Loot Bonus for a winning defense.

Edit: Let me start off by saying this will not penalize the attacking player. It will be a Loot Bonus like the League Loot bonus when you win an attack but in this case, if your defense wins an attack it should get this bonus. Original post follow:

I think it would be a good idea to add bonus loot to a winning defense. Here me out..

This could be implemented in many different ways such as...

1. If your defense wins then you will get back half of your lost loot back as bonus loot. Winning this way is not getting starred at all.

2. Supercell just makes up percentages for each shield level. Kind of like right now if you win an attack. Winning means 0 stars again this way.

OR

3. 3 starred means 0 bonus loot.
2 starred means small 25% loot back
1 star means 40% back or so.
0 stars means 50-60% back.

These aren't the only ways it could be implemented. These are just a few I thought of. If this gets put in place it could also help with getting townhalls being put back inside the walls making them more valuable once again.

Throw some other ideas out there or let me know what you guys thinks. Thanks for reading.

The loot is just rewarded to you, right? Not actually taken from the attacking player? Either way I'm not too sure about the percentages idea. They seem too high.

Correct it's not taken away from the other player. Also they were just examples. Not set in stone of coarse.

I don't this is a great idea, as it's not really realistic to gain loot from protecting your own. you know?

I really like the idea, but it could implemented much easier if they gave a fixed defensive bonus. Kind of like the attack bonus you get when you win (based on league). It could even be the exact same as the league attack bonus. And maybe only if they get 0 stars on you?

They probably shouldn't take the bonus out of the loot the attacker gets from you, that would destroy farming for folks. But I love the idea! :)

I think there should be a loot cap that goes up with your town hall level. Also the percentages should be lowered for gold and elixir but still be higher for dark elixir just so de storage zaps aren't as devastating, but th 7s can still get the de.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GameswithWalrus

I don't this is a great idea, as it's not really realistic to gain loot from protecting your own. you know?

---

Is it realistic to get bonus loot that's not part of another's players loot? No. It's a game. Supposed to be fun. Nothing about this game is realistic.

I must write this message bigger to BUMP!

With the new update, the need for this is greater than ever

Its a good idea but the defense win bonus should be the same as the attack win bonus, getting gradually larger the better the league your in