good idea BUT, super cell will not add this, thats why they added boosting your heroes regeneration. to get you to buy more gems. i personally like the idea
Printable View
good idea BUT, super cell will not add this, thats why they added boosting your heroes regeneration. to get you to buy more gems. i personally like the idea
its really hard with the waiting system .. hope supercell takes a peek at this
While I do agree, and I would like to see it implemented I have one weak argument against it and a potential alternative or addition to it.
The argument is this, would you really be able to command any king or queen to do anything if they didn't feel healthy? I understand that this is a game but on a "would it really happen in CoC world" level it is a reasonable question.
As an alternative/addition, instead of instantly ending combat at 100% it would be nice to be able to send in a healer after the buildings are destroyed (if there was more time left) to allow her to heal your king.
This has already been ruled out at this thread : http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...this-thread%2A
But being allowed to use the entire battle timer so you could use a healer to do it manually? It would require you to plan ahead and spend resources to make it possible. A strategy that not many would deploy, but it would have a benefit.
It hasn't been ruled out in any of the threads. I spent a LOT of time checking to make sure it was good to post. "But NFriesen, I saw the word "Hero" in a ruled-out thread, which has to mean yours is bad", Nope. If you're going to criticize me for my thread, provide significant evidence as to why. Below is a list of ruled-out Hero ideas that you probably confused with mine, because I know that mine isn't ruled out. Nice try though.Quote:
Originally Posted by Concussions
Here's the list of ruled-out ideas from the thread you linked me. Note that there's nothing about my idea.
Also from that post, this (again nothing to do with my idea).Quote:
7.List of ideas and why they are ruled out
donating resources-Funneling resources, safeguarding loot (which is against game ethics and would make loot worse), selling loot for real money
player search- alot of players have same name, privacy issues
anything builder's huts related-would cause players to advance too fast, SC loses profit
gem mine/drill-same as above
converting loot- would unbalence game's economy
changing village name-could be abused
filter match making- easily abused, make finding loot harder due to all good bases gone
And here are the ruled-out ideas that have to do with Heroes (in the actual ruled-out thread).Quote:
5.To make a good Heroes thread if SC will add any in the future:
Any hero that contains King, Queen, etc are bad. Heroes related to troops are ruled out, Please remember to make a thread that contains a Hero non Clash Troop related. E.g. Cushion Prince.
Quote:
Troop/Barracks Related:
*Requests for all troop types to have a related hero
Thanks for taking the time to read this very long reply.Quote:
Miscellaneous:
*Add push notification for Hero ready (healed/able to attack)
it has been ruled out by simple logic. "MONEY"
Being able to use your hero anytime will render regeneration rate gem and heal gem to be obsolete as people will not use them anymore......
i think it has been explained multiple times as it is simple and logical. "They want you to WAIT so you GEM if you don't want to WAIT" Supercell's main product is "TIME CUT". Probably the reason that they haven't ruled out this idea is that they don't have good reasons to say that this idea is bad other than it will cause SC loss. :p
NFiesen,
Thanks for taking the time to link that all back in. What we are discussing here has not been ruled out anywhere that I can see. I am not proposing any additional hero altars, nor any specific hero by name. The idea here is to add new hero options available from the same altars with distinct advantages and disadvantages that can be switched so that only one is active at each altar. Any specific name I may have used was purely to provide context to the description of their dynamic. Honestly I could care less what their actual name or back story is.
I understand the money argument all to well. My original idea was to add an additional timer to switching a different hero. In theory this would encourage people to spend MORE gems if they don't want to wait for the hero to travel from whatever land they rule over normally.Quote:
Originally Posted by mikaru
sexy idea, but supercell may not agreed because of the "GEMS" thing...
you did yours, wait for supercell to decide.
Bump+1
could you put them at sleep while battling though?