Xp for war castle donated troops

I got this idea today when I was donating in clan wars.I asked a friend to donate in war castle but he denied saying that it doesn't give him any benefit.

So i am not asking the donations we made to be included in our profile, but if we at least get XP for what we donated in war then people will be more willing to donate and at the same time the donators can get to higher levels when compared to others.

Please guys support those who donate.

I don't support it and let me explain why.

For clan war donations, you don't want lower level troops. You want the strongest, maxed out levels of each troop.

That means level 6 archers, level 6 wizards, level 2 witches, level 6 balloons, you catch my drift.

Any one who really cares about getting experience or to increase their donation count is likely not in possession of these maxed level troops.

You want these troops coming from the strongest bases in your clan. Since lower bases currently don't get recognition for donating their troops, they are less likely to donate. Which is what we want anyway. So leave it as it is. The upper levels already have their "friend in need" achievement completed so they don't care if you count donations or not.

I know you can dump troops in war bases if you don't like/want them, but that's a hassle to maintain consistently. It was waste of their time and elixir/DE to donate troops you're going to drop anyways.

The system works fine as-is.

Just read every other thread on this topic!

The benefit is better chance on wining the war in turn everyone gets more war loot

Why would there be a higher chance of winning?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MAFDWILL

The benefit is better chance on wining the war in turn everyone gets more war loot

---

The only possible way this is true, is if you are in an incredibly small or incredibly inactive clan, to the point where people's war base CC's don't get completely filled.

In which case, it would be helpful to get my donation participation from slightly lower bases, since a maxed CC is better than a half full CC.

But if that's not the case, your statement doesn't make sense.

Hawdog i get your point.Supercell also introduced a feature to reject the troops if u dont like them so it won't be a problem.If people dont get anything for their donations why would they want to donate.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hawdog

I don't support it and let me explain why.

For clan war donations, you don't want lower level troops. You want the strongest, maxed out levels of each troop.

That means level 6 archers, level 6 wizards, level 2 witches, level 6 balloons, you catch my drift.

Any one who really cares about getting experience or to increase their donation count is likely not in possession of these maxed level troops.

You want these troops coming from the strongest bases in your clan. Since lower bases currently don't get recognition for donating their troops, they are less likely to donate. Which is what we want anyway. So leave it as it is. The upper levels already have their "friend in need" achievement completed so they don't care if you count donations or not.

I know you can dump troops in war bases if you don't like/want them, but that's a hassle to maintain consistently. It was waste of their time and elixir/DE to donate troops you're going to drop anyways.

The system works fine as-is.

---

I agree but at the same time I see some flaws, I personally have maxed troops. This is like you mentioned except for level 6 wizards as I am a townhall 9. I think that in my specific case, if you are in a high level clan, you're going to receive these troops anyway. I don't see the xp being a problem in higher level clans, especially now that you can dismiss troops. I personally think that if you did receive xp, it wouldn't be abused.

Yeah in high level clans where everyone has good troops xp will encourage people to donate as they can show case higher level. Who wouldn't want a high level in their profile.