Printable View
What do you guys think? Should time be a factor in attacks? I don't thinks so. it is just an extra OP Defense. you can have a town beat, but you don't get 3 stars because time runs out. There are no time limits in the single player maps so why in multi-player? The could add something like a time bonus for winning within a time frame, but the attack shouldn't end because time runs out.
Everything is OP. Deal with it.Quote:
Originally Posted by cab0053
because then you would be able to attack for 6 hoursQuote:
Originally Posted by cab0053
The reason for the time, is most likely servers, running multiple battles at more than 3 min will be bad
also, it adds challange and balance
Unlimited time for a raid is pointless, your troops will eventually die. A reason for single player to have unlimited is because in some missions, you only have to drop one minions and you get 3 star. Get a strategy where you can win in under the time limit. If you can't win use a better strategy
The time limit adds to the strategy, challenge and fun of raiding.
The single player matches are meant as training grounds for you to experiment with new armies and how to attack different types of bases. They get progressively tougher as your army grows stronger, so that your raiding skills can evolve as your skills and troop levels do the same. That is why there is no time limit in single player, it is so that you can slowly figure out some new offensive strategies and with practice, you can do them quicker.
In terms of being overpowered, the opposite is actually true the further along you get in the game, meaning OFFENSE is actually what is overpowered currently, not defense.
What if they did an added time thing. like for ever X% you distroy you get X secs added to the clock. they could even lower the initial time from 3 min to like 2 min. sometimes i just need those few extra sec lol
This can actually be exploited, not letting some people log in, the scenario will follow like this:Quote:
Originally Posted by cab0053
- *Player searchers for a base*
- *Player attacks the base with one troop*
- *Now player leaves his Ipad sitting in the table without surrendering for 6 hours, and the attack constantly keeps going*
- *Now the owner of the base can't log on until the player ends his battle in 6 hours*
I personally think that it's fine as it is, it is your challenge to try and get the bas three starred in under 3 minutes :)
Haha I could imagine, the clash screen saying your under attack wait 6 hours until the raid is over :D
dang guys i wasn't saying it was fool proof lol i was just ranting and sending out an idea at the same time... obviously not a good idea lol
How can you argue with this logic! Great point.Quote:
Originally Posted by Saltin
I really think it ain't broke, so no need to try to fix it. 3 minutes is fair.
yes I agree not the greatest idea lol, but my idea was worse, look at the thread I made :Dhttp://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...g-donations%21
I know you're honestly trying to contribute what you believe to be good ideas cab0053, but we can't just throw up any idea or rant any time one comes to mind or else this forum would be a complete mess, and even more filled with repeated ideas, ruled out ideas, and just a complete hassle to both moderate, as well as to discern good ideas from all the bad ones.Quote:
Originally Posted by cab0053
If you haven't yet, I would strongly recommend you read dahimi's sticky thread here: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-posting-guide
I think after you read this guide, you will understand my intentions. :)
I have read it. it is cool i know what you are saying. im just bored and wanted to pass around the ideas i have had for weeks now. and johnny i saw man. i knew what it was from the start. funny as heckQuote:
Originally Posted by hawdog
Sometimes victory is not enough for seconds! Now, if there were a way to add more time literally 5 seconds ...
Haha thanks cab, hope I didn't annoy any members of this forum:p:p Blik, I'm sorry to say it, but if you can't get 3 stars in 3 mins, then you should either change the strategy, raid easier people, or place troops better. If you get 99% because of a sneaky builders hut in the corner, then make sure at the beginning of every raid take out buildings in the corner first! Hope this helps in some way shape or form:)
It's not a strategy problem. Early in the fight need to pull troops from the castle pull the king, the queen of archers. How do I change the strategy in this case? Make my army stronger and attack the weak?
That's just the problem - good strategies do not work - not enough time.
When you look at attacks not much on clash is op but the reason time is a factor because time adds a factor of strategy because that what clash of clans is a strategy game. so deal with it:cool:.Quote:
Originally Posted by Connor19817
nah otherwise the defending player has to wait ages and at least there is a little challenge for being quick
This ^^^^^^^^Quote:
Originally Posted by hawdog
What if the owner of the base wants to log on. He can't because he has to wait for you to finish your attack. So you could hold someone offline forever lol
No discomfort during the attack my base in the war of clans. Why it is necessary to wait out the normal attack? This happens rarely and briefly.
Even if you have to wait, it's not about the hours of walking. +15 seconds for King, +20 for the queen.