Clan Wars Loot

Good idea, but higher people needs more loot. So at the end of the war, they need to look at the level of each player.
EDIT:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vineetnayak28

Let the clan leader has a switch to decide between capitalism and communism.

In capitalism you keep what you loot. i.e. current loot system

In communism all the loot goes into a pot then gets divided according to rank first. So say there are 4 people in the clan( I know not possible but I dont want to math more) and there is 10mil loot total in the pot then
1st rank gets 4mil.
2nd gets 3mil.
3rd gets 2mil.
4th gets 1mil.
But wait 2nd didnt get any stars and 3rd got only 3 stars !
So 2nd does not get anything (3mil * 0/6 stars)
and 3rd gets only (2mil * 3/6 stars) 1 mil.
So basically nobody gets the 4 mil and it is lost.

---

like your idea, but a little bit different. With 1 or 2 stars you get 1 mil instead of 3mil. with 3-4 stars you'll get 2mil and with 5-6 stars you'll get 3mil.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dirkvs

Good idea, but higher people needs more loot. So at the end of the war, they need to look at the level of each player.
EDIT:

like your idea, but a little bit different. With 1 or 2 stars you get 1 mil instead of 3mil. with 3-4 stars you'll get 2mil and with 5-6 stars you'll get 3mil.

---

That is exactly my formula. first all loot is divided by rank in war. so in clan of 5 the loot is divided as follows
5+4+3+2+1 = 15
your allocated loot = (total loot /15) * your rank
so higher players will get more loot if rank 5 gets 1 mil rank 1 gets 5mil.

But you wont get the entire amount allocated to you, this will depend on stars 1/3rd for every 2 stars or
your final loot = (allocated loot) * (stars/6)

PS. you made me math :mad:

There is a solution for lower level players who attack up, or Town Hall pick just for war bonus, it is called "Kicking". Go to your Clan Castle, Press Clan, Select Player, and Kick Player.

Those who don't work as a clan and selfishly attack bases way higher than them, or "Town Hall Pick" just for the loot deserve the big old boot. Especially if they do it right off the bat at the beginning of the clan war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TrenchFoot

There is a solution for lower level players who attack up, or Town Hall pick just for war bonus, it is called "Kicking". Go to your Clan Castle, Press Clan, Select Player, and Kick Player.

Those who don't work as a clan and selfishly attack bases way higher than them, or "Town Hall Pick" just for the loot deserve the big old boot. Especially if they do it right off the bat at the beginning of the clan war.

---

Hece my suggestion to keep two modes and clan leader chooses before starting clan war search
capitalism(current)
where you get more loot and get loot even for 1 star
vs communism(new)
which will distribute loot and you get loot according to war effort (meaning most probably less loot than you won)

Suggestion:

• Defeating the player you selected will earn your X win bonus (how it is now)

• Using your attacks will give you X attack bonus (even if you lose)

• Your clan overall star % will give you X bonus
  
  • 9/10 = 90% stars
  • 40/50 = 80% stars

the reward will still be based on your townhall level so TH10 will earn more compared to TH2

Lol @ trenchfoot, nice advice.

A solution to this problem would be for the "recommended target(rt)" to be more accurate. Currently, my rt is several castles lower than my actual playing ability. Based on most humans being lazy morons, they will hit their rt without much thought, leaving lower ranked players with nothing to hit, or just hitting anything for 1 star to get resources.

With rt fixed, it is far easier to reward players based on the stars they get v their rt, with this being the hit that earns them the most resources in a 3 star battle. Going higher or lower than the rt only gives resources for 3 stars.

Basically, it all depends on the rt being adjusted by the coders to something far more accurate.