Printable View
I got 4 gold storage, lv 11, lv 11, lv 10, lv1
Someone attack me and it shows that all avalible gold to raid to get is 300k
That person only attack storage lv10 and take half gold 150k.
WHY? Why one lower storage is 150?
Not like something like this: 110k 110k 70k 10k
Its seriously not fair!
That's odd. Are you sure he didn't take most of the loot from collectors?Quote:
Originally Posted by subdark
Seems like the only option is the collectors. i would take a good look at the replay again, if possible
Yes, the gold is supposed to be distributed evenly amongst all the storages.Quote:
Originally Posted by Benny101
The 300k listed is not the available loot, but is the defensive loot cap. According to the loot system rules, the most gold a TH8 can lose is 300k. However, a full level 10 gold storage holds 1,000,000 gold of which 14% may be stolen, which amounts to 140k. The remaining 10k the attacker stole likely came from collectors.
Be happy there is a defensive loot cap. Otherwise, the player could have stolen more than 700k from your storages alone.
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...=1#post1157535
Fairly sure that's not how it works - the available loot (300k in this case) is distributed amongst the storages, taking into account their level, so it should be pretty much exactly how OP wants. I've never ever seen a situation (on attack or defence) where I would be able to get almost all of the loot from 1 storage, even if the storages were full.Quote:
Originally Posted by SharkyFinn
I was always of the opinion that it was split evenly across storages.Quote:
Originally Posted by SharkyFinn
Im not sure about your explanation. When I raid TH10s showing 400k gold, i normally get 200k from 2 storages. Certainly I have never walked away with 400k from only taking 2 out of the 4 storages.
Quote:
Originally Posted by subdark
Quote:
Originally Posted by Antonioca
With his stated storage levels, how can the loot be divided evenly when, in particular, his level 1 storage can only hold 1,500 gold? It's been so long since I've had different level storages, I forget if loot is placed in them at an even percentage based on their level or if the lowest one fills first, working up ,in this way, through the levels.Quote:
Originally Posted by VincentVegas
Either way, it seems that the OP has omitted/overlooked needed information. Empty clan castle and empty/partially full collectors come to mind.
i think the amount that can be stolen is proportional to the amount held in each storage. So the OP's storages were completely full (2m in each Lvl 11, 1m in the Lvl 10, 1,500 in the Lvl 1) then 40% of the total would come from each of the Lvl 11s, 20% from the Lvl 10, and almost nothing from the level 1.
If the attacker really did get half of the total available and only took 1 storage, some must have come from the mines or clan castle.
It's pretty obvious let's say one storage holds 250K and the others hold 500K each.Quote:
Originally Posted by Herpacleese
It takes the lowest one , distributes equally until it reaches 250K once the amount in question has been divided it ignores the smallest storage and distributes evenly to the other 3 (or whichever scenario applies).
As for loot stealing it's percentage based on the difference of townhalls and maximum loot that can be stolen.
Based on the above stated formula if someone attacked your smallest storage they would only get a percentage of that small amount vs a bigger storage holding obviously more loot. When I go for storages and I see a small underdeveloped one and larger ones , I obviously go for the larger ones.
im very very sorry
i watch replay again and again but somehow dont get attention to lightning strike on my dark elixir storage who also take some gold from gold storage
very sorry my mistake