Spot those useless clanmates!!!

What do you do when you go offline and a member gives you a useless unit like the clumsy GIANT? Or the blasted WALLBREAKER?

NOTHING!

If you aren't online you can never tell who gave you those units. And that's a BIG problem. Why?

1) If you don't find that guy and KICK him out, he's gonna continue donating useless units that take up unnecessary space.

2) If you have 20 archers and 1 giant you would have to clear ALL the archers first before the giant can go out.


Proposed solutions:

1) When you view the clan castle info, you can click on that unit to see who gave it to you. So if you happen to have 5 level 1 giants inside, just click on the giant icon and this will pop out: "Donated by xxx" POOF! xxx kicked out.

2) Setting which troops in the clan are allowed for donating. Let the leader have the option to select which units he wants in circulation in the clan.

3) Option to clear the unit out. This will give that selfish snot a second chance without harming you. When you click on the unit's picture/icon a "Clear out" option will pop out. Then a second confirmation will pop out. "Are you sure you want to clear the Level 1 giant sent by xxx?" Done! Clan castle troops cleared out!

This is the stupidest thing ever. Just appreciate what your clan-mates have to offer you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OhMax

This is the stupidest thing ever. Just appreciate what your clan-mates have to offer you.

---

Have you ever been in a "donate archers only" clan? If you haven't you're missing out on a lot. If someone gives you giants its a sign of brushing you off. Appeasing you by filling up the space.

sounds logical, but would regular members be able to kick out other members that donated useless troops? think about that. only elders and the leader can kick so how would a regular member react? he would have to tell the leader or an elder and then they can kick that person out. even though giants and wall breakers are pretty bad donations, it really isnt worth it to go through all that trouble to kick someone out that made the mistake of giving a giant or wall breaker (and goblin). you could later catch that player on chat and tell him or her "hey, could you not donate these troops?" and if there are more reports of that person giving bad troops, then you should kick that person.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cristian

sounds logical, but would regular members be able to kick out other members that donated useless troops? think about that. only elders and the leader can kick so how would a regular member react? he would have to tell the leader or an elder and then they can kick that person out. even though giants and wall breakers are pretty bad donations, it really isnt worth it to go through all that trouble to kick someone out that made the mistake of giving a giant or wall breaker (and goblin). you could later catch that player on chat and tell him or her "hey, could you not donate these troops?" and if there are more reports of that person giving bad troops, then you should kick that person.

---

Yeah the kicking is for the elders and leaders only.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Moseszator

Have you ever been in a "donate archers only" clan? If you haven't you're missing out on a lot. If someone gives you giants its a sign of brushing you off. Appeasing you by filling up the space.

---

I haven't but I highly doubt that this idea will come into play.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OhMax

I haven't but I highly doubt that this idea will come into play.

---

Ask anybody, the idea of "a donate archers only clan" has been around for a looong time.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Moseszator

Ask anybody, the idea of "a donate archers only clan" has been around for a looong time.

---

I know but what are the chances of SuperCell implementing this into the game?

1) be happy with what you get, it's better to have a full CC then not.

2) join a better clan, I'd be happy with any troops in my CC even WB now they are better. As my clan is almost all lv5 troops

3) don't be so dumb under your rules I bet your clan would be empty

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Stan2040

1) be happy with what you get, it's better to have a full CC then not.

2) join a better clan, I'd be happy with any troops in my CC even WB now they are better. As my clan is almost all lv5 troops

3) don't be so dumb under your rules I bet your clan would be empty

---

It's sad to see so many people in the dark... Archer only clans grow way better than any other clan. My clan is flourishing, and everybody's pleasant. Unlike you.

my clan is an "archers only" clan. but sometimes when we get new recruits, that new member donates a giant or goblins. when that happens i simply address that person and tell him or her our archer rule.

Other proposition i made few Time ago
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-Castle-choice

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Moseszator

What do you do when you go offline and a member gives you a useless unit like the clumsy GIANT? Or the blasted WALLBREAKER?

NOTHING!

If you aren't online you can never tell who gave you those units. And that's a BIG problem. Why?

