Clan Wars Shared Elixir Bank and Instant Donations [READ ALL]

If you don't support please state why.

How it works:

• clan wars elixir bank: (including dark elixir)
  
  • Players can donate elixir to clan wars bank
  • Players cannot take any elixir from clan wars bank
  • the clan wars storage bank will have a limit (depending on clan size)
  • any left over elixir will be carried over next wars
  
  
• Donating Clan War Troops:
  
  • ​When you click donate troops in clan wars screen you can select any troops you have unlocked and it will be donated instantly. (wont use your personal barracks).
  • If there's elixir in the clan wars bank then the costs will be reducted from clan wars bank
  • if there's no elixir in the clan wars bank then the elixir will be reducted from your own storage.

This is just a general idea. if you think i should change anything then feel free to give feedback e.g troops should take time to build.


Example of system:

• Bob Donates 10,000 elixir [10,000 in clan wars bank]
• Ben Donates 20,000 elixir [30,000 in clan wars bank]
• Bill donates 1 dragon that costs 25,000 [5,000 in clan wars bank left]
• Bill donates 1 more dragon costs 25,000 [0 in clan wars bank and 20,000 is taken from his own storage]

How clans can use this system (small 10 man clan):
Clan leaders can request clan mates to donate a set amount of elixir and the best clan mate to make troops e.g:

• Every clan mate needs to donate 25,000 elixir to clan bank
• X clan mate will then use the 250,000 collected elixir to build 10 dragons.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zetris

How it works:

• clan wars elixir bank:
  
  • Players can donate elixir to clan wars bank
  • Players cannot take any elixir from clan wars bank
  
  
• Donating Clan War Troops:
  
  • ​When you click donate troops in clan wars preparation day screen you can select any troops you have unlocked.
  • If there's elixir in the clan wars bank then the costs will be reducted from clan wars bank
  • if there's no elixir in the clan wars bank then the elixir will be reducted from your own.

This is just a general idea, if you think i should change anything then feel free to give feedback e.g troops should take time to build or something along the lines

---

So i'm quite not understanding this, when you donate elixir to the bank, and while its being deducted from the bank when you add troops to it, do you have to pay for the troops?

Would be a good way for lower level players to help out. Could dark elixir be donated has well?

Maybe a player could still make them like they do now and then when they donate, the elixir they spent or partial sum of elixir spent gets added back into their storages from the bank.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TurtleBandits

So i'm quite not understanding this, when you donate elixir to the bank, and while its being deducted from the bank when you add troops to it, do you have to pay for the troops?

---

if there's elixir in the clan bank then its free (payed for from elixir donaters)

example:
- X clan mate donates 100,000 elixir [adds 100,000 elixir to clan wars bank]
- You donate 1 dragon to clan wars - costs 25,000 elixir [75,000 elixir in clan wars bank left] - FREE FOR YOU

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zetris

if there's elixir in the clan bank then its free (payed for from elixir donaters)

example:
- X clan mate donates 100,000 elixir [adds 100,000 elixir to clan wars bank]
- You donate 1 dragon to clan wars - costs 25,000 elixir [75,000 elixir in clan wars bank left] - FREE FOR YOU

---

Hmm interesting, and once it runs out, you have to pay out of pocket elixir for the troops you make for donations?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TurtleBandits

Hmm interesting, and once it runs out, you have to pay out of pocket elixir for the troops you make for donations?

---

yes, so its not entirely free, but clan mates can contribute in costs for higher levels.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zetris

yes, so its not entirely free, but clan mates can contribute in costs for higher levels.

---

Nice, i like this idea, you have my support on it!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by i4mmclovin

Would be a good way for lower level players to help out. Could dark elixir be donated has well?

Maybe a player could still make them like they do now and then when they donate, the elixir they spent or partial sum of elixir spent gets added back into their storages from the bank.

---

didn't think about de, ill add it to OP. thanks for the reminder

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TurtleBandits

Nice, i like this idea, you have my support on it!

