Wow nicely done bro . Glad to see u fending off mass hogs with 3 heal :) ..Quote:
Originally Posted by slimphatty
And nice mod on closing up the funnel ~
thanks for the nice feedback
Wow nicely done bro . Glad to see u fending off mass hogs with 3 heal :) ..Quote:
Originally Posted by slimphatty
And nice mod on closing up the funnel ~
thanks for the nice feedback
Friendly bump
In the last weeks, I have tried all kinds of anti-hog layouts found on the forums in an attempt to find THE one even if that's theoretically impossible, so when I came across this one, I decided to give it a try too. However, in less than 2 days, I have lost 10,000+ DE in 3 defenses, so I figured luck wasn't on my side for this one. I did close the funnels and make some slight modifications, but in essence, it was fairly close to the original layout posted. However, I don't want to sound pretentious, it may very well be possible that my changes were the reason of the failures I witnessed. Or maybe I just had too much DE in stock, and when one really craves for DE, one can always get it one way or another...
To illustrate how The Prime failed for me, I have 3 defense logs recorded and posted on youtube for everyone to see. I listed the main attacking force, i.e. giants/hogs, as well as number of spells used:
-32 lvl 4 hogs + 3 lvl 4 healing spells --> lost 3350 DE
-14 lvl 6 giants, 10 lvl 5 hogs + 3 lvl 5 rage spells --> lost 3532 DE
-15 lvl 6 giants, 6 lvl 5 hogs + 2 lvl 5 healing spells, 2 lvl 5 rage spells --> lost 3805 DE
There are hogs everywhere, although mainly in the first defense, lvl 4 ones at that. Basing on the defenses, I think that it may be a bit too easy to clear out the core for this layout. But anyways, judge for yourself.
Enjoy! :)
thanks for the effort in uploading the videos , my internet is down so it's quite hard for me to review all the video properly ~ will do once my internet is back on k ..Quote:
Originally Posted by moaob
that's huge amount of DE you are holding , like stated in the post , if u want maximum protection for DE , u should swap the DE storage with CC , i never once get my CC touch or taken down untill now ~ and i did it this way to protect my DE :) , when my de storage is at the center , I didn't get anyone touch my de before
my clan mate are using it up to crystal 1 and is working very well againt hogs + barch + loonz ...
giant + healer + heal / rage spell will take down at max 1-2 gold storage sometimes , but overall it works really well for me and other clan mate and I got good review on the prime without a problem too ... Weird it don't work well for u
my apologise on the losing of DE bro .
I have been using this base for a bit with my newer th9 account. To date it has done pretty well.
I have been hit with a bunch of big attacks.... and lose a storage or two at best.
I do keep the DE storage swapped with the CC unless it is empty....
Overall, it is a very good design. Even sitting with full gold and pink, it seems to keep the attackers away....
Reviewing your vids, in vid 1, you broke the ring of defensive units by putting a mine where a defensive item should be thus breaking the ring for hogs to go around.Quote:
Originally Posted by moaob
For vid 2 and 3, you then broke the ring of non-defensive units by having a cannon in there beside the DE area. That will draw hogs/giants/balloons to it breaking the ring further allows them to get to the core rather going around the ring.
I've tried out this base and definitely a big fan of it but for the purposes of any ring based anti-hog design, you can swap out defensive items for other defensive items and non-defensive items for non-defensive items but do not swap defensive for non-defensive and vice versa.
Great design superwolf!
thanks for the nice feedback bro :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Misthaufen
For me and around 8 of my clan mate using the prime at different league from gold 3 to crystal 1 , it works nicely too , at most we lost 1-2 storage , non touch my de storage when i swap with my cc and keep it in the middle of my core :)
im im really glad the base works well for u .. Gonna be my last th9 base :)
heading to th10 once I get some walls done !
Quote:
Originally Posted by moonsabre
Thanks for the detail review on the vids , my place internet is down , viewing the video is slow and quite tough hence i cant view it detaily , and thanks a thousand for clearing the doubt for the base :D
and I'm really glad that you love the base bro , it's my honour :o
And really appreciate your nice feedback ~
cheers
nice base.... i will use this hehehehe!!!
I think the wall placement should defend against wallbreakers a bit more or I don't think there would be a point in defending hogs. Make sure infantry doesn't get through.
Thanks for for the nice comment bro , glad u like it too :)Quote:
Originally Posted by wenks
Most of the anti hog ring base don't have enough wall to make more compartment at the outer layer , ring base usually focus on channeling the hog or giant to circle the ring and get blasting down by core towers and traps . It works well though :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Gumball8223
if u get raided more by different type of troops and wb . U can try Prime B :) a all rounder for most troops combination .
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...Giant-Wb/page5