Geronimosemiro's clan war spectator role improvement idea

Introduction:

Getting left out of something is really, really depressing. You kinda feel like a nobody, and that's something I sorta know about. Not that I am getting bullied though. That's why I purpose to make the left out people in clan wars, thus the spectators a role in clan wars and get rid of the left-out-depression. :rolleyes:

Chapter 1. What they should be able to do

Like I said above I wanted to give spectators a role in clan wars, too. So you might be asking: "how?".

Time for the main point, what I purpose is that spectators should become a helping hand. Meaning that clan war spectators should have the ability to DEPLOY TROOPS AND SEND IN MINI MED AND RAGE KITS LIVE TO A CLAN MATE'S BATTLE DIRECTLY.

Chapter 2. How it works

Troops:

You can deploy any troop you have currently unlocked on a clan mate's battlefield up to 10 spaces, however there is a cost for sending reinforcements. Also the troop level is based on your troop's level.

5 troops: 5000 gold
7 troops: 7000 gold
10 troops: 10000 gold

Strategy Help:

You can help your clan mate by tapping the screen before battle, telling he or she where to deploy the troops.
Designated spots will be in blue and can be seen very clearly.

2 spots: 2500 gold
5 spots: 6000 gold
8 spots: 10000 gold

Med kits and rage kits:

Med kits and rage kits are mini version of heal spells and rage spells. They are exactly one-third of the originating spell's power. Also med kit power and rage kit is base on your spell level.

Med kit: 15000 gold
Rage kit: 17000 gold

Chapter 3. Real life example

Let's say there is a player named A. A is a spectator, so he wants to help his clan mates. He can only HELP TWO TIMES JUST LIKE CLAN WAR ATTACKS, so he must choose carefully. He finds a clan mate named B, who is currently attacking. A can see directly how B is attacking and can strategically place troops and kits. He sends a med kit at the right timing and B gets two stars. In repayment, B must pay 5 PERCENT OF HIS CLAN WAR LOOT BONUS TO A. Also, if he thought A was a horrible player he could have REJECTED THE HELP. But suddenly, A regrets helping B because it cost 15000 gold, which is a lot of money for A's town hall level. However, soon A's troubles are washed away because A HALF OF THE GOLD SPENT BY THE SPECTATORS IS ADDED TO THE CLAN WAR LOOT BONUS AND WINNING AMOUNT. In conclusion, B is happy, A is happy, everyone in the clan is happy.

Chapter 4. Extra rules

1. Leaders and co-leaders can not be spectators from now on
2. There is no experience earned deploying troops in clan wars
3. If you are kicked out of a clan during a war unlike attacking you can not deploy to your ex clan mate.
4. If your helped clan mate does not get any loot from the battle they must pay a basic fee of 5000 gold.

Chapter 5. Achievements!

Super helper 1: Help your clan mate once. Reward: 5 gems
Super helper 2: Help your clan mate 20 times. Reward: 20 gems
Super helper 3. Help your clan mate 100 times. Reward: 50 gems

Geronimosemiro, signing off. :)

P.s. I know this idea sucks real bad but please be kind. :rolleyes:

Please leave feedback. :)

Forgot to reserve in case feedback makes me change the thread a bit. :)

I don't agree. This would eliminate strategy. Someone could donate 5 dragons to someone who is weak. That person would never learn or need to upgrade then. This is not a good idea.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fireforge100

I don't agree. This would eliminate strategy. Someone could donate 5 dragons to someone who is weak. That person would never learn or need to upgrade then. This is not a good idea.

---

The limit is 15 troops... read carefully. The bare reason why I made the max limit to 15 troops per battle is because of dragons. :(

Also added that you can only donate troops you have currently unlocked.

Hey bro, i was reading your idea and its a pretty good idea,but the main problem with it is that this will put one clan to an advantage to the other clan. Just imagine if a really high level player goes around small clans and gives them high level reinforcements, that the other clan doesn't have as just leaves. That is why spectators are spectators. The only real way to become a spectator is if you are a hopper and you are ineligible or if you are one of the lowest in your clan:

the he simple solution to not being a spectator is:
A. Gain trophies while your clan is in war or
B. Stay loyal to a clan

Although I love the idea of spectator's being able to participate, I feel your idea is too complicated. Imagine the server and game space your idea would take...

There is a flaw I see, I could start a ten v ten war clan with some of my Phoenix friends, and afterwards get 40 members to use ridiculous amounts of support troops and rage/medic kits.

Really cool and creative idea!

I don't think spectators should be able to help the person doing the battle though. It would give them way too many troops. Even for people with low town halls, fifteen barbarians would be a huge boost.

Instead, why not have spectators that can suggest strategies. Maybe the spectators can click on the screen to show where to place troops and are able to chat with the attacker...