Remake the trophy aattack and defend rewarding and loss

After seeing ridiculously stupid things on my match history, I feel like trophy rewarding and deduction needs a change

I was heavily "overkilled" by a TH8 and loss 33 trophies. He had less trophies so I lose more trophies. It obviously shows that you could be a TH9 rampaging in silver three, over kill Th5 bases and get 30+ trophies. This is further proven when somebody with more trophies and equal TH PvP and he got 25 trophyish, hardly getting three stars

Etc etc etc...

Improvement that can be made
-The current system operates on raider and defender's trophy differences.
-The system will now calculate the variable of raider's army strength and defender's base strength
-Star from TH sniping will yield bit less trophy from star from 50%. There's a huge difference in the effort.
-Trophy rewarding will also take into variable of damage done. 75% will yield more trophies(Couple)than 50% straight.
-49% attacks grant you 2-5 trophies. People often get 49% and rage. I lost 30 trophies in 49% raid

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bresn

After seeing ridiculously stupid things on my match history, I feel like trophy rewarding and deduction needs a change

I was heavily "overkilled" by a TH8 and loss 33 trophies. He had less trophies so I lose more trophies. It obviously shows that you could be a TH9 rampaging in silver three, over kill Th5 bases and get 30+ trophies. This is further proven when somebody with more trophies and equal TH PvP and he got 25 trophyish, hardly getting three stars

Etc etc etc...

Improvement that can be made
-The current system operates on raider and defender's trophy differences.
-The system will now calculate the variable of raider's army strength and defender's base strength
-Star from TH sniping will yield bit less trophy from star from 50%. There's a huge difference in the effort.
-Trophy rewarding will also take into variable of damage done. 75% will yield more trophies(Couple)than 50% straight.
-49% attacks grant you 2-5 trophies. People often get 49% and rage. I lost 30 trophies in 49% raid

---

What benefit does the TH9 rampaging in Silver 3 have to attack TH5 bases? And I doubt think a TH9 gets 30 trophies from a TH5. Even if he does, what is the point? He'll eventually get enough trophies to leave Silver 3. Loot will be non-existent due to loot penalties.

You deserve to lose those stars if all you could muster is 49%. This suggestion would ruin the traditional way of game play and trophy pushing in general.

I disagree completely.