Best suggestion for wallbreakers omg

Hi Clashers!
I have a new suggeestion: If you want to employ wall breakers, everything turns dark, but not doo dark instead of walls. They are in the normal colors, so you can just touch the walls. After you touched a wall, the wall breakers go to the wall to break it. You can't employ them anywhere else

Is this idea good or good?

Hmm..... Well this might disrupt the flow of a battle. What happens if you want to deploy ALL wall breakers at once?
Plus, Clash of Clans is all about strategy, and being able to target walls takes that away. We have to learn their AI

And why just Wall breakers? If this was implemented, some would expect this to happen with giants (Highlights defences), healers (highlights troops), barbs (anything) etc.

Sorry, but it would be too OP and time-wasting.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kyumin2lee

Hmm..... Well this might disrupt the flow of a battle. What happens if you want to deploy ALL wall breakers at once?
Plus, Clash of Clans is all about strategy, and being able to target walls takes that away. We have to learn their AI

And why just Wall breakers? If this was implemented, some would expect this to happen with giants (Highlights defences), healers (highlights troops), barbs (anything) etc.

Sorry, but it would be too OP and time-wasting.

---

I agree with this person :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kyumin2lee

Hmm..... Well this might disrupt the flow of a battle. What happens if you want to deploy ALL wall breakers at once?
Plus, Clash of Clans is all about strategy, and being able to target walls takes that away. We have to learn their AI

And why just Wall breakers? If this was implemented, some would expect this to happen with giants (Highlights defences), healers (highlights troops), barbs (anything) etc.

Sorry, but it would be too OP and time-wasting.

---

I disagree with this guy. I think it's a great idea. Then it makes it really your fault if you win or loose. Also there are way more complex games out there than this idea. If you want to deploy all your wall breakers then hold down your finger on a wall. Also it would be cool if you can send a wall breaker at a building (Less damage though). And yeah I would love this idea and all the troops to be like this. If not all the troops then just wall breakers. Good idea don't let other people talk bad about your idea. They need either to support the idea or find another idea to post. For some reason people don't want to feed into ideas and help with ideas. Instead they like to just bash them. Moderators or supercell employees will say yes or no to the idea so there's really no point for people to tell you if they think it won't work.
-rakino-

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rakino7863

I disagree with this guy. I think it's a great idea. Then it makes it really your fault if you win or loose. Also there are way more complex games out there than this idea. If you want to deploy all your wall breakers then hold down your finger on a wall. Also it would be cool if you can send a wall breaker at a building (Less damage though). And yeah I would love this idea and all the troops to be like this. If not all the troops then just wall breakers. Good idea don't let other people talk bad about your idea. They need either to support the idea or find another idea to post. For some reason people don't want to feed into ideas and help with ideas. Instead they like to just bash them. Moderators or supercell employees will say yes or no to the idea so there's really no point for people to tell you if they think it won't work.
-rakino-

---

Thanks for helping me and thanks for agreeing. I also think they should say what to make better and not just diagreeing...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BobJackson

Thanks for helping me and thanks for agreeing. I also think they should say what to make better and not just diagreeing...

---

What do you mean by 'helping you'? Part of being a good ideas-guy is accepting feedback against them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rakino7863

I disagree with this guy. I think it's a great idea. Then it makes it really your fault if you win or loose. Also there are way more complex games out there than this idea. If you want to deploy all your wall breakers then hold down your finger on a wall. Also it would be cool if you can send a wall breaker at a building (Less damage though). And yeah I would love this idea and all the troops to be like this. If not all the troops then just wall breakers. Good idea don't let other people talk bad about your idea. They need either to support the idea or find another idea to post. For some reason people don't want to feed into ideas and help with ideas. Instead they like to just bash them. Moderators or supercell employees will say yes or no to the idea so there's really no point for people to tell you if they think it won't work.
-rakino-

---

Your 'fault' is learning the AI and using it strategically to your advantage. That's why COC is so unique. You have no control of troops, other than deploying them.

Talking bad of a idea is the best thing that can happen. If all there was was positive comments, then why have a discussion forum? If it's good we'll tell you it's good and propose changes. However, if it's bad, you need to listen why, and make changes. But there are those ideas that can't works, or don't fit with COC, and that's why we need people to say so.

I'd love to have wallbreakers target certain walls, but I'd also love to control troops to attack a certain part of the base instead of acting ♥♥♥♥♥♥ed at times. Wallbreakers can be quite a frustrating troop when farming.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tyrober

I'd love to have wallbreakers target certain walls, but I'd also love to control troops to attack a certain part of the base instead of acting ♥♥♥♥♥♥ed at times. Wallbreakers can be quite a frustrating troop when farming.

---

Yeah, SC said they are going to improve the troops' AI soon

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kyumin2lee

What do you mean by 'helping you'? Part of being a good ideas-guy is accepting feedback against them.


Your 'fault' is learning the AI and using it strategically to your advantage. That's why COC is so unique. You have no control of troops, other than deploying them.

Talking bad of a idea is the best thing that can happen. If all there was was positive comments, then why have a discussion forum? If it's good we'll tell you it's good and propose changes. However, if it's bad, you need to listen why, and make changes. But there are those ideas that can't works, or don't fit with COC, and that's why we need people to say so.

---

Well said, Junior. We'll said

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rakino7863

I disagree with this guy. I think it's a great idea. Then it makes it really your fault if you win or loose. Also there are way more complex games out there than this idea. If you want to deploy all your wall breakers then hold down your finger on a wall. Also it would be cool if you can send a wall breaker at a building (Less damage though). And yeah I would love this idea and all the troops to be like this. If not all the troops then just wall breakers. Good idea don't let other people talk bad about your idea. They need either to support the idea or find another idea to post. For some reason people don't want to feed into ideas and help with ideas. Instead they like to just bash them. Moderators or supercell employees will say yes or no to the idea so there's really no point for people to tell you if they think it won't work.
-rakino-

---

If you want positive feedback only, perhaps forums aren't the right place for you.
If we (as a forum) ignore ideas we disagree with it makes it look like this idea has community support, when clearly it has mixed support at best.

I don't like this idea for two reasons.

It will slow deployment in battle.
Troops in CoC are made to follow an AI. You mightn't like it, and it might do some dumb things sometimes, but troop placement and then doing what they're pre-programmed to do is basically just how the game works.
If you don't like that sorry, but asking them to redesign raids because your wallbreakers fail isn't a good solution.