Printable View
I think as part of a clan, spectators who have missed the cut of being included in the war should be able to donate troops to the war clan castles. Theres nothing worst than being in a clan and having missed out and feeling stink cause you're not involved. By being able to contribute troops, you feel you are playing an active part in the war effort. Just saying peepz. What's everyones thoughts on this?
Here are my thoughts.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pdoggz
If you are a war spectator, that means one of 3 things:
1) you are new to the clan, and the clan you left was already participating in a war at the time
2) you joined the new clan AFTER prep day started
3) you are among the lowest 1-4 trophy totals4 in your clan
If it's #1 or 2, then no worries, you can contribute next war and every war after that, all good.
If it's #3, then you just have to work on upping your trophies slightly.
Also, if you are #3, there's a good chance that almost all the clan has stronger bases than you right? And that would also suggest that there's a good chance that they have stronger, higher level troops than you as well right? Since stronger troops can help your clan mates defend their bases better than lower level troops, it should be left up to the strongest players to donate the strongest troops to clan war bases. So although you have the right intentions, I think your clan would benefit from getting troops stronger than yours donated to their war bases.
Thanks hawdog, I can relate to what you've said and usually thats the case. Im referring to my sisters clan, which is pretty new, 19 members only. Two top players are TH8s lv 4 and 5 troops. The rest of the clan are TH7s who have the same strength of troops so theres not much difference between them. She's missed out three times due to been raided or the loss of a battle, just unlucky I suppose, as its been prior to the war button being pushed. She's maxed out all her standard troops to lv 4, hogs to lv 2 wont go to TH8 until all her defences, collectors etc are maxed. Even tho shes gutted she feels that she should be able to help her clan mates and feel part of the team by contributing troops. Surely this must be happening to other players out there. I just advised her to get her trophies up and stay outa the zone where she might miss out again. So thanks for that mate, good to hear other peepz thoughts.Quote:
Originally Posted by hawdog
100% no even with the ability to drop troops now. You can have people who join other clans, if they are open or invite only (if they get accepted) and troll or have weaker members join lower clans to weaken them by filling it with WB or giants etc.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pdoggz
It is more then enough for them to donate to CC to help attack.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tydorstus
Wow, That never crossed my mind Tydorstus. Yes, you're right, it could happen but what would any clan or peepz gain from that, ......some elixir, some gold, some DE. Doesn't seem worth the effort and like you said, players now have the option of dumping unwanted troops. If there are players like you suggest, I'm sure they'll be sussed out early and tossed out. Thanks for your thoughts tho man, I'm perplexed that there can be peepz out there that would do that, after all, its just a game,
Oh believe me, it is happening. But now that you can dump CC troops, the danger of wallbreakers filling up your war castles is gone.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pdoggz