Donating resources

Printable View

June 23rd, 2014
dirkvs

Donating resources

I know that this idea is posted already. But there is a difference. They just wanted to donate, but I want more rules for donating.
1. You can receive 100xtroop capacity
2. The donator needs to donate 10x more than the receiver receive
3. No dark elixer

Maybe we have to changes this rules.
Before you close this topic if it still is a bad idea, i want to know why it is a bad idea. I've searched for the reason but the only thing i found was: ruled out.
I hope this is a better idea, and i hope that you've understand my bad english.
June 23rd, 2014
HeavensFace

this is ruled out because players with multiple accounts would abuse it. even with your rules this would happen.
June 23rd, 2014
Evanp

Only some people would abuse the feature, but i think it would work well for the majority of the community. We could als add a set limit of like 500k resources donates
d per season so people can not abuse this feature to much
June 23rd, 2014
dirkvs

Quote:

Originally Posted by Evanp

Only some people would abuse the feature, but i think it would work well for the majority of the community. We could als add a set limit of like 500k resources donates
d per season so people can not abuse this feature to much

I agree with your idea. There will always be people abusing things. That's the same with donating troops.
June 23rd, 2014
HeavensFace

Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvs

I agree with your idea. There will always be people abusing things. That's the same with donating troops.

yes but there is a good reason behind every ruled out idea
June 23rd, 2014
dahimi

Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvs

I agree with your idea. There will always be people abusing things. That's the same with donating troops.

Oh it is? How exactly do you abuse donating troops?
June 23rd, 2014
dirkvs

Quote:

Originally Posted by dahimi

Oh it is? How exactly do you abuse donating troops?

If you've 2 accounts, you can give your noob account Minions, Hog Riders, Valkyrie or a Witch.
June 23rd, 2014
HeavensFace

Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvs

If you've 2 accounts, you can give your noob account Minions, Hog Riders, Valkyrie or a Witch.

yes but imagine donating 1 million elixir to your new account... even worst
June 23rd, 2014
kyumin2lee

Quote:

Originally Posted by Evanp

Only some people would abuse the feature, but i think it would work well for the majority of the community. We could als add a set limit of like 500k resources donates
d per season so people can not abuse this feature to much

But the fact that it will be abused rules it out.

Your logic:

OK, then we will now not have locks on our safes, because although some people will steal from it, the majority is fine so it's ok! ;)

Ok, then we won't lock our front doors, because although just a little bit of people would steal from your house, the majority is fine so it's ok!
June 23rd, 2014
dirkvs

Quote:

Originally Posted by kyumin2lee

But the fact that it will be abused rules it out.

Your logic:

OK, then we will now not have locks on our safes, because although some people will steal from it, the majority is fine so it's ok! ;)

Ok, then we won't lock our front doors, because although just a little bit of people would steal from your house, the majority is fine so it's ok!

I never close my door, so my idea is OK?
You can receive 1000 gold per day and that will cost someone else 10.000. We can change the 10.000 to make it more difficult. Something with your town hall level or something?
June 23rd, 2014
kyumin2lee

Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvs

I never close my door, so my idea is OK?
You can receive 1000 gold per day and that will cost someone else 10.000. We can change the 10.000 to make it more difficult. Something with your town hall level or something?

What I am saying is that you are saying the idea is ok because most people won't abuse it. But many people will abuse it. And them abusing it, ruins the game for people who don't abuse it, which makes us people abuse it.

The idea is either UP or OP, and the concept is ruled out. No arguing. It's ruled out.

So, here was the OP.

Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvs

I know that this idea is posted already. But there is a difference. They just wanted to donate, but I want more rules for donating.
1. You can receive 100xtroop capacity
2. The donator needs to donate 10x more than the receiver receive
3. No dark elixer

Maybe we have to changes this rules.
Before you close this topic if it still is a bad idea, i want to know why it is a bad idea. I've searched for the reason but the only thing i found was: ruled out.
I hope this is a better idea, and i hope that you've understand my bad english.

1. What? That's too, too ,too OP! Attacking will be too hard!
2. Loot will be flooded out of the economy and CoC will shut down.
3. Ok I suppose.

But once again.

The idea is ruled out. Please read the stickies before posting.

