Four star attacks?

I often see people who get +-80% on their attacks and only get one star, whereas others get 50% and two stars
What is my solution?
-Instead of three stars, make it four!
star 1: 50%
star 2: 75%
star 3: townhall destroyed
star 4: 100%
I see this as the solution, it keeps the town hall star whilst allowing those getting +-80% and no townhall enough stars too....
Tell me what you guys think down below, AGREE? DISAGREE? WHY? WHAT WOULD YOUR SOLUTION BE?
LUKA :)

I don't really see the point. We'd all start losing heaps more trophies

I see your point, but I am targeting clan war attacks, sorry for not specifying

I've gotten 98%...1 Star. Now THAT is annoying. The dude had everything placed perfectly to deter ranged attacks on his Town Hall. Something like this would be good, but I don't think they would implement.

Edit: I ran out of time, I almost had the Town Hall destroyed.

All we need is publicity on the matter, if more and more people share there thoughts on the topic, whether in agreement or not, it might eventually catch supercell, and they may look into it, keep the replies coming guys :)

yes, time is also a problem guess, but that is a different matter in itself

I think the system they have now is fine

It wouldnt be a Huge fix but i get your point

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ABCasper

I've gotten 98%...1 Star. Now THAT is annoying. The dude had everything placed perfectly to deter ranged attacks on his Town Hall. Something like this would be good, but I don't think they would implement.

Edit: I ran out of time, I almost had the Town Hall destroyed.

---

Think I just found my opponent in the last clanwar, lol :-)

ps. I am in favor of the 4 star proposal above.

I think if it is for regular multi-player battles it would be too hard to implement and would mess up the trophy system. However, if for clan wars, I think a five star system would make more sense:
Star 1: 50%
Star 2: 75%
Star 3: All Defenses and resources
Star 4: Town hall
Star 5: 100%

And what happens if I snipe a townhall in clan wars?

I prefer the 3 star system, it makes you think about your attack, after all the game is about strategy. Do we really want them to make changes that hinder our ability to set up our bases in a more strategic manner?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sirhybrid

I think if it is for regular multi-player battles it would be too hard to implement and would mess up the trophy system. However, if for clan wars, I think a five star system would make more sense:
Star 1: 50%
Star 2: 75%
Star 3: All Defenses and resources
Star 4: Town hall
Star 5: 100%

---

I thought about it having five stars, but all defenses and resources + townhall = 100%
therefore that is two stars for one?

Guys, this whole idea was meant for clan wars, sorry if i never specified, but the four star system is for clan wars only, not multi player battles, that wouldnt make sense. Please keep this in mind when you vote and reply.
Thanks,
Luka:p

You know I always said to myself

"The person who thinks of a 4 star is the next person I'm gonna hate"

But I don't hate you...But we would be losing more trophies if we got a additional star

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JustElisha

And what happens if I snipe a townhall in clan wars?

---

one star out of four

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LukeClashOfClans

You know I always said to myself

"The person who thinks of a 4 star is the next person I'm gonna hate"

But I don't hate you...But we would be losing more trophies if we got a additional star

---

This concept is for clan wars as previously mentioned....

this is idea is like a double edged sword.

bumpidy bumpidy bump, what you guys think?