Printable View
I understand why donating to the cc in cw doesn't count for the friend in need achievement as you could easily abuse it and just donate-dismiss-donate-dismiss forever until you get it.
But as for the rest of them, why don't they count? I'm talking about the ones that count mortars destroyed, TH destoryed, builders huts, xbows, inferno towers, ect (not sure if I missed one). These really should count!
Whacha think?
I don't see why not, that's pretty reasonable.
bump. no one else wants this?
I've thought about this myself. I think it is rather absurd not to count them as donations, this way it will push clan mates to donate for war since they will get xp toward level and achievements for it.
Great idea.
Well as for donations, it can be abused in the way that the OP stated. Although, counting the non-donation accomplishments makes sense to me.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ninja352
I guess SC just wants to treat clan wars completely separate from regular raiding achievements.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bulldog241
Bumping is against forum rules. Check my sig (OR HERE)..
If someone finds your idea interesting, they will talk.
Hi EpicChris, its actually "repeated bumping" thats not allowed, but very useful you police the threads so proactively...:pQuote:
Originally Posted by EpicChris
I like the freeze tower idea, but would propose it is a 2x2 1 off defense similar to an inferno tower, available from th level 8. Range could be similar to a mortar. I think that town hall lev 8 thru 10, a wizard tower should be upgradable to mirror whatever spells your spell factory can make. Relevant ones should be lightning, heal and freeze at the moment. would make things very interesting....
Well I don't see why not!!
I totally agree with this, but i think donations to the war camp should also count. You should only be able to donate to the war camp once. Supercell could also introduce a calculation that deducts your troop donation if that troop is rejected. But rejecting a troop in a war camp is no different AT ALL from taking clan castles and dumping the bodies in the goblin woods to free up the space for a re-request...Quote:
Originally Posted by Bulldog241
No bumping is not allowed not just repeatedly but even once!Quote:
Originally Posted by leif
Thank you Sir JohnnyQuote:
Originally Posted by johnnybro1234
This is correct. This should clarify things:Quote:
Originally Posted by johnnybro1234
http://i208.photobucket.com/albums/b.../cantbump1.png
http://i208.photobucket.com/albums/b.../cantbump2.png
Qwertgfdeeeyy
You could easily abuse the system. You can now dump clan castle troops, so if you co-ordinated you could get tons of XP. Donate, dump, donate, dump, donate, dump, etc. etc.
Well it can be abused.....
So your object was to my use of the word "bump"? Someone else had posted, and my "bump" wasn't a bump since I was just replying to him. So if I had just said:Quote:
Originally Posted by EpicChris
"no one else wants this?"
Then you would have been fine? Quite the nit-pick there, but whatever. Oh yeah, "bump". Oh no, I did it again!! lol.
If there was some way to "undo" your donation if your troop got rejected, I suppose that would avoid any abuse. But it is different from dumping your CC in the goblin woods because you have to wait 20 min on your CC, but in the wars you can do it instantly over and over again. At any rate, this is a bit of a derail.Quote:
Originally Posted by leif
My suggestion is to include the building destructions in your achievement count, and it seems like just an oversight on Supercell's part that it's not.
Agree.........
anyone know if this was an oversight, or if this was done intentionally?