Troops that don't die should go to camps.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Irishsmooth

Have you guys played their game boom beach? It would work just like on there where the troops that didn't die just go back to your ships/camps. There is no advantages to anything. You will still have to make troops that did die. It would just help save up more elixir that's all.

---

hey Irish, look at what I bolded above, you listed one of the main advantages in your own post. That is a pretty big advantage, it let's you save potentially A LOT of elixir.

I could use full 11 dragon raids on weaker bases in gold league and over half of them would survive. It would cost me only half the amount of time to recover the 4-5 dragons that DID die and I would be saving a ton of elixir that way. this is what you call OVERPOWERED.

Another huge advantage is the fact that this would let you raid a lot more often since build times would become shorter. Supercell makes MONEY off of people spending gems to speed up their barracks. If this were to be implemented, a lot of people would be boosting barracks less or never.

Along that same train of though, if your armies build faster, you can raid more efficiently to the point that it would be very difficult to find collector raids for farmers, because everyone else would be attacking so much, they would be snatching up those collector bases, giving them 12-16 hour shields while you are clicking next, getting even more frustrated looking for that next collector raid.

These are huge advantages that mess with the equilibrium of the game.

This would be OP.

Drop down in trophies, and raid over and over again, with the same 10 drags.

People already complain about farmers dropping trophies. What do you think this would do?

No way can you imagine the people the high level farmers using their golums and Pekkas all day. What about spam hog armies. When I use one only about 4-5 die each time it would be non stop raiding all day.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hogyh03

No way can you imagine the people the high level farmers using their golums and Pekkas all day. What about spam hog armies. When I use one only about 4-5 die each time it would be non stop raiding all day.

---

great point hogy, especially with the mass hogs, which are already the most overpowered troops in the game.

Are you guys starting to understand why this is a bad idea?

*see title*

Agreed. They should go back to camps or clan castle(if troops survived from CC deployment)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Irishsmooth

I've been playing this game for like a year now. I always wondered why when your troops don't die in a raid they don't just go back to their camps. Escpecially since I've been playing boom beach and they do this on that game. I think they should make an update to change this. It would help people save elixir so they wouldn't have to keep making troops.

---

Imagine farming people would go to bronze and just use a pekka and keep getting a ton of loot for nothing

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cyrand

I think your being a bit of an ♥♥♥♥ to be honnest, i like this idea, there would be no advantages except you save your troops that did not die!

There would be no advantages to any player, because everyone could do it.

and you just ramble, about they would need to make traps never need to be reset and clan castles always full...

No they would not, if you get attacked you get your sheild, whats the problem?

---

So if this happens I'm taking my lvl4 dragons for a walk in the 500 trophy range. Easiest loot ever. See the advantage yet?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Irishsmooth

I've been playing this game for like a year now. I always wondered why when your troops don't die in a raid they don't just go back to their camps. Escpecially since I've been playing boom beach and they do this on that game. I think they should make an update to change this. It would help people save elixir so they wouldn't have to keep making troops.

---

No, just no.

The whole point of the game is to use different strategies to get better. This kind of ruins a lot of the attacking strategy and would make the game too easy.

My opinion is that maybe we should get a portion of elixer back for troops that survive maybe like 50%? That way everyone wins. We still use gems to boost and no one's overpowered since making a profit on elixer is hard especially with th10