Printable View
Well the idea might be weak but..
I would like there to be a forfeit button while your in war..If your clan member isn't in war you can just press the forfeit button..
There is a flaw though..People can keep pressing the forfeit button to find a easier opponent clan...So there should be a 24 hour cool down
You may not be able to forfeit in battle day nor will you be able to forfeit after 5 hours of the preparation day
Thats no fair to the clan you are facing because they dont get to attack and get loot.
How is it not fair?They can just start a other warQuote:
Originally Posted by XavierBOSS
People will abuse this untill they find an easy opponent in clan wars and it will be hard to find clan wars. Also many clans start clan wars at certain times for important reasons. If you arnt going to win a clan war and you know it dont raid.Quote:
Originally Posted by LukeClashOfClans
Ha ha..That's why I have edited this problem before you replied :rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by XavierBOSS
I still do not believe you should be able to forfeit because supercell believes you have be matched with an even opponent and it is no fair to the other clan if they get an easy win to just lose their win. I think both clans would have to agree on a forefit.Quote:
Originally Posted by LukeClashOfClans
It should make you lose the war. If you don't want to attack and lose, don't do anything.
There was a thread like this from before.
My response was to allow a forfeit but this is how it goes down. Each member surrenders the war loot bonus that the other clan would have gotten had they attacked and won against their equal.
So if you are #10 in your clan and if by attacking you, the #10 from the opposing clan would have gotten 400k of each and 1k of DE, then to forfeit, you must pay that amount from your own loot. This is a surrender/forfeit fee.
Unless, of course, the equal already received bounty for his attacks already.
This is the only way I would approve a forfeit ability.
So you can either suck it up and finish the war, allowing the other clan to take their gold and booty, or you can surrender and offer your riches for them to leave you alone.
A better option than forfeiting is if you are losing by an unsurcomable amount you can have an option to end war early but only within last 6 hours of battle day! And both clans must accept it! So co-leaders and leaders from both clans accept the early end to the war!
2 QuestionsQuote:
Originally Posted by AxionXD
1. Does the other #10 then get the free loot you gave up or does it vanish into the abyss?
2.What happens if the other player doesn't have enough to pay off his portion of war surrender? Does the player who would receive it just get short-changed? (assuming it doesn't just disappear)
1. The winning clans #10 gets it, unless he already made his attacks and has loot coming from that. If that's the case, loot goes back into the system.Quote:
Originally Posted by i4mmclovin
2. In the interest of being relatively fair, you cant have all your loot surrendered. How about the 400k or 80% of your available loot, whichever comes first. Any loot difference will be made up by the Gods of CoC.
Quote:
Originally Posted by AxionXD
players might just start an upgrade just before forfeiting so that the gods pay it all...
I don't like the idea of being able to forfeit a war, and I think it s not needed.
For me there is a simple reason to say no to this.
If you click on the war button it reads: "Is your clan ready to go to war?"
So, either a leader or co-leader clicked the button to search, implicitly stating your clan is ready for war. As such, there should not be a single reason to forfeit. Just sit their and watch yourself being slaugthered or fight for your life ;-)