If it ain't broke........

Wish Supercell would stop bowing down to the whiners in the forum for every upgrade. Those happy with the game who enjoy playing it as is tend not to make comments, it's only the whiners of "ooohhh, please make the game easier for me" who seem to be in here.

My points -

Ability to dump war castle troops - the war castles are great for clan cooperation and clan management - if your clan cant coordinate it puts you in a weaker position in a war than a clan which can. Therefore it is clan vs clan i.e. Clan wars. If there is no coordination and cooperation - it's just individual battles. If people in the clan cannot cooperate - is the clan properly managed, do you want those people in the clan? And why should those clans who can cooperate not have an advantage over those who cant?

Constant loot complainers - get a grip, it's the same for everyone, doesn't put you at a disadvantage over others so put up and shut up. There's enough new loot available to those complainers through the wars.

Now the latest one is an opt in/ opt out button - should not be included for exactly the same reason dumping castles shouldn't have been - clan wars is about clan vs clan, it's about managing your clan, coordinating and cooperating - you all whined enough about wanting clan wars now everyone seems to not want it......

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DC0u

Wish Supercell would stop bowing down to the whiners in the forum for every upgrade. Those happy with the game who enjoy playing it as is tend not to make comments, it's only the whiners of "ooohhh, please make the game easier for me" who seem to be in here.

My points -

Ability to dump war castle troops - the war castles are great for clan cooperation and clan management - if your clan cant coordinate it puts you in a weaker position in a war than a clan which can. Therefore it is clan vs clan i.e. Clan wars. If there is no coordination and cooperation - it's just individual battles. If people in the clan cannot cooperate - is the clan properly managed, do you want those people in the clan? And why should those clans who can cooperate not have an advantage over those who cant?

Constant loot complainers - get a grip, it's the same for everyone, doesn't put you at a disadvantage over others so put up and shut up.

Now the latest one is an opt in/ opt out button - should not be included for exactly the same reason dumping castles shouldn't have been - clan wars is about clan vs clan, it's about managing your clan, coordinating and cooperating - you all whined enough about wanting clan wars now everyone seems to not want it......

---

Amen......

That is so very true

I haven't done much (or any) whining. Maybe an occasional suggestion to improve things, or agreeing with someone. And I agree with you on the loot from a th9 perspective.
On Clan Wars, though, many of us have a clan with friends and family - I'd call it the casual clan. Many in my clan love clan wars, and would do it every two days if they could. Others would do it once a week or once every two weeks. But we enjoy getting on, chatting, sharing videos. We would prefer that people didn't have to leave and rejoin regularly for wars, but we also want to be competitive when we war. My nephew graduates this weekend, there are parties galore, my brother will be busy with that all weekend - it would be nice if they both didn't have to leave the clan, or leave us 4 down on attacks.
I wasn't too worried about clan castle dumping, but I can see it being an issue and think it would be a positive improvement.
So I won't bash people for suggesting improvements to the game. If forumers hadn't rallied for Clan Wars would we have it? Not sure.

Hallelujah.

PREACH!

This forum is absurd, its a free game for fun. Just enjoy it!

They don't owe you anything, they can do what ever they please, get over it!

And so The Lord spoke…

however, about the point on dumping cc. It doesn't come down to poor clan management if an individual feels the need to 'troll' fellow members as a joke or as a leaving present. A few times we have had 1 or 2 individuals donate wrong troops (giants and wall breakers when we ask for wizards and witches) and the rest of our clan have been spot on. And as the donators remain anonymous it is a trollers paradise, but with the new update trolls can now be counter-acted, and who doesn't want this?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DanielB

And so The Lord spoke…

however, about the point on dumping cc. It doesn't come down to poor clan management if an individual feels the need to 'troll' fellow members as a joke or as a leaving present. A few times we have had 1 or 2 individuals donate wrong troops (giants and wall breakers when we ask for wizards and witches) and the rest of our clan have been spot on. And as the donators remain anonymous it is a trollers paradise, but with the new update trolls can now be counter-acted, and who doesn't want this?

---

Thats exactly what poor clan management is...... Good clan management is to ensure the guys you do have wont do this..... And if you absolutely have to go to war with new members in the clan you don't yet fully know.... Maybe you shouldn't be warring at that time or organise your clan so that all castles get filled by those with the correct troops as soon as the war button is pressed.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DC0u

Wish Supercell would stop bowing down to the whiners in the forum for every upgrade. Those happy with the game who enjoy playing it as is tend not to make comments, it's only the whiners of "ooohhh, please make the game easier for me" who seem to be in here.

My points -

Ability to dump war castle troops - the war castles are great for clan cooperation and clan management - if your clan cant coordinate it puts you in a weaker position in a war than a clan which can. Therefore it is clan vs clan i.e. Clan wars. If there is no coordination and cooperation - it's just individual battles. If people in the clan cannot cooperate - is the clan properly managed, do you want those people in the clan? And why should those clans who can cooperate not have an advantage over those who cant?

Constant loot complainers - get a grip, it's the same for everyone, doesn't put you at a disadvantage over others so put up and shut up. There's enough new loot available to those complainers through the wars.

Now the latest one is an opt in/ opt out button - should not be included for exactly the same reason dumping castles shouldn't have been - clan wars is about clan vs clan, it's about managing your clan, coordinating and cooperating - you all whined enough about wanting clan wars now everyone seems to not want it......

---

Disagree completely. The whiners are the ones that get things done. They add new ideas to improve gameplay. What are you doing? Absolutely nothing. So you sir should shut up. There is a small loot issue no matter what you say. And even the best clans in the world can have a troller that donates goblins. This needed to be added to fix that. The war base idea is so we can farm and enjoy clan wars. You can do the argument of coordination in clan wars would fix this but what about that one guy that is about to get kicked? Do you want him to give you bad troops before he gets kicked, ruining your defence chances? Coordination doesnt fix everything bud. Now be happy supercell worked their asses off for the majority and not for what you want.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Killer35616

Disagree completely. The whiners are the ones that get things done. They add new ideas to improve gameplay. What are you doing? Absolutely nothing. So you sir should shut up. There is a small loot issue no matter what you say. And even the best clans in the world can have a troller that donates goblins. This needed to be added to fix that. The war base idea is so we can farm and enjoy clan wars. You can do the argument of coordination in clan wars would fix this but what about that one guy that is about to get kicked? Do you want him to give you bad troops before he gets kicked, ruining your defence chances? Coordination doesnt fix everything bud. Now be happy supercell worked their asses off for the majority and not for what you want.

---

The whiners add ideas to improve gameplay? I'm just saying that it isn't always necessarily an improvement the people who aren't whining are the ones that are happy with it as it is - how can you call the relatively few who whine the majority? I'm just saying if you are happy, you don't tend to post.

As for me "shutting up" thought you said the whiners are the ones getting things done.....so let me have my whine!

Loot issue - matter of opinion, but even if there is one, it's the same for everyone so no one disadvantaged.

And yes, you will from time to time get that goblin (giants in my clan) donating idiot but again, same for everyone so how does that ruin defence chances? It's Clan Wars and if your clan includes an idiot so be it, it's just as likely your opponent will have one. Let's just say that due to clan coordination and management we don't have the non-team player in the clan anymore.

Totally agree war base fix is a good one.

What is the forum if not a place for us to share our views, my views are that dumping and opting detract from the necessity to coordinate clans and detract from it being true 'clan' wars.