"REVENGE" against ex members that have dropped the clan!!!

Many times it happens that a member leaves the clan when he no longer needs their help ( "Please give me troop" -> GIVEN -> XYZ has left the clan)
This is a very common situation and it occurs within a few minutes : I HATE THAT!!!!

A fair solution may be (at least) a revenge attack against that ones who have left the clan for no reason

Ya buy still applies to a normal revenge thing( only when they are offline/no shield) and only 1 person can attack

It's called a hopper... You aren't the only one who hates them

No this isn't a fair solution. It's a terrible one that would be highly exploitable.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

No this isn't a fair solution. It's a terrible one that would be highly exploitable.

---

I said that may be a fair solution, obviously not the best one. All kind of advice shall be helpful :p
(notice that a revenge attack could be used only if the ex-member is really a "hopper" , E.G. Time XYZ has left - Time XYZ has joined < time threshold ; algorithm that uses probability exc.)


It's a usual situation in Italian servers (and so in other ones) and should be found a countermeasure to reduce this problem..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by salvdangelo

I said that may be a fair solution, obviously not the best one. All kind of advice shall be helpful :p
(notice that a revenge attack could be used only if the ex-member is really a "hopper" , E.G. Time XYZ has left - Time XYZ has joined < time threshold ; algorithm that uses probability exc.)


It's a usual situation in Italian servers (and so in other ones) and should be found a countermeasure to reduce this problem..

---

How about only if they leave a period of time after requesting, because some people looking for clans will hop around to find the ideal clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by salvdangelo

I said that may be a fair solution, obviously not the best one. All kind of advice shall be helpful :p
(notice that a revenge attack could be used only if the ex-member is really a "hopper" , E.G. Time XYZ has left - Time XYZ has joined < time threshold ; algorithm that uses probability exc.)


It's a usual situation in Italian servers (and so in other ones) and should be found a countermeasure to reduce this problem..

---

This doesn't really alter how exploitable it is by much. The countermeasure for this is to set your clan as invite only and implement an application process for your clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SpiderPig

How about only if they leave a period of time after requesting, because some people looking for clans will hop around to find the ideal clan

---

Doesn't matter. Any behavior you add as a condition can be simulated by others and used as a resource/trophy exchange.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

Doesn't matter. Any behavior you add as a condition can be simulated by others and used as a resource/trophy exchange.

---

True. We do need some sort of anti-hopper addition though.

Ok, I catched the flip-side problem but.. what about to report the inappropriate behaviour of the user(in the same way used for messages)?
If counter (warnings received by user/headman of DIFFERENT clans) > 10, 20.. then it's a malicious user!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SpiderPig

True. We do need some sort of anti-hopper addition though.

---

We have one. It's called managing your clan properly.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by salvdangelo

Ok, I catched the flip-side problem but.. what about to report the inappropriate behaviour of the user(in the same way used for messages)?
If counter (warnings received by user/headman of DIFFERENT clans) > 10, 20.. then it's a malicious user!

---

Only if we implement the same thing for clans. Clans who make 10 - 20 false reports or report without making any attempt to self manage are immediately disbanded.

Fact: Someone leaves your clan. It's not good enough.

• It is not an excuse to attack.
• Yes, if they hop it's understandable. But as Dahimi kindly said, implement something yourself to fix the problem in your own way
• Fix your clan, if a long term member leaves, your doing SOMETHING wrong.

umm..... no

"Hey Bob, need some resources? I'm full"

Sure !

Sets TH and elixer storage in unprotected corner. Leaves clan.

Returns to clan

Hey, enjoy all that gold and thanks for the free shield!

Or

Hey, I need 200 more trophies to get to (1,250, Cyrstwl, Masters) to get free gems, can anyone help out?

Sure can, leave, revenge, up trophies, they return, rinse and repeat.