I need to learn your secret. :)
To answer the OP's question... I like the bottom one better, but that's just my opinion.
Printable View
I got exact the same problem like the OP
What i dont like at the bottom base is that the heroes are not in the center..
There is only the canon to change with one hero but whats with the 2nd one?
The top one is very popular and weak against barch imo.
Im atm with ringus but will change to Cloud whisky because of my league ;)
I would go for:
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ight=felkaroth
Browse through some good TH9 clans and see what their bases are like. Like The Fog, The Haze, TH9 (literally).