Printable View
I suggest that when someone leaves a clan, his/her clan castle is emptied. I imagine it would be a lot of programming to have those troops returned to whomever originally donated them, so maybe just have the troops deleted instead.
This will hopefully reduce the number clan-hoppers that just show up for donations and encourage players to stick around in a clan for a while.
I get that some might just attack before leaving a clan but I'd let supercell figure out how to make this work:)
WOW!!!!!
Here's an idea dont give new people troops right away...
People can leave if they want to leave. Don't punish someone because you gave them a couple archers.
[QUOTE=Godsmack;289284]
WOW!!!!!
Here's an idea dont give new people troops right away...
People can leave if they want to leave. Don't punish someone because you gave them a couple
Of archers.
The only people that would care are clan hoppers. Sounds like you're one of them.
I don't really care what the consequence should be for clan-hopping, I just think supercell should somehow make it harder to do so.
How is it a punishment to the clan hopper? It would just make clan hopping a waste of time. And yes, spoken like a hopper.Quote:
Originally Posted by Godsmack
if you left a clan in less then X amount of time you have to pay X amount of gold to get into a new one. This means ether clan hoppers have to 'pay' to hop or that it would make sure they had to stay in a clan for X amount of days. I suggest 2 or 3 days to stay in a clan or pay 20 000 gold.
It should cost you a gem or two to leave a clan unless you are kicked by an elder or leader (basically someone who outranks you). This would slow down the hopping some. Other games already use this and it is very effective.
The way to stop clan hoppers is not by adding restrictions but by making clans beneficial. Right now people hop for two reasons.
1) to chat with friends. Supercell has made it clear there will be no people search and thus no good way to chat with people not in your clan. Therefore it is necessary to hop to chat. Nobody minds if these people hop.
2) to request troops. These people are annoying. They don't benefit the clan in any way.
To fix this, add more benefits to being in a clan besides chat and troop donation. Let the members donate towards the benefits. Examples:
- 10% additional hps to troops
- 10% additional health to buildings
- 10% faster resource production
- 10% faster troop building
- 10% more storage
- 10% more troops in camps
These could easily be put in some sort of technology tree. Use some exponential cost to upgrade the levels of these benefits and limit the donations per person per day.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Botia
What if a 'request to leave clan' button is added? Then the leader or an elder can choose 'yes' and the person leaves with no penalty, or 'no' and money/Elixer/gem is penalized? The problem with this is there has to be elder or leader online, otherwise request might take a while to be answered. And penalty has to be quite substantial for it to matter to the person, so maybe a small amt of gems is best, like 1 or 2, since unless the player regularly buys gems, even 1 or 2 is difficult to earn.
Someone should have to pay money if they were tempted to join a clan, but there wasn't the things promised? Like elder, lv of troops, or the fact that the clan was immature? I am no clan hopper, but a dedicated elder to the clan Farmigeddon. I think it would be unfair for that to happen, so I agree with benifets to being in a clan
Don't like this, because it doesn't acknowledge the consequences for people who aren't the intended target.
For instance, there are a lot of clan families with 2, 3, 4 different clans that members jump between to visit with or donate. It would really suck to lose your CC full of lvl 5/6 archers or lvl 3 dragon just because you want to go chat or donate to a feeder clan.
It's hard to come up with a perfect solution to stop the 'bad' hoppers. Even our clan has a couple of ex-members that come back to say hi from time to time and we love it when they visit. But it's those that come to request troops or leaves 2 minutes after they join that are really annoying (our clan don't really recruit very actively so we don't make false promises to get people). And I do agree with the above comment that some people get lured into a clan with false promises, so they have good reason to leave. So the issue is that there are different types of hoppers and hopping for different reasons. As far as the idea of adding clan benefits, it's good and supports the idea of a clan, but I think won't stop the chronic hoppers cos they can get the same benefits with the next clan they hop to. What if the game employs a loyalty period? Can only leave after joining a clan for a certain amount of time (to give the player a chance to build a relationship with the clan) or they can only begin to enjoy the benefits of the clan (extra HP etc) after staying with the clan for a while? But then this would not be good for the 'friendly' hoppers. Hard to please all people :p
Here's the simple solution: Why should you care? By donating to them you level up, if you don't like hoppers kick as soon as they request and they'll have to wait another 20