SUPERCELL, please investigate & don't ban legitimate defensive players please.

First, can I please commend SUPERCELL on a job well done on listening to the community in regards to the recent (let's just call it) glitch that was running rampant in high Champions' League.

Can I also commend SUPERCELL on their efforts in punishing these players
- I think bans are circulating amongst the offenders as we speak.

HOWEVER, I fear that in the process of trying to exact swift justice on the perpetrators,
some innocent bystanders have been caught in the cross hairs.

So, a clannie of mine logs in to find this screen welcoming him lovingly:
http://i1277.photobucket.com/albums/...ps0uagxaky.jpg

This is him, btw:
http://i1277.photobucket.com/albums/...psgzjstxd0.png

Now, looking @ his defensive wins in a week, one can hazard as to why SUPERCELL thought that he should have been lynched along with the rest of the offenders.

BUT, unlike those who abused the glitch, my clannie has a replay for EACH AND EVERY defense that he has won:

http://i1277.photobucket.com/albums/...psa6noaelw.jpg

http://i1277.photobucket.com/albums/...psvjixs2wr.jpg

http://i1277.photobucket.com/albums/...ps4qeqdm0t.jpg

^-- From the above, you can see that
a. he has replays for all his wins / losses - with the glitch, NO REPLAYS ARE AVAILABLE (which I will show later)
b. ghadi doesn't always win - I have seen -20+ and -30+ replays on that base
c. his high defensive wins are in part possible because he always breaks shield - look @ the times between successive defences

On the other hand, a dishonest defensive win would NOT HAVE A REPLAY:

http://i1277.photobucket.com/albums/...pscf8e156b.jpg
^-- base as a player is disconnected

http://i1277.photobucket.com/albums/...ps5633b1e1.jpg
^--- attack log of maligned victim

(I've tried my best to edit out the name as not to name & shame)

Defensive Champ play is possible.
A maxed base + the right design + the right CC troops + a few drunk attackers will work magic on your trophy count.

Kings Rock is proud to say that we DID NOT PARTAKE in the abuse of this glitch
and we fully support SUPERCELL's efforts to take the offenders to task.

But please, please, please, please do not punish innocent bystanders who have only been trying to play an honest game, the way it was intended to be played.

Thank you, SUPERCELL.

We trust that you will do the right thing.

-----
The little (trusting) Potato

thats an awesome defense log.

I really hope they are actually looking into this and not just banning anyone who has defensive wins....

Awesome log btw.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pete82

I really hope they are actually looking into this and not just banning anyone who has defensive wins....

Awesome log btw.

---

Yes, we do hope that they will look into this.

ghadi only has about 10 H left on his shield, and to go on defense without his proper CC will be catastrophic.
And if he really is going to be unduly banned for 7 days, well, let's just say it's going to $uck (for lack of a better word).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Triedon

thats an awesome defense log.

---

lol... you should see the times that he loses 20-30 on a defense. :p

But yes, we are all very jealous of ghadi each time he posts a defensive win.
We also think he's crazy for breaking shield so often.

But it works for him. :rolleyes:

-----
The little (envious) Potato

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pete82

I really hope they are actually looking into this and not just banning anyone who has defensive wins....

Awesome log btw.

---

If this is the case then predator has probably been banned as well.

Not cool SC.

How could this guy screenshot his logs of he's been banned? There's no date shown at top of phone so how do you know with a certainty that your clanmate didn't ♥♥♥♥♥? Its possible some people were just smarter about it than others not using it to get 30 wins and what not. All those screen shots were at different times since his trophies and xp are changing each time so who knows if those are really his most recent defenses.

You might be right but there's gotta be a decent chance that super cell is right and there's data to support he ♥♥♥♥♥ed and is lying to you to save face. Just a thought. If he didn't ♥♥♥♥♥ than hopefully he gets his account back asap.

That's an awesome defense log, and I don't think for a minute that you or your clan have taken part in this ha ck. however if this player was banned how did you go about getting a new list of his recent defenses? A person could argue those are possibly old defense log screen shots, taken before the ban was enacted. Again I'm not saying you're lying and don't think you are. Just a devils advocate question.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Arom

How could this guy screenshot his logs of he's been baned?

---

Lol, he took them earlier before he was banned.

Let's just say that it's nice to take screenshots of things that are as rare & magical as unicorns.

-----
The little (took a screenshot of a +39 win & sent it to EVERYONE on her LINE / KiK / GroupMe contact list) Potato

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Arom

How could this guy screenshot his logs of he's been banned? There's no date shown at top of phone so how do you know with a certainty that your clanmate didn't ♥♥♥♥♥? Its possible some people were just smarter about it than others not using it to get 30 wins and what not.

You might be right but there's gotta be a decent chance that super cell is right and there's data to support he ♥♥♥♥♥ed and is lying to you to save face. Just a thought. If he didn't ♥♥♥♥♥ than hopefully he gets his account back asap.

---

Maybe he was like "OMG how have i won these many" so he decides to take a picture. Most champs get 1 to 3 wins, but not all the time. No one has there perfect raid all the time. I agree that SC should look into who needs banning and not, i feel like they just banned anyone over 10 defense wins..