Which base design should I use?

Option 1 - My Current One:
http://i.imgur.com/SBIIi3b.jpg
NOTE: since this picture was taken, I have closed off that bottom area.

Option 2 - New Design:
http://i.imgur.com/bgSOPkk.png

Going to have to vote option 3: none of them. Check out the TH8 base design thread for ideas.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Spikefood

Going to have to vote option 3: none of them. Check out the TH8 base design thread for ideas.

---

Care to share why?

I think the 2nd one is pretty good in terms of countering wall-breaker AI!

TH8 thread is full of different versions of each other.. I want to make something diff. xD

None of them is good, but I think the 1st is better

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by saad22

None of them is good, but I think the 1st is better

---

Can you please share your reasoning so I can use it to improve? :P

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jenniifuh

Care to share why?

I think the 2nd one is pretty good in terms of countering wall-breaker AI!

TH8 thread is full of different versions of each other.. I want to make something diff. xD

---

In the second one its clear you focused on making lots of compartments but you compromised them by making some X junctions where a WBer could gain access to two or three areas at once. I'd attack from the east taking out the mortar and WTer and the gold storage. A few more WBers and I'd get your DE also. Since you've got only 4 storages that means you'll love 100k per storage.

Also looking at your base you've put too much empty space in the middle, it's obvious where the Teslas are, you want them to be more hidden. Lead the attacker to be confused to as where the Teslas could be.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Spikefood

In the second one its clear you focused on making lots of compartments but you compromised them by making some X junctions where a WBer could gain access to two or three areas at once. I'd attack from the east taking out the mortar and WTer and the gold storage. A few more WBers and I'd get your DE also. Since you've got only 4 storages that means you'll love 100k per storage.

Also looking at your base you've put too much empty space in the middle, it's obvious where the Teslas are, you want them to be more hidden. Lead the attacker to be confused to as where the Teslas could be.

---

Where can they break into 2-3 areas at once?? Could you circle?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jenniifuh

Where can they break into 2-3 areas at once?? Could you circle?

---

Looking at it again maybe not 3 areas but definitely 2 areas. Attack from corners. Giants to distract, archers to take out exterior buildings and about 10 WBers to gain access to about 60-70% of the base.

Also centralizing your BK does little to no good for you on defense.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Spikefood

Also centralizing your BK does little to no good for you on defense.

---

i agree with what everything spike says - i actually keep my BK inactive for defense cuz real farmers can take him out no problem. waste of space.