Count donations of War Map :)

Here ya go:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marika[Supercell]

April 10:

Your ideas, our thoughts:

1. Saved base layouts - Yes!!! We hope to add this in the next update, but as always, no promises!
2. Lock in or "save war base" button - We had this in a company playable but ruled it out due to the confusion it caused when we were testing it. We hope to add more distinction between your Village and your War Base in a future update, with the focus of resolving the current difficulty in preparing your war base
3. Showing Donation History - we will not add this. It is not part of the normal clan mode and we feel it is "too hardcore" to be able to track who is donating what. See the next note though
4. Dump Clan Castle Troops - Yes. It will happen, hopefully next update, but no promises yet.
5. Claim an opponent on prep day - Great idea, and we talked about adding it initially. We'll see how your guys' war days goes and what the feedback is then. I would mark this in the "maybe to likely" range of requests.

---

So ya my point was defending an idea with an idea that will never happen is not a good idea...

Since the dump is LIKELY to happen, it makes your idea bad because of the potential abuse. This is a big issue here and you tried to shoot that objection down by calling my clan bad. Well I can say the same if you need some kind of indicator to "promote donating". (Note my clan has nothing to do with this statement but public in general) This is why I said you have not really been reading to what I say. Because this is the biggest problem here with the idea and you did not properly refute since you went down the route of a ton of argument fallacies to dismiss my objections.

I think it's unfortunate that Supercell deemed the idea of showing who donated what troops to war base clan castles was "too hardcore", because in my opinion, that would be the quick and easy way to deal with those individual clan members who are donating ♥♥♥♥ troops to war base clan castles.

In order to make it not fully public, then Supercell could make this visible to just the leader and co-leaders, who would be the ones offering up disciplinary action anyways.

Regardless, this point in moot since Supercell doesn't want to be "too hardcore", so having the ability to dump troops will suffice. Once the troop dumping feature is implemented, the original idea proposed in this thread can be junked.

Still wish we could find out who was giving ♥♥♥♥, would be so satisfying to give them the boot.

So do I and I told storyteller that long ago.

But that does not change the fact I am pointing out it is a bad idea to support an idea when the supporting idea is flagged not happening. It means this idea can't happen as well esp if they are giving us troop release.

bring up my post

Yes this will make more of my clanmates donate to clan wars and make us win more. Add this supercell. And you should add a poll.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheTreeMan

Yes this will make more of my clanmates donate to clan wars and make us win more. Add this supercell. And you should add a poll.

---

Added a poll now

I don't see how you would abuse this if it would only make your donation count go up. It would be obvious you abused it, I don't see the harm.

It's really too bad SC rules out seeing who donated what troops.. I truly think they're just trying to get off easy with not too much programming. Least they could do is hard-wire our clan troop wishes into the game. So I could turn off being able to receive giants/goblins/wallbreakers all together. But I guess that's a different idea all together which is probably not happening either.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lenskop

I don't see how you would abuse this if it would only make your donation count go up. It would be obvious you abused it, I don't see the harm.

It's really too bad SC rules out seeing who donated what troops.. I truly think they're just trying to get off easy with not too much programming. Least they could do is hard-wire our clan troop wishes into the game. So I could turn off being able to receive giants/goblins/wallbreakers all together. But I guess that's a different idea all together which is probably not happening either.

---

Exactly! :)

Up we go yo ho

Back to the top, start voting :p