Printable View
When you are attacking someone there is a percentage predictor on how your set up compares to theirs so you have a slightly better educated guess on how well you will do. Also in clan wars the percentage shows next to the persons name. And if the percentage is 100 then you can't attack them in clan wars.
I feel like this would be extremely complicated to code for SC,but I don't know how to code,so I'm kinda neutral on this.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cfisher
My ideas would be to compare the level of the defensive towers and troop levels. Not taking into account all the other small things
Hmm. It would be difficult to code, but not too difficult, I doubt it's that hard to just compare troop level to defence levels, however there is one flaw.
- People may get encouraged to raid less if their percentage of winning is constantly low, ruining the whole purpose of the game.
Very true... but it's pretty much only going to be effective for the newer people. The newer people could use a sor of guide like that. I'm at TH 6 and I know pretty much who I can and can't attack
Mate u win the battle not on your troops totals vs their totals it all depends on the way you put troopsQuote:
Originally Posted by Cfisher
I can use the same troops to attack the same base and get 0% on one and 80-100% on the other this would be impossible to predict it depends on your strategy
It wouldn't compare the amount or the type of troops you are using just the level of the defenses at your base and the level you have your troops upgraded too. It wouldn't be a win or loss predictor just to see how you compare to them. It isn't a crutch to see who you can and can't attack but just a little bit more information to have. More of like an estimate, not a thing to say yes you are going to win them or no you aren't. It isn't a strategy calculator. I could attack someone with all wall breakers and I wouldn't win. The way someone attacks isn't possible to calculate. But a level 5 cannon can easily be compared to a level 5 cannon. Is just a nice way to see how you compare to them. It wouldn't be a bunch of little percentages over each defense but a overall comparison at the top.
Then this is uselessQuote:
Originally Posted by Cfisher
You should already know who you can and can't attack that's not what this is about. It wouldn't be a end all be all attack guide there are apps and guides and videos for that. Knowledge is great, learn. That's more of what this is about. Having a way to compare your levels to theirs. It would be a way to also prevent really high levels from attacking the lower levels. At 100% you will not be able to attack them. The trophies make it so people are attacking at their levels, but what about the people that purposely lower their trophies to take advantage of the lower people. It would also be a way to make clan wars more when because then people would have to attack someone that is in their ballpark instead of the top guys being able to use their attack and 3 star the lower people. That also makes it so the lower people have no one to attack. Its a way for the game to be able to even things out but also just a little bit of knowledge too.
More even*