War Draws

Printable View

June 28th, 2014
BigJay

War Draws

Hi we just had our first draw, it was a great effort by all and we was looking forward to a win via a draw using the new stats reports (we had more attack wins 23:22 and a better avg destruction 91.7%: 90.5%) but it turns out a draw is bad for everyone, the loot is halved and neither clan gains a win.

I can understand some might say we should have won more stars, hey even the max 45, but what if they had also won 45? seems unfair to both sides that when a draw happens the stats are not taken into account or that both teams get a win or that there is a record of wins/draw/losses.

Im not angry or anything, love the game, but its just been a disappointing end to a good 24hrs.

Cheers for reading,
June 28th, 2014
HeavensFace

how would you want supercell to address this problem? i did not understand your solution.
June 28th, 2014
sirhybrid

Maybe theycould have some sort of tie breaker.
September 16th, 2014
Heberus

Sorry for resurrection.

There are some tiebreakers to war? Number of attacks or something?
June 20th, 2015
Cmon

Tiebreakers solution

It might be fun to settle clan wars with a shoutout. Select a random pair of counterparts and have them attack each other. Most stars wins. If they are still tied select another pair. Or select a random group of three to attack any of the other three like a mini war. For God's sake, nobody likes a tie!
June 20th, 2015
Chris66

I like the idea of a tiebreaker but it should be like the people with the most heroic attack/defence have a face off.
June 20th, 2015
CaptainSport

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cmon

It might be fun to settle clan wars with a shoutout. Select a random pair of counterparts and have them attack each other. Most stars wins. If they are still tied select another pair. Or select a random group of three to attack any of the other three like a mini war. For God's sake, nobody likes a tie!

Can you not resurrect threads from 2014?
June 20th, 2015
darkedgex

Quote:

Originally Posted by CaptainSport

Can you not resurrect threads from 2014?

So you'd rather he started a new thread and got chewed out for not searching first?

Some people can't win.
June 20th, 2015
Champion

solution

Well with a win a clan is awarded 50xp or something right? In a tie there is no win xp awarded, so to me Supercell needs to half the win xp a clan would normally get (for a win obviously) and award that half xp to both clans and i don't think the loot should be halved either. A lot of players spend a great deal of resources for a war and donating war troops.