Clan wars do not reward or highlight individual efforts at all.

Printable View

April 30th, 2014
Pablonius

Clan wars do not reward or highlight individual efforts at all.

Right now at the end of a war you get some loot an thats about it. There is no MVP, there is no #1 loot gainer, There is no chart that says "I did the best/most risky attacks. There could even be points you get after each war that ranks people up based on army ranks. Like if i attack bases with higher level townhalls than mine and i successfully defeat them I get +10 squire points, then after I reach 100 i get promoted to warrior or something. Or even better I can choose what i get promoted to and based on what i choose a certain unit of mine gets a bonus. Like if i level up to novice mage then my wizards get +5 attack or something. I think the war system is very good. But it isnt aesthetically pleasing for the individual player enough
April 30th, 2014
Phoenix64

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pablonius

Right now at the end of a war you get some loot an thats about it. There is no MVP, there is no #1 loot gainer, There is no chart that says "I did the best/most risky attacks. There could even be points you get after each war that ranks people up based on army ranks. Like if i attack bases with higher level townhalls than mine and i successfully defeat them I get +10 squire points, then after I reach 100 i get promoted to warrior or something. Or even better I can choose what i get promoted to and based on what i choose a certain unit of mine gets a bonus. Like if i level up to novice mage then my wizards get +5 attack or something. I think the war system is very good. But it isnt aesthetically pleasing for the individual player enough

You get loot.... that's about it, because that is what it is for... using hogs, or using mass dragons does not make you a "risky attacker", it makes you a cheap person who wants to win wars just so he can get the loot. Oh wait... that's me! I used GoWiPe for the first time. I got two stars. I'm so happy that the golems blow up when they die!
April 30th, 2014
enviem

Because it's called "Clan Wars", not "Individual Wars".
April 30th, 2014
Liderc

And...you've realised how pointless Clan Wars are.

The only thing CW did was screw up loot. The loot from CW is nothing and relying on 49 other people to do the right thing on a mobile game is about the dumbest idea ever.

I can't believe this is what people had asked for forever, possibly the most useless thing ever.
April 30th, 2014
Pablonius

Quote:

Originally Posted by enviem

Because it's called "Clan Wars", not "Individual Wars".

I knew someone would inevitably say this. But its still a video game where people want to progress and have results for how well they did. If I attack better than my clan mates I want them to know it. Why you ask? Simply because a clan/guild that doesnt have anyway of giving the players prestige gets real old/really stale, really fast. We all know trophies are a joke so I think using the system i made in my first post would make at least clan wars interesting. I have done 6 successful attacks in a row in my clans last 3 wars. higher level guys than me and dudes my same th level keep ♥♥♥♥ing up their attacks. So I want recognition for doing well. Games, especially online games, are suppose to fulfill that want.
April 30th, 2014
littlefish

You can watch the replays and tout the clan members that shined in their raids. :cool::D
April 30th, 2014
daz258

There are achievements for the individual to work towards.

But it's mostly a whole clan thing, if you want to recognise individuals do up your own spreadsheet program or something to show it.
April 30th, 2014
CousinSal

its a team effort, stop your crying
April 30th, 2014
facescraper

I think the thing to remember is it only just came out. They're going to tweak things and add things in future updates. Much like when replays first came out, they changed things a bit and added loot amounts etc later after we asked for them. I see where the OP is coming from... there's bigger issues though like not having a separate war base from your own base making farming extremely difficult for some players. Lets see what they come up with over the next few updates.
April 30th, 2014
porrotu

That's why my clan is undefeated: because we are One team... We the big players are constantly chatting with the smaller members to rearrange theIr village, attack strategy, star and loot gain, and advice to not bite what you can't chew... We don't fight for individual glory.. Clan Wars won't make a member grow from level 20 to 50 in a single war, but grow you with experience... We fight for collective clan success... :cool:
April 30th, 2014
SargeantZeal

Well, clan wars does not have these highlights YET, but I can safely assume it would be added sometime in the future when the bugs and glitches are fixed.

My clan makes our own individual highlights, like the leader giving the MVP award for a TH 8 that actually defended against 7 attacks, mostly hogs and even one mass dragons attack. For anyone managed to three star a decent base, clanmates would praise them and this does acknowledge their achivement. Same thing with greed snipes and 2 th level below attacks, most clanmates give advice that it should not be done again and what it would do to our clan's winning chances.

Even the replays shared by my clanmates are no longer only of the "looky, me got big loot from inactive player", they actually shared (and attacks) strong looking bases (usually with huge storage loot) using strategies that the more 'hardcore' clan members tought them. And they got appreciation from clanmates for doing this.

The conversion from farmer's mentality to a warrior's is a good thing, shows that clanmates are taking the recognition positively and strive to gain more. And if you want an automated individual recognition for CWs, it would come soon, but it wont be as fair as human recognition of your achivement.
April 30th, 2014
SillyS

Nice ideas

Definitely clan wars rewards well organised clans that work together.

How do you reward individual stars who help the clan results? Tough call. You can't reward someone for taking out an opposition base that is 5 levels higher than them just because the opposition forgot to put their town hall back inside. The people who claim those bases in the first 5 mins of war deserve a boot.

What about the high level players who coached the others to get the great results? That takes a lot of time and patience. Particularly if you are doing it in the lead-up to the war too.

If this system were introduced, perhaps clan leadership should decide who deserves the best "individual star" award per clan war? If your leaders always award their friends, well find another clan where they are fair. If you deserve such an award, a good clan will be very happy to have you.
April 30th, 2014
bandtx

That's because it's a CLAN war, it takes the effort of the clan to win, not just an individual.
April 30th, 2014
Terraist

Why not just make the fun up yourself then amongst your clan?! As the leader I watch every replay from each CW and do pass out a (symbolic) MVP each war. I also point out the coolest or most daring raids and even poke fun at the epic failures.

CW is new and what you make of it. The replays are all there if you choose to watch them and decided for yourself. I personally don't think it needs much else atm. As others have said, this is all about how well a clan works together and is not about each individual clog in the system.
April 30th, 2014
PrincessRorro

CW are not about loots

Quote:

Originally Posted by Liderc

And...you've realised how pointless Clan Wars are.

The only thing CW did was screw up loot. The loot from CW is nothing and relying on 49 other people to do the right thing on a mobile game is about the dumbest idea ever.

I can't believe this is what people had asked for forever, possibly the most useless thing ever.

Even if you don't get huge amounts of ressources after winning the CW, it's still a fun part to play.
It adds a little change compared to the raid bashing :rolleyes: