Tired of people donating what you didnt ask for???heres the answer

So.....this idea also came to me this morning. Has This ever happened to you??? You submit a troop request for lets say, 2 witches and a level 6 archer for base protection because you are saving up gold for an upgrade. You then sign off for a while.....once you get back online you peek into your Clan Castle to find 4 level 4 giants...... Now you are so mad and when you ask who donated them NO ONE will admit they gave them to you!!!! I HAVE AN IDEA! I suggest a troop donation history option. It works like this......each player in his or her profile will have a brief donation report. This will help to see who assists during a clan war, but at the same time will keep track of dishonest donators, who secretly donate crappy troops due to immaturity or whatever behavioral issues they suffer with. That way, you can see the worth of your clan mates generosity, and kick those who do not obey the clan donations rules. I think it would also be sweet to see the elixir value in your donations per season. For example.....I might spend 1 million elixir per season on donations for my clan.

P.S. Its an interesting idea.....Remember, I am more interested in holding annoying, trolling kids accountable who donate horrible troops for fun and assume no one will ever know!!

A brief summary would be good and maybe it could only be accessed by Leaders and co-leaders and maybe elders.
My clan is all about donations so this is a problem we have with both new and old members, our Leader had to kick his own nephew because of it, but your toll doesn't give me that option, it asks if I want to kick them, sometimes it could be a genuine mistake by a player that could easily be resolved by talking it through...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lecten

A brief summary would be good and maybe it could only be accessed by Leaders and co-leaders and maybe elders.
My clan is all about donations so this is a problem we have with both new and old members, our Leader had to kick his own nephew because of it, but your toll doesn't give me that option, it asks if I want to kick them, sometimes it could be a genuine mistake by a player that could easily be resolved by talking it through...

---

If it is a simple mistake then that can be cleared up when you confront the offender. The poll is only geared towards guilty, intentional idiots.

Some clans members give you what you want it is based on the clan you are in I guess

i dont think its a problem. the people who donate what you dont ask for are better than people who dont donate at all. also, you can suicide the troops given, use them in a raid, or wait until they die in defense.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PVZ2

i dont think its a problem. the people who donate what you dont ask for are better than people who dont donate at all. also, you can suicide the troops given, use them in a raid, or wait until they die in defense.

---

No one wants to waste a troop request because of some little brat. Kick them.

If u want that what u ask only u get that then this will not troop donation its like u buy troops from others.Donation is always from the heart and how much u can u will donate.Better suicide them if not want .

As clan leader i would love to see not how much an individual donated but also what troops! It will help me build a better clan. Weed out the inactives and beats who try to disrupt by donating troops not asked for. Being able to trash war castle troops as being suggested for upcoming update is a start😄

That's a great idea but maybe only elders co leaders and leaders could use it. And the leader can see all donations to see how good the clan donates. I think that is a great idea. Tell your opinion.

I understand your grief, but have you ever had some total newbie begging for dark elixir troops, when no-one, not even the #1 player, has them? I just give those n00bs lvl 3 Barbarians. (Moar generous than others in my clan who give lvl 1 archers)
The leaders, and co-leaders should be able to see what was donated, who donated what, what the request was for, and who made the request.

Maniacal Coyote
I got booted from Cyber for donating Lvl 2 Barbarians to someone's "Anything, please!" request.:mad: