My Idea for Clan Hoppers/Jumpers

My idea to reduce the amount terrible acts called hopping is this.

Players can add 'tags' or a rating on players depending on their reputation. A hopper would have the tag 'hopper', as he has the reputation of a hopper on him. This would also help to recruit good members that would be a healthy addition to a clan.

To prevent abuse of this, at least 5 people must choose a tag to have it added onto that member.

For hoppers who want to change, the tags disappear after an X amount of weeks, depending on how many people voted the X tag.

This will not completely cure hoppers, but substantially reduce the amount of them. Please put some constructive criticism on this below.

*If I see a good addition for this I will add it in here

Only a problem comes here, i think.

I heard a few times, that someone got a ban on the chat, only because there are a few players who just wanne ban some players.
Not because of insult, but just for the fun of it.

And i think these players, do the same with this.



I got 2 idea`s about your tread:


1)
Maybe it can be possible, that someone automaticly can be taged in the system for
a "possible clan hopper" and "clan hopper"

"possible clan hopper" when u joined 3 clans in a week.
"clan hopper" when u joined more than 5 clans in a week.


2)
I also think a clanleader, and elders, have the possibility to put some players on ignored.
So they can not ever join that clan anymore.
But also can take someone name off that list.



These idea`s should not solve the hopping problem, but it makes it more difficult for the clan hoppers to join somewhere.



Ps. Maybe my english is not that good, sorry about that, but i try

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ThierryN

Only a problem comes here, i think.

I heard a few times, that someone got a ban on the chat, only because there are a few players who just wanne ban some players.
Not because of insult, but just for the fun of it.

And i think these players, do the same with this.



I got 2 idea`s about your tread:


1)
Maybe it can be possible, that someone automaticly can be taged in the system for
a "possible clan hopper" and "clan hopper"

"possible clan hopper" when u joined 3 clans in a week.
"clan hopper" when u joined more than 5 clans in a week.


2)
I also think a clanleader, and elders, have the possibility to put some players on ignored.
So they can not ever join that clan anymore.
But also can take someone name off that list.



These idea`s should not solve the hopping problem, but it makes it more difficult for the clan hoppers to join somewhere.



Ps. Maybe my english is not that good, sorry about that, but i try

---

^^^I like this idea better. OP has too much room for abuse.

I've been thinking about this a lot as it's been happening in our clan and it really frustrates me.

I think the solution is to simply let the clan leader set a few rules in the clan. For example:

1. Donation request rules: a new clan member cannot request troops for X many days or X many donations

2. Clan leader can block repeat hoppers specifically, without making the clan invite-only (this would help with spammers and general rabble rousers as well)

3. Clan leader can set the clan to automatically reject multiple "leaves" and "returns" in a day. If someone leaves the clan, they are out for the whole day.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ThierryN

Only a problem comes here, i think.

I heard a few times, that someone got a ban on the chat, only because there are a few players who just wanne ban some players.
Not because of insult, but just for the fun of it.

And i think these players, do the same with this.



I got 2 idea`s about your tread:


1)
Maybe it can be possible, that someone automaticly can be taged in the system for
a "possible clan hopper" and "clan hopper"

"possible clan hopper" when u joined 3 clans in a week.
"clan hopper" when u joined more than 5 clans in a week.


2)
I also think a clanleader, and elders, have the possibility to put some players on ignored.
So they can not ever join that clan anymore.
But also can take someone name off that list.



These idea`s should not solve the hopping problem, but it makes it more difficult for the clan hoppers to join somewhere.



Ps. Maybe my english is not that good, sorry about that, but i try

---

I understand it could be abused, but more than 5 people have to add the same tag. Why would 5 people come into a clan, and all put 'hopper' on the whole clan? They would need to be a team, and usually hoppers and evil elder seekers are by themselves. Maybe if 5 people don't vote the same tag in an X time period the tags the X other's votes on X would be refreshed and it would require another 5 votes again?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AngrehBard

I understand it could be abused, but more than 5 people have to add the same tag. Why would 5 people come into a clan, and all put 'hopper' on the whole clan? They would need to be a team, and usually hoppers and evil elder seekers are by themselves. Maybe if 5 people don't vote the same tag in an X time period the tags the X other's votes on X would be refreshed and it would require another 5 votes again?

---

yes, it could work, but than the developers, must find the right one.

Maybe some of the developers can reply to this, and tell us, what the possibilities are for this game.
Are our ideas good, can they fit in the game??

Please let us know

Gr T

I don't get why people care so much it's 25 arch........a few 1000 elixir so what, Get over it,


no I'm not a hopper, but when looking for a new clan I may go through 4-5 before I find 1 I like its not hopping.

i only find hopping annoying because im in a clan for a specific football team i support, so why join if you dont support them and want the banter from other fans, match nights are particularly good, so "hoppers" who dont answer to hello's etc and request 3 times in the hour its obvious to us they're not a fan or even interested in being in the clan, they tend to be kicked quickly although we do give people a chance, if they havent donated back for instance and request 3 times they're gone.

this for us is enough and its your choice to donate anything and as previosuly said its not much for 5 archers, if you doante more like 5 giants, or a dragon, in my eyes its your own fault for donating to a new member so fast.

a solution that has been thought of many times and picked apart for the reason that some clans have feeder clans and jump back and forth and people have friends in old clans they go back to, is to make it so you can join more than 2 clans in a 24 hour period.

Actually there are certain clan hoppers that just leave a clan to visit friends. Also another type of hopper just donates a bunch of troops and then leaves. I do not think that we should penalize those types of hoppers.

We only ment, that they give us the possibility that u can block them, or tag them as a hopper.
And that a leader have the possibility to give more ranks, with difrent kind of rights.

So u can controle this type of players

Some players just shouts, and leave.
I think that kind of players must be blocked.

Now u cant do a thing about it, and it can be very anoying.

So it is better to controle these players.

If u want to use that possibility, that is your choice

I think some sort of reputation system would be good