Support, add this supercell
Printable View
Support, add this supercell
I have simplified my original equation some and diminished the glaring flaw it originally had, but it is still present. I'll keep working on it a bit more because the basic idea has a lot of merit.
Having the opposing clan vote is a very interesting idea. There is room for exploitation though by members switching to discuss who to vote for. There would need to be a way to temporarily block joining the previously attacked clan until voting was over. Also, since wars success is based on star count the only people eligible to be voted on could probably be reduced people who successfully got 6 or 5 stars, potentially excluding the possibility of an MVP if nobody did. Lets face it, if NOBODY was able to get more than 4 stars was there an MVP caliber performance that war? Also, after playing this game for a while I have come to learn that most players are too lazy to research the war results and make an informed decision. The voting screen would need to quickly reference stars, % destroyed, attacker rank and rank of target relative to the attacker.
One thing voting would not work for is facilitating a season reward for the best MVP of a war season should such a thing come to be.