Maintenance of Clan Members and Defenses Tests

I was talking to the members of my clan these days. And we had an idea that everyone liked.


What would you think of a day of the week the members of the clan can attack other members of own clan? It would be very interesting, because the staff of the clan could measure the defense of mates and improve tactics for clan war.


Another idea, this is more out of necessity, should have some file or tab (for leaders and colideres only), which shows the share of each member in every war, so the leaders could analyze and remove members who are inactive wars.


I am a leader and I suffer enough of this problem, I have many members who enter the clan and do not actively participate in the wars, so I have to keep an excel spreadsheet noting who attacks in every war.

I hope you enjoy these two ideas, it would be very cool and useful, especially the second :rolleyes:

there is already a tab in the clan war menu... no need for another one

if you can attack players from your clan, players would become really good at attacking and villages would be op

Surely there already, but stats expire very fast.


I imagine that every clan should have a rule of inactivity in the war to expel members. In my clan if a member does not attack in 3 wars (performing two hits allowed), we remove this member, it is very difficult to do this with existing accounting tab, I think it could be improved, or just be a statistical added by members (number of wars / attacks made).


The attacks among the clan, would not give resources or experiences, these attacks would be in just a day marked by the leader or the server, I think everyone wants to improve their villages and clans, and thus would have an increase of interactivity between members of clans and improvement in the wars.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gothicoil

Surely there already, but stats expire very fast.


I imagine that every clan should have a rule of inactivity in the war to expel members. In my clan if a member does not attack in 3 wars (performing two hits allowed), we remove this member, it is very difficult to do this with existing accounting tab, I think it could be improved, or just be a statistical added by members (number of wars / attacks made).


The attacks among the clan, would not give resources or experiences, these attacks would be in just a day marked by the leader or the server, I think everyone wants to improve their villages and clans, and thus would have an increase of interactivity between members of clans and improvement in the wars.

---

i know i won't give resources or xp but players would be to good at attacking and they could just mimic the clan war bases of the enemy and beat them easily.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HeavensFace

i know i won't give resources or xp but players would be to good at attacking and they could just mimic the clan war bases of the enemy and beat them easily.

---

More if this would be the problem is easy, to this day the clan can not be at war. You would not find it fun to attack his companions? The people of my clan live speaking this

I agree, remove the chance to get rss and XP. Also make sure they csnt change their base while this time period is on

Being a clan leader of a mid range, small but very stable clan, I am wondering about the many times I see requests like this submitted to the forum. The issues are typically described are clanmates not attacking or clanmates not donating correct troops or clanmates levaing clan while at war.
All proposals are typically techncal solutions for problems that to me are not technical issues.

Personally I think the issue is moral.

Can we fix moral in any way in a technical solution?
I think that is not possible.

Personally, I think the only real solution is that clanleaders will keep moral highin their clan. I´m not stating you don´t try to, don´t get me wrong please, I am just stating I think the solution should never be technical.

Let me share what I do to keep moral high.
- I spent a lot of time on-lne, few hours a day
- I personally welcome anyone joining the clan, always ask about what they search for in a clan
- I always explain them what type of clan we are, how and when we play war, etc
- I never tell anyone they did it wromg, I always tell people objectively what they did and what I would prefer to see next time
- I show appreciation for what they do, even if it is putting goblins in my castle, and then explain what I would rather have
- I never recrute people in global chat, in my experience this is where you find the hoppers you don´t want
- If a clanmate in war gets 0 or 1 star I tell them they tried well, we analyze the fght and we give recommendations for the nesxt attack.

Hope it helps,
McLeo

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mcleo

Being a clan leader of a mid range, small but very stable clan, I am wondering about the many times I see requests like this submitted to the forum. The issues are typically described are clanmates not attacking or clanmates not donating correct troops or clanmates levaing clan while at war.
All proposals are typically techncal solutions for problems that to me are not technical issues.

Personally I think the issue is moral.

Can we fix moral in any way in a technical solution?
I think that is not possible.

Personally, I think the only real solution is that clanleaders will keep moral highin their clan. I´m not stating you don´t try to, don´t get me wrong please, I am just stating I think the solution should never be technical.

Let me share what I do to keep moral high.
- I spent a lot of time on-lne, few hours a day
- I personally welcome anyone joining the clan, always ask about what they search for in a clan
- I always explain them what type of clan we are, how and when we play war, etc
- I never tell anyone they did it wromg, I always tell people objectively what they did and what I would prefer to see next time
- I show appreciation for what they do, even if it is putting goblins in my castle, and then explain what I would rather have
- I never recrute people in global chat, in my experience this is where you find the hoppers you don´t want
- If a clanmate in war gets 0 or 1 star I tell them they tried well, we analyze the fght and we give recommendations for the nesxt attack.

Hope it helps,
McLeo

---

I agree with you and really understand what you mean.


In my clan we also have these rules and we are always onlines, so we have 20 members who are real friends.


But even explaining the rules and talking to new members, we face these problems, we have to understand that people lose interest and there are sporadic players.


This idea of keeping members is to facilitate the actions of leaders and help make a more united clan with people who really enjoy the game.


In my experience as a leader, I think my clan is very active, but always come new members and these are difficult to measure activity in wars.


In my opinion are minor modifications (will not weigh in the game) would really be useful for the maintenance and health of a clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gothicoil

More if this would be the problem is easy, to this day the clan can not be at war. You would not find it fun to attack his companions? The people of my clan live speaking this

---

clan members would just copy somebody on their revenge list and it would be way to easy to plan the perfect attack.
i would like to have this implemented but i think there are many flaws that need to be addressed first.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HeavensFace

clan members would just copy somebody on their revenge list and it would be way to easy to plan the perfect attack.
i would like to have this implemented but i think there are many flaws that need to be addressed first.

---

This really is a point to think about, especially for high level characters.


I do not know how hard players are in the game (I imagine there are many), but I think it would be a lot of work to copy a village just to get revenge.


More on this issue, maybe it would be nice an edition equal to that existing in the war of the clans, but with some kind of demarcation editing, maybe an edition for a particular period (1 time this week).


Perhaps a good solution for this is to edit the town in a day to confrontation and after about 3 or 4 days the attack is released. Thus the time for revenge is lost.


really is a difficult question this process of copying villages