Clan war new program proposal

I appreciate all the thought you've put into this, but I'm not a huge fan of the idea. No clan should ever surrender! Even when my clan is taking a beating (rare, but it happens), we do our best and try to learn from the experience. I would quit any clan where the leader just up and decides it's time to quit just because we "appear" outclassed, or find ourselves behind.

Why should the winning clan suffer a loot penalty because the other team wants to quit? Wouldn't the losing team always offer to surrender towards the end of a war?

That said, I do support the idea of allowing both clans to declare themselves "ready" before the 24-hour preparation day comes to a close. Why not let the war get started if both clans are ready to go hours into the process?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mrscheid

Don't you think you are over complicating this?

You could just create a clan wars setting where there is the standard 2 day set up, 1 day set up (12hr prep/12 hr battle) , and a 12 hr set up (6 hr prep/ 6hr battle)

---

The time shall be agreed between clans. It is decided by both individual clans not only system.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JohnnyBGood

I appreciate all the thought you've put into this, but I'm not a huge fan of the idea. No clan should ever surrender! Even when my clan is taking a beating (rare, but it happens), we do our best and try to learn from the experience. I would quit any clan where the leader just up and decides it's time to quit just because we "appear" outclassed, or find ourselves behind.

Why should the winning clan suffer a loot penalty because the other team wants to quit? Wouldn't the losing team always offer to surrender towards the end of a war?

That said, I do support the idea of allowing both clans to declare themselves "ready" before the 24-hour preparation day comes to a close. Why not let the war get started if both clans are ready to go hours into the process?

---

I think you appreciate the real battle. The rival clan can have your clan a beat. The proposal is helping the clan to find other clan which suit them. The clan surrender to other clan does not mean they are weak. The overwhelming clan can surrender to the weaker one because they are not interested to spend 2 days for a slaughter.

you may only surrender before the battle! Not during the battle or towards the end of battle.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by brewtown

This is exactly what I was looking for... a way to cancel a war if your clan is over matched! Perfect way to solve the issue.
However, can you move from angel to barbarian classification or vise versa?

---

Of course, keep refusing the surrender may change the nature of clan.

Up Up Up UP UP UP

Up Up Up Up Any comments ?

i really like this idea. it would def. be a good add on

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by oulvfi

Up Up Up UP UP UP

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by oulvfi

Up Up Up Up Any comments ?

---

First, stop bumping your own thread. Second, I'm assuming the people who like this idea haven't read it (or more likely don't understand it), because it is both incredibly complicated and pointless. I consider myself a fairly intelligent individual, but it took me 10 minutes to figure out the intricacies of this convoluted thing. More importantly, when I did, I hated most of it.

Here's the problem: your major ideas require cooperation from BOTH clans. Of course people like the possibility of getting a rematch when they're matched against a better clan, but would they "accept a surrender" if they were the better clan? Not in a million years. And this one fact collapses most of your idea, leaving only the rubble of "faster wars" in its wake.

Excellent idea, well thought out. Might even get me to like wars again.

Yea I want supercell to see this will be a lot better in clan wars