy to beat of a clan. Or if you're on the other end of it, then it won't be a complete failure on your part when considering the people you had in your clan.
Thanks for reading this, hope it gives you a idea off of what I was saying above.

---

This is great! Thanks for the addition Avery!