1) If you don't find that guy and KICK him out, he's gonna continue donating useless units that take up unnecessary space.

2) If you have 20 archers and 1 giant you would have to clear ALL the archers first before the giant can go out.


Proposed solutions:

1) When you view the clan castle info, you can click on that unit to see who gave it to you. So if you happen to have 5 level 1 giants inside, just click on the giant icon and this will pop out: "Donated by xxx" POOF! xxx kicked out.

2) Setting which troops in the clan are allowed for donating. Let the leader have the option to select which units he wants in circulation in the clan.

3) Option to clear the unit out. This will give that selfish snot a second chance without harming you. When you click on the unit's picture/icon a "Clear out" option will pop out. Then a second confirmation will pop out. "Are you sure you want to clear the Level 1 giant sent by xxx?" Done! Clan castle troops cleared out!

---

Be grateful for the troops you get, would you rather nothing?

To be honest, I'm not sure why all the hostility.

Yes, I prefer archers, but:

I've seen giants stand there and tank for a few seconds while my defenses continue to pummel the invaders.
I've watched a dragon melt somewhere between 5 and 8 giants (now that they're splash) within seconds.
I've had a nest of wall-bombers swarm invading giants and do AOE splash damage to all of them.
I've heard of healers popping out and healing buildings that are under siege.
...
...

So sure; archers are really versatile. But depending on your base setup and your intentions for your clan hall, almost anything can still be valuable (save, perhaps, goblins on defense?).



That being said, I would like to see some kind of ability to control the troops going in and coming out of your clan hall. But I'm not up in arms about it.

~Fritz

giants are NOT useless they are good for distraction but wall breakers are.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Moseszator

What do you do when you go offline and a member gives you a useless unit like the clumsy GIANT? Or the blasted WALLBREAKER?

NOTHING!

If you aren't online you can never tell who gave you those units. And that's a BIG problem. Why?

1) If you don't find that guy and KICK him out, he's gonna continue donating useless units that take up unnecessary space.

2) If you have 20 archers and 1 giant you would have to clear ALL the archers first before the giant can go out.


Proposed solutions:

1) When you view the clan castle info, you can click on that unit to see who gave it to you. So if you happen to have 5 level 1 giants inside, just click on the giant icon and this will pop out: "Donated by xxx" POOF! xxx kicked out.

2) Setting which troops in the clan are allowed for donating. Let the leader have the option to select which units he wants in circulation in the clan.

3) Option to clear the unit out. This will give that selfish snot a second chance without harming you. When you click on the unit's picture/icon a "Clear out" option will pop out. Then a second confirmation will pop out. "Are you sure you want to clear the Level 1 giant sent by xxx?" Done! Clan castle troops cleared out!

---

Maybe for some clans this would be useful, but in my clan everything is accepted.

Ginats r helpful for attacking. However, wallbreakers r useless, but ive never seen any1 donate a wallbreaker.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ZainBhaila

Ginats r helpful for attacking. However, wallbreakers r useless, but ive never seen any1 donate a wallbreaker.

---

What is this Ginat you speak of mate? LOL.

The heck? I dont check back for a day and people start hating already?

Our basic troop to donate is archers but!!:

1. Giants are not clumsy, there are a good troop to take hits whilst your other troops can get in.
2. Wallbreakers are a very good troop to use, you just need to learn how to use them obviously.

Just be grateful for getting a full camp, would you be on here moaning if people were giving you Dragons and Pekkas?

Would be nice if when you request it would say "pinser wants archers" above the donate button:cool:

Firstly, giants arent that bad for those who raid,especially if they are high level. They distract while ur other troops destroy. And a CC that has 20 archers and 1 giants sounds better than 25 archers. Not to mention, it costs moore to make giants and wall breakers, be thankful you dont hav to spend your own resources to make them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Moseszator

It's sad to see so many people in the dark... Archer only clans grow way better than any other clan. My clan is flourishing, and everybody's pleasant. Unlike you.

---

I think your the unpleasant one here...

I think this is great but maybe the leader should be able to set a checklist of acceptable donations in clan or each person could have their own checklist of donations he would accept which would nullify the problem completely!