Troop return

Printable View

May 20th, 2014
Why1

Troop return

I don't know if this has already been said, but I think that all surviving troops of a raid should return to your camps, maybe set a wait time for their return, but I would like this mostly because dragons, pekkas and golems are expensive and while barbarians, archers and giants may pay for themselves dragons and pekkas do not
May 21st, 2014
JustAnoth3rCoCPlay3r

Already been suggested

Yes Many times before and I am sure SC won't incorporate it.
May 21st, 2014
hawdog

Quote:

Originally Posted by Why1

I don't know if this has already been said, but I think that all surviving troops of a raid should return to your camps, maybe set a wait time for their return, but I would like this mostly because dragons, pekkas and golems are expensive and while barbarians, archers and giants may pay for themselves dragons and pekkas do not

Those troops that you mentioned are expensive are expensive for a reason. It's because you're supposed to use them to win big raids with a higher payoff, since they should be harder to raid.

Imagine you pick on weak bases with full dragon armies and your dragons never die, but you always win 100% against weak bases. Does that seem fair to you?
May 21st, 2014
Why1

They do already

Quote:

Originally Posted by hawdog

Those troops that you mentioned are expensive are expensive for a reason. It's because you're supposed to use them to win big raids with a higher payoff, since they should be harder to raid.

Imagine you pick on weak bases with full dragon armies and your dragons never die, but you always win 100% against weak bases. Does that seem fair to you?

They already attack everyone and this idea is already in the incorporated ideas so I apologize for the repost
May 21st, 2014
Emsboy

I agree with you.
May 21st, 2014
Thatguy147

Idea for how this could work...

Maybe they could incorporate a cost to return the surviving army... so if a dragon survived, to bring it back you would pay a discounted price to get it.... I don't know just a thought....
September 24th, 2014
motex

Quote:

Originally Posted by hawdog

Those troops that you mentioned are expensive are expensive for a reason. It's because you're supposed to use them to win big raids with a higher payoff, since they should be harder to raid.

Imagine you pick on weak bases with full dragon armies and your dragons never die, but you always win 100% against weak bases. Does that seem fair to you?

Higher levels will always attack lower level supercell should stop this. im fed up of being attackedby high levels who use there king and queens against me. Youcan only win a certain amount in raiding. attacks should be based on levels not trophies like other clan type games then it would stop the bullying. Lots of people are getting fedup of not beong able to save loot now. Dark elixer is even worse its capped at 2000 it takes ages to farm at 45 per hour. th 10 are capped at 3000 and they farm 300 per hour. So if theyget a shield they can recoup their losses. this is supposed to be a free game but you cant get on without gemming.
September 24th, 2014
Mallan

Quote:

Originally Posted by hawdog

Those troops that you mentioned are expensive are expensive for a reason. It's because you're supposed to use them to win big raids with a higher payoff, since they should be harder to raid.

Imagine you pick on weak bases with full dragon armies and your dragons never die, but you always win 100% against weak bases. Does that seem fair to you?

Yes it does. If I take the easy route, I get less plunder & less trophies. Low risk low reward.
September 24th, 2014
mbrianp

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mallan

Yes it does. If I take the easy route, I get less plunder & less trophies. Low risk low reward.

If you had dragons that returned to your base after attacking, you would never again have to spend elixir on an army. You could also raid nonstop. Sure you would get less loot per attack but your loot (and trophies) per hour would be incredibly high. This is why your troops do not get returned to you.
September 24th, 2014
klem70

Bad idea

It about committing the right amount troops to their job.

If you get all survivors back. All troops will go in every battle. So making it easier

I get wrong sometimes have to send more in. Can cos a lot more in the end if you send o few in.
September 24th, 2014
Mallan

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbrianp

If you had dragons that returned to your base after attacking, you would never again have to spend elixir on an army. You could also raid nonstop. Sure you would get less loot per attack but your loot (and trophies) per hour would be incredibly high. This is why your troops do not get returned to you.

this is a faulty generalization. And incorrect. The Dragons or any other troop could have a "shelf life". So after a set number of battles, your Trooper dies and becomes a tombstone. Still have to replenish troops, but not immediately after they survive a battle. It just seems wrong.

For instance:
Barbs Archers and bombers last an hour after battle.
Wizards Giants & Healers maybe 2-3 hours
Dragons & P.E.K.K.A. 4-6 Hours.

Not immortal, just worth the elixir investment.
September 24th, 2014
Ochausis

There is a simple tool for getting the troops back which you did not use.

Don't OVERKILL! :-)
September 24th, 2014
Mallan

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ochausis

There is a simple tool for getting the troops back which you did not use.

Don't OVERKILL! :-)

LOL 3:1 advantage "almost" guarantees victory. Its a true military axium.

Why bring 2 to likely win, when 6 will ensure the win with Minimal losses.