Clan War Lineup/Rally

This is an idea I have been thinking about for awhile now. This could help clans who want to have more competitive wars, clans that have members who sometimes dont attack during clan wars making their clan lose. Let me you know what you think.

For the purpose of this example lets say you have a clan with 30 members. When a clan leader or co leader chooses to go to war, they would first choose the number of members in their clan they would like to go to war. With 30 members you could choose 10,15,25, or 30. Lets say the lead or co lead chooses a 10 member war. Once they chose 10 members, a message would come up in the clan message board that looks exactly like a donation message and would say (village name) is trying to rally for a war! Join him now! Or something along those lines. There would be 1 spot already filled because the member who started the war would automatically be entered in the rally. Of the 30 eligible clan war members, the first 9 to join will go to war. Once the 9 spots have been filled, the search for the clan war will begin automatically. If somebody who joins the war does not use at least one of their attacks, then they would be penalized by not being able to join the rally for the next war. Also if the lead or co lead choose a 30 member war, then the search would start like it does now because there would be no need for people to join the rally.

I really think this would be beneficial. Not everyone is a dedicated clasher and when you are in a war and not everyone is contributing it can be frustrating. This would enable people, who actually are ready and craving that awesome loot bonus, to join and win a war. Let me know what you think clashers and supercell

You could maybe join a new and more dedicated clan like us (Signature below for details about us:rolleyes:) or if you are a leader, then slowly kick people who don't raid twice, thats what we do

Ya I thought someone might say that but Im in a clan with my friends and don't really want to join another. Not everyone is a dedicated clasher and Im sure there are some people who hold there clans back. My idea wouldn't take anything away from what they are already have in place. It just gives people more options providing a better chance to win

But Unfortunately it is called CLAN wars, because you must fight with your clan, but I see what you are saying, friends are friends, but ditch them and join us:p:p

Exactly! Im not saying that you choose random people. Just people from your clan. And if you have a really good clan, which it sounds like you do, then you dont have to limit the number of people in your clan who join the war by choosing the maximum amount