Thank you and have a nice day!
June 23rd, 2014
dirkvs

why is 1 OP?
Clan castle level 6 means a maximum of receiving 3500 gold per day
Clan castle level 1 means a maximum of receiving 1000 gold per day
But if there are a lot of people who would abuse this, It is a bad idea. But maybe we can find a way against the abusers.
June 23rd, 2014
kyumin2lee

Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvs

why is 1 OP?
Clan castle level 6 means a maximum of receiving 3500 gold per day
Clan castle level 1 means a maximum of receiving 1000 gold per day
But if there are a lot of people who would abuse this, It is a bad idea. But maybe we can find a way against the abusers.

Oh I thought that you meant we could give 100 troops!

Find a way against abusers? For an idea in which people can give other people - and themselves - free loot? No matter how small or limited, the concept is wrong.

Sorry, but once again, Ruled out! There is a reason why the SC team carefully took the time to analyse and finally rule out the idea.
June 23rd, 2014
hogyh03

Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvs

why is 1 OP?
Clan castle level 6 means a maximum of receiving 3500 gold per day
Clan castle level 1 means a maximum of receiving 1000 gold per day
But if there are a lot of people who would abuse this, It is a bad idea. But maybe we can find a way against the abusers.

Yes it has been ruled out and side note 3500 gold/elixer a day doesn't help someone a whole lot, especially someone with a level 6 cc.
June 23rd, 2014
dirkvs

Quote:

Originally Posted by hogyh03

Yes it has been ruled out and side note 3500 gold/elixer a day doesn't help someone a whole lot, especially someone with a level 6 cc.

But 1000 for level 1 is enough to help friends
June 23rd, 2014
kyumin2lee

Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvs

But 1000 for level 1 is enough to help friends

Look, there isn't any point arguing. It's ruled out.
June 23rd, 2014
ClashOn4Life

Quote:

Originally Posted by kyumin2lee

Look, there isn't any point arguing. It's ruled out.

This could be abused easily. If you have 3 accounts, don't play for a 12 hours and you can donate 200k in resources.
June 23rd, 2014
Kuris

Please look below for my automated response

Hey There. Thanks for posting your idea in the SuperCell Forum.

*Donating (or trading) resources or gems to (with) other players
*An exchange building to convert between elixir, gold, dark elixir, or gems
*Assign multiple builders to one build/upgrade
*Upgradeable builders’ huts – lvl 2 huts for a 5% time decrease?
*Player search function
*Ability to change village name
*Active/ Live “Online Status” examples: colored icons, on/off indicator, etc.
*Indicate last online date
*Remove the “Report” button/feature from global chat. Abused too often, and mute is better solution

As you can see, it is currently ruled out as it is easily exploitable, or messes up with Personal issues.

This Ruled Out Post is taken from - http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines
June 23rd, 2014
dirkvs

Quote:

Originally Posted by ClashOn4Life

This could be abused easily. If you have 3 accounts, don't play for a 12 hours and you can donate 200k in resources.

And if we customize it to the level of the receiver

Quote:

Originally Posted by kyumin2lee

Look, there isn't any point arguing. It's ruled out.

Sorry, but me and my friend have talk about this for weeks and we thought it was a great idea. Now i know why it wasn't in the game already, I want to solve the problem.
June 23rd, 2014
MEimCHRISTOPH

its true

I hate to break it to u buddy but people would donate to themselves in other accounts.
June 23rd, 2014
kyumin2lee

Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvs

And if we customize it to the level of the receiver

Sorry, but me and my friend have talk about this for weeks and we thought it was a great idea. Now i know why it wasn't in the game already, I want to solve the problem.

Umm.... this idea in its self is not fair - because it's either unhelpful, or can be abused.

It can be a pointless addition, or it can be an OP, abused addition.

It's ruled out. No matter what stat or method is changed, it is ruled out, and is a bad idea. Sorry to be so harsh.
June 23rd, 2014
SuperMarc

Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvs

I know that this idea is posted already. But there is a difference. They just wanted to donate, but I want more rules for donating.
1. You can receive 100xtroop capacity
2. The donator needs to donate 10x more than the receiver receive
3. No dark elixer

Maybe we have to changes this rules.
Before you close this topic if it still is a bad idea, i want to know why it is a bad idea. I've searched for the reason but the only thing i found was: ruled out.
I hope this is a better idea, and i hope that you've understand my bad english.

Sorry but but this is ruled out
June 23rd, 2014
dirkvs

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuperMarc

Sorry but but this is ruled out

Ow...
OK thanks