Would you guys please add a Elder Chat Tab? Instead of having only two tabs (global & clan) add a third for elders... This way we could discuss promotions and demotions without everyone in the clan seeing it.
What do you guys think?
Printable View
Would you guys please add a Elder Chat Tab? Instead of having only two tabs (global & clan) add a third for elders... This way we could discuss promotions and demotions without everyone in the clan seeing it.
What do you guys think?
I'm not an elder (and don't really want to be), but I think this is an excellent idea.
I think this a great idea and it make it easier than going to Facebook to talk to each other
~F.U.B.A.R~
I'm a clan leader of 47 and would have use for this. Good idea
I think this is a great idea. I would rather not have to use Facebook or iMessage to communicate with elders. I like my fellow elders, but I would like to talk about clan matters without having to give out personal info via Facebook or mobile.
A totally brilliant idea! We are always chatting about promotions and demotions and have to be careful what we say!
Maybe instead of a separate tab as then you would have an extra one to read they could make it so you can choose to post to elders and leader only so that it appears in chat highlighted but members can't see it only appears for elders and leaders
That could be a problem if someone forgets to press the "mute" button, better with a seperate chat.Quote:
Originally Posted by KingKasma
Yes I can see why a separate tab would be better now.Quote:
Originally Posted by XenapZ
Our whole clan wants this!!!!! We think its a great thing! Defo need more things for the clans as its clash of CLANS but at the min there's not much clan stuff to it
Haha our clan has no elders so this wouldn't be much use to us...
Quote:
Originally Posted by IRoss
Lol...maybe not for you but I think it would be great for the majority.
Sounds like a fantastic idea to me.
yep, and some people dont have facebook, like me :/Quote:
Originally Posted by Juggal0James
Nobody else?
+1 to this :D or even a whisper is also great!
I agree that this would be a great feature. I would add that the entire messaging system should be addressed. You should be able to message individual players in and out of your clan. This holds players longer and as supercell knows retention increases exposure to purchases. Simple math.
I want to push this to the top as the more I play and communicate with fellow elders, the more i wish we had something like this. We've been ui g iMessage, which is annoying and disruptive (16 texts in 1 min this morning) and like what was said earlier, not everyone has Facebook. Please add this elder chat feature, it would greatly enhance the gameplay experience, especially for elders:)
Great idea! I think this would add value to the elder status and encourage members to be more active to achieve the promotion, in addition to the other benefits discussed above.
This along with adding a bulletin board and perhaps PM function would make the inter-clan communication system perfect!
They could also add in a feature where you suggest a person and then the elders vote yes or no for elder. Then they could have a discussion on the elder chat and talk about it. I think it's a good idea but I think some people might not use it, and just discuss it in front of the clan
Wait an elder only one...what about the leader cuz I'm a leader :/
Domo:)
+1 for an elder-only channel
+0 for a bulletin board: not worth the trouble
-1 for the ability to IM any player: I destroy your base and you IM me nasty words. I think Supercell is doing a good job keeping the game relatively free from trolls. (except for the farmers who leave you without a shield, but even that is debatable)
This would be a great idea, currently we have to use an app outside of COC for elders to communicate information like this in.
I'd rather just see personal messages implemented.
yes im an owner of an clan and i defiantly want to see this, so the owners can talk to elders about demotions/promotions without every seeing it. i give it a 9/10, i would be 100% sure no one would hate on this idear.
Great idea! Would be really easy!!
Messaging tab for Clan Elders is an excellent idea.
A private messaging option for EVERYONE would be a great addition to the game as well! Don't you agree?:confused:
its been suggested before, and i approve the idea. there should definitely be some personal space for the elders of the clan to discuss who to promote and kick without regular members eavesdropping and then start whining. im a leader so this would be pretty good, and i trust my elders.
Great Idea!
Why can't you discuss clan business in front of members? If you are afraid to talk about those matters in front of clan members you are terrible leaders.Quote:
Originally Posted by JLegend84
Anything that improves the social side of the game gets my vote the only thing is the amount of space on screen is limited so it might make it over complicated....but if you didn't know already most clans use an iPhone instant messaging app - we use kik but i understand there are others available.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JtB
Sorry don't agree, I discuss potential rules with elders privately before discussing with all members. That's why u have elders.
Also excellent idea for the elder chat tab, would save us having to come off game to go on fb messenger or kik messenger.
Agree.Quote:
Originally Posted by JtB
Hmm.. it says i have to type at least 10 characters before i can submit reply, oh nice done it already.
How is separating clan chat helping the social aspect? If anything, it will alienate clan members and cause division. Many clans are all elder so an elder chat would be redundant to most of the community. There are also many all member clans so an elder chat wouldn't even help those clans.Quote:
Originally Posted by Daddy
Potential rules? I have had a clan for over 7 months and the clan rules have always been the same. What potential rules are you talking about? Does your clan change rules all of the time? You say we have elders so we can have an elder chat? I don't understand what you are saying.Quote:
Originally Posted by scanners107
Great idea i have recently become an elder of s.a.s 2 and we sometimes need to disscuss stuff, great idea!!!
So you guys are afraid to talk in clan chat? This elder chat reeks of people power tripping off of their rank. It's so sad, people don't know the first thing about being good leaders.Quote:
Originally Posted by Lloydiiboii
We actually had to create an email distribution list for this purpose. Sure some people had issues with getting emails from WebeMillfn@XXXXXX.net but they got over it. Love this idea, instant and clean.
+1 for this idea :D
Rules change as the the game changes I.e. new donation counter.Quote:
Originally Posted by JtB
It's good to discuss new stuff with elders before members but I'm sure your going to argue no matter what I put. As you can see people have mixed views on this idea so just leave it to SC to decide.
hey boys for my clan talk elders,leader and sub leader we use this app for pic and group
Appstore get this app ( GroupMe )
But i think it would be better if you were able to individually choose friends for this 3rd chat tab elder or not
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lukemilner123
more add for the game is like more lag or more bug :/
I have just seen that nearly most of peoples threads you have put a negative comment about. Whats the point , these are are opinions, not yours!Quote:
Originally Posted by JtB
I think this is a bad idea. Only because its bad enough with people joining and instantly asking for elder status. As soon as we say no, it has to be earned.....they leave. Making room for another noob to do the same. Having an "elder only" chat would make things even worse. Tho I like the idea as it would come in handy....I just think it isnt needed.
Tho thats only my opinion...and my 2 cents :)
This is a great idea. In our clan we only promote 1 person per week. There is very fierce competition for the 1 promotion and sometimes some debate. If this debate could take place privately from the general chat section it would make things easier.
Nice idea.