Tracking Damage Done By Each Defense In a Raid

What if supercell could allow us to track how many kills each defense has in a battle as part of the battle log that we already have as well as how much total damage is done by each defense throughout the raid, heroes on defense could also get these stats. Also, we could get a heat map of our own base that shows red spots where troops are deployed most often against us and maybe green where troops are deployed the least. These features would help defense strategy and be really cool. Tell me if you think this is a good idea, and also if you have any other defense stat ideas. I think this game needs an overall boost in defense strategy. The only way to make your base good os to upgrade defenses which is fine but other than a few funneling tricks and standard layouts there isn't that many possible defense strategies. With a new emphasis on attacking and defending in clan wars, i think its time to make attacking and defending more dynamic. Something major needs to happen. Thanks for reading, and commenting!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DoRe

What if supercell could allow us to track how many kills each defense has in a battle as part of the battle log that we already have as well as how much total damage is done by each defense throughout the raid, heroes on defense could also get these stats. Also, we could get a heat map of our own base that shows red spots where troops are deployed most often against us and maybe green where troops are deployed the least. These features would help defense strategy and be really cool.

---

Some of this would be pretty cool. For the trainspotters amongst us.
Might take a fair bit of work, and add to the amount of data the game uses?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DoRe

I think this game needs an overall boost in defense strategy. The only way to make your base good os to upgrade defenses which is fine but other than a few funneling tricks and standard layouts there isn't that many possible defense strategies.

---

If this was true there'd only be a handful of bases used by TH8 TH9 and TH10s.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

Some of this would be pretty cool. For the trainspotters amongst us.
Might take a fair bit of work, and add to the amount of data the game uses?

If this was true there'd only be a handful of bases used by TH8 TH9 and TH10s.

---

There is some defense strategy, but I'm thinking there could much more. If they could add features that allow us to be able to use more strategy on defense it would be more fun. As far as layouts go, there is the accepted way of laying out your base, symmetry, wall staggering, and most bases are effectively doing the same thing with a slightly different layout. There are only a few specialty bases like anti-hog. Putting your strong defenses near the middle and segmenting walls is standard, not too much variation there.

I think that it would be very complicated for Supercell and would ruin the game. Why not have an edit part in which a Supercell programm takes in accounts the levels of every buildings to suggest you the most adapted base? You would say that it means the player won't have anything to do. Well, you're only asking for some tools to help you but the point is the same: the goal of CoC is that the player takes himself his decisions, not that the player is given every tip to help him.

Personally I like the idea of counting total DPS received and dealt... and frankly the game is already tracking DPS for and against. It doesn't seem like adding a sum function would be that problematic.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lempereur

I think that it would be very complicated for Supercell and would ruin the game. Why not have an edit part in which a Supercell programm takes in accounts the levels of every buildings to suggest you the most adapted base? You would say that it means the player won't have anything to do. Well, you're only asking for some tools to help you but the point is the same: the goal of CoC is that the player takes himself his decisions, not that the player is given every tip to help him.

---

You still need some skill to understand the information and make necessary changes. The point of this thread is not that my ideas are perfect. Im asking if you have any other suggestions on how we could add more dynamics and variance to attacking and defending. How about you add something to thread and promote discussion instead of just trying to find problems with my suggestions(they are only suggestions).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DoRe

You still need some skill to understand the information and make necessary changes. The point of this thread is not that my ideas are perfect. Im asking if you have any other suggestions on how we could add more dynamics and variance to attacking and defending. How about you add something to thread and promote discussion instead of just trying to find problems with my suggestions(they are only suggestions).

---

I guess it's just thatvitbis easier to point problems that to find solutions. Anyway, if you want tools to help the player know more about its village capacity to defend itself, it has to be simple ones. Maybe keeping track of how many times each wall has been broken would be better. Given that attackers are all differents, after a lot of attacks you will have difficulties knowing from which side you are more often attacked, but the exploded walls are often the same ones.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DoRe

Im asking if you have any other suggestions on how we could add more dynamics and variance to attacking and defending. How about you add something to thread and promote discussion instead of just trying to find problems with my suggestions(they are only suggestions).

---

You have aslo asked to say if we found that idea good. So I was answering what I thought.