[Vote] Regarding a New + Seperated Base Design Threads for respective TH Level

EDIT: Seperated thread for individual TH level created.
TH9 Base Design thread: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...se-Designs-TH9
TH8 Base Design thread: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...se-Designs-TH8
Th7 Base Design Thread: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...se-Designs-TH7

Intro: The current base design version 2 thread is at page 233, and a revamp is way overdue considering the new wb AI update rendered many old bases useless.
So while we do need a new base design thread, what we also need is a clear segmentation(not of your storages..) of the thread base on TH level.

So this is a request to the mods who may or may not have heard our request for separated and new base design threads.

Should we exclude TH6 ?
Currently the most popular TH levels are TH6, TH7, TH8, TH9.
But TH6 isnt that popular, so maybe we should leave it out ?

Rationale for Sticky
And the rationale for a sticky is that if there are many seperate base design thread, the less popular TH Level will get lost easily, and that will defeat the purpose of a "compiled base design" thread

So here are the few proposals(Please read each proposal carefully)

1. Create individual Base design thread for TH6, TH7, TH8, TH9 and sticky them on General Section.
2. Create individual Base design thread for TH7, TH8, TH9 and sticky them on General Section.
3. Create individual Base design thread for TH6, TH7, TH8, TH9 and sticky them on Strategy Section
4. Create individual Base design thread for TH7, TH8, TH9 and sticky them on Strategy Section
5. No need for Separation, just create a new Base design version 3 thread on General Section
6. No need for Separation, just create a new Base design version 3 thread on Strategy Section

Pros of Separated Individual Base Design Thread/Cons of Single Base Design thread

• Easier for individual TH level to discuss without getting interrupted by another TH level
• Easier for future referencing for those looking for specific TH design

Cons of Separated Individual Base Design Thread/ Pros of Single base Design thread

• An addition of 4 stickies makes it crowded at the sticky area. But strategy section currently only has 1 sticky
• Higher TH level players might not be bothered to go to lower TH level thread to contribute/criticize/give comment

Pros of sticky at general section/ Cons of sticky at Strategy Section

• Higher traffic since its general section
• sticky means will not get lost even if there are less response at certain times

Cons of sticky at general section/ Pros of Sticky at general section

• More clutter at the sticky section, currently 4 sticky

Fun Read regarding shifting of Base design thread from General to Strategy Sub forum: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...moving-threads << Click Me !

If you have any opinions regarding this matter, make a post below

IMHO, no need for seperation (voted for Another General Base Design thread.) I learn a lot from looking at all TH level designs. It will be too messy and time consuming having 1 topic per TH level.

My 2 yens.

i voted for th6 - th7 sticky in the strategy section. the general section is quite stickied at the moment and it is the fastest moving section of the boards so the fewer stickies the better else things fall off the first page too quickly (although sometimes that would be beneficial for certain threads).

having it segregated by TH level would be super helpful and make them maybe a little less difficult to wade through.

Luckily I thought of more options.. first 4 votes all different ! :eek:

Will add in some pros and cons to the first post

i vote for TH6,TH7,TH8,TH9 in the sticky of strategies because that one is not too full :o

I'm a loner :(

EDIT
I'm no longer a loner :)

I agree with Pingfao. You can learn a lot form base designs, regardless of the th level. I voted for make a new thread in general

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lol4657

I'm a loner :(

---

Nah you are not. Illy is with u.

I don't find any reason to put a combined thread at strategy section though.

Well yes, thats technically the right place to discuss strategies and layout, the traffic is lower than general, and its not like we are having 3-4+ threads, so there really isn't an incentive to place it there..

but yeah, I just place that option there for people who feel that way.

I voted 7-9 in the general section. Base designs have always been in general and I would hate to see this confined to just the strategies section. Here is what happened when this came up a while back: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...moving-threads
That didn't end well, now did it?

To be honest, though, I think they should only be temporary stickies, like Base Designs 2 was. These threads will take off insantly and would do perfectly fine without a permanent sticky.

Anyway, I would like to see some separation between the different TH levels. TH 6 doesn't really seem overly necessary, but I am really indifferent on that one due to the lower frequency. The others, though, I think deserve their own threads. TH 7 is nothng like TH 8 and TH 8 is nothing like TH 9. Their base designs are completely different and I feel they warrant their own separate places.

Just my $.02

Well, lets discuss it point by point. The first point is about including th6 or not, including th6 adds more posters to the post, doesn't matter if everything is in one thread, BUT, seeing multiple threads stickied is more organized, thus, having a complete thread for th6 ( not many are on that level ) is useless.

Maybe Making a thread for

• TH6 and TH7
• TH8
• TH9

Is more appealing, since TH6 and TH7 are quite familiar and similar.

I voted for the threads to be stickied in the 'general' tab because:

1. This is how it was all the time, everyone goes to this category for this thread.
2. It is not a Tactic, Strategy or Question thread. It is a Design thread where strategy is not applicable... It was made for Aesthetics and for the fun of best thing about this game.

Moe, the wishing Meerkat