---

thank you, i hope SC supports too :)

updated thread, if any1 voted no please state why.

I really really like this idea:) and I think related to this should be an indication of who donated how much elixir and what not to see if players are committed or constantly going under the radar to get good troops. And I think this sum of elixir and DE should be displayed on the top left of the war map like the war bonus is shown in offense. Also I think troop training time is still important just to continue clash of clans generic strategy. But I really do like this :)

My only concern though is who will do the donations and I think it should be the best player in the clan.

Secondly it's important that we look at dismissing troops which was just added as a feature, I think a 50% return in elixir should be given back to the bank.

And my final thought is simply whether or not the person in the clan can donate if 1) his army camps are full (as in will the training be separate or joined) and 2) obviously how the production will work, as in if it will use that players barracks and so forth and finally 3) how does a player indicate that the troops are for the wars.

Personally the best thing I can think of is that making troops is still independent as in the strongest player/s make the troops BUT as soon as they donate they get refunded from the elixir bank that is stored :) and just one last thing obviously elixir banks are non-refundable (whether between wars or moving clans) and will stay at a balance between wars and can be added to at any stage. What would be really cool was if it was chat related, as in the message log it says 'xyz donated 50 000 elixir to clan bank'


Sorry for the long reply I just think this is a wicked idea😁 and I'm just analysing it critically so we can plan it flawlessly.

This is the same concept as giving Resources, the high levels give elixir so the low levels don't have too. The point of Clan Wars is too make it so you must spend money if you want a strong defense. Also for dark elixir, those that barely have high level drills can get so much dark elixir for their donations.

Overall I am not a huge fan of this, but hey, maybe with tweaks it could work.

Sounds like a fun concept, at first I thought it would be more like exchanging recourse, which would have made this idea ruled out. But you didn't do that. Well done.

I like this idea, as I'm only TH6 i haven't unlocked L4 troops or dragons yet so my clan discourage me from donating. With this it makes me able to make a contribution, and there's an extra place to spend all of that elixir ;)

Bank and all is not needed.

Just donating troops without training would be better.
The troops will be trained in receivers clan castle.

PS: The calculations in example are wrong

I like this.


This could add to a 'clan base,' sorta idea. Very good.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DewmHammers

This is the same concept as giving Resources, the high levels give elixir so the low levels don't have too. The point of Clan Wars is too make it so you must spend money if you want a strong defense. Also for dark elixir, those that barely have high level drills can get so much dark elixir for their donations.

Overall I am not a huge fan of this, but hey, maybe with tweaks it could work.

---

This does not count as exchanging resources given you are not directly sending resources to other players. In fact, people are paying so that you can donate. And if no one pays, then it counts as if you are just donating your own troops

This is not a problem that SuperCell needs to solve.

What happens to the leftover elixer (if any) the clan war?

Well i don't see much of a point for this, as troops Arnt all horribly expensive to make. However if you made it cost more to pay out of your storages then the bank would be more useful.

I don't like this idea, too easy to exploit for ignorant clan members.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ExcellentPosts

Bank and all is not needed.

Just donating troops without training would be better.
The troops will be trained in receivers clan castle.

PS: The calculations in example are wrong

---

thanks, just fixed the calculations.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ljungstroem

I don't like this idea, too easy to exploit for ignorant clan members.

---

care to explain the exploits?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by amd1314a

What happens to the leftover elixer (if any) the clan war?

---

updated the thread, any left overs will remain and carry over.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ethdew19

Well i don't see much of a point for this, as troops Arnt all horribly expensive to make. However if you made it cost more to pay out of your storages then the bank would be more useful.

---

if your clan is balanced e.g all high levels then its not too bad. however some clans only have 1-2 high levels and rest lowers, in that case the 1-2 higher levels will need to donate to mass low levels which is costly depending on troops.

Looks like a good idea but I dont think sc will be ok with it taking 0 training time