Have Top farming clan changed their ENTRY Requirements?

Printable View

April 27th, 2014
Dragonn

Have Top farming clan changed their ENTRY Requirements?

In our clan we recruit people based on their age, troop level, gold grab record and Town Hall level. Now we have added a new requirement which is master+ profile achievement.

We have peeple in our clan who literally do not know how to attack. We have long term members in our clan that has never pushed before, but that should not be an excuse to use Jump Spell on Hog Riders or Heal Spell on Balloons that is getting utterly destroyed by Multi Inferno Towers.

It was unbelievable, the first 3 war went horribly wrong. We had to kick those members out and recruit people with master+ profile. Really sad but this must be done in order for us to win a single war.

Anyone else have Master+ profile as one of their requirements now?
April 27th, 2014
Dolamite

Yep the clan war log exposes who the weak links are when it comes to attacking
April 27th, 2014
Luke121613

We didnt really change entry requirements, but those who dont know how to attack in cw get the 👞
April 27th, 2014
bonemancer

Heal spell on balloons actualy works pretty well. I prefer it to rage and if you watch a few of daddy's recent videos he uses one.
April 27th, 2014
Styper

Quote:

Originally Posted by bonemancer

Heal spell on balloons actualy works pretty well. I prefer it to rage and if you watch a few of daddy's recent videos he uses one.

Not against Infernos.
April 27th, 2014
DeCourseyyy

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragonn

Anyone else have Master+ profile as one of their requirements now?

We take a few things into account. If your stats are low but we've seen that you can raid up at 3200 cups, then great. The opposite is also true; If you havent traveled up to high masters but you have incredible farming stats, hop aboard!
April 27th, 2014
bonemancer

Quote:

Originally Posted by Styper

Not against Infernos.

Nothing works that well against infernos. The trick is to rage the balloons for the infernos and heal them for the wiz towers/when they get low.
April 27th, 2014
Fros

Master+ doesn't prove they're a good attacker... There are defense-only chAmpions who rarely/never attack. Also there are th snipers etc.
April 27th, 2014
XxA1xX

Quote:

Originally Posted by Luke121613

We didnt really change entry requirements, but those who dont know how to attack in cw get the 👞

We also have done this in our clan dont attack can't attack you get das boot.
April 27th, 2014
HamsterGubben

Quote:

Originally Posted by bonemancer

Nothing works that well against infernos. The trick is to rage the balloons for the infernos and heal them for the wiz towers/when they get low.

Bump! Was about to say this but had to check to not double post because I say so much in most of my post xD
April 27th, 2014
HamsterGubben

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fros

Master+ doesn't prove they're a good attacker... There are defense-only chAmpions who rarely/never attack. Also there are th snipers etc.

That isn't very usual though right? :) And defence only champion would probably be far better then many other people!
April 27th, 2014
jakewebs

People who get one or zero stars total usually get the boot in my clan.
April 27th, 2014
diLuca

Oh yes, the easier way to win is to kick members and hire new ones.

Ill stick to my old members and tell them what they did wrong by watching their replays and they are all thankfull by getin helped out.

To each their own I guess
April 27th, 2014
Terraist

Seems like a lot of you take CW way too seriously. Or the game in general.

We are a clan of TH4-TH10 with no requirements outside of vegan and adult members only... so no special game play achievements needed. We love being a wide mix of people as the lower players get great advice and troops and can develop faster. We have enough mid-high players to keep the donates good and everything equal as well. If you want to limit yourselves to only one category of player that is all well and good. Best of luck!
April 27th, 2014
Slicktype

I have considered myself an everyday farmer, but the CW attacks is def an eye opener for me and clan mates.
April 27th, 2014
diLuca

A vegan clan? Are hog riders allowed ? :D:D
April 27th, 2014
TheConfuzed1

Quote:

Originally Posted by bonemancer

Heal spell on balloons actualy works pretty well. I prefer it to rage and if you watch a few of daddy's recent videos he uses one.

Not if they're taking inferno fire...
April 28th, 2014
Xlcblx

Quote:

Originally Posted by diLuca

A vegan clan? Are hog riders allowed ? :D:D

Haha omg thats awesome
April 28th, 2014
CJH1X4X

Quote:

Originally Posted by Terraist

Seems like a lot of you take CW way too seriously. Or the game in general.

We are a clan of TH4-TH10 with no requirements outside of vegan and adult members only... so no special game play achievements needed. We love being a wide mix of people as the lower players get great advice and troops and can develop faster. We have enough mid-high players to keep the donates good and everything equal as well. If you want to limit yourselves to only one category of player that is all well and good. Best of luck!

Would love to be matched with these guys in our next war, nothin' wrong with taking an easy loot bonus...
April 28th, 2014
lulug

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragonn

In our clan we recruit people based on their age, troop level, gold grab record and Town Hall level. Now we have added a new requirement which is master+ profile achievement.

We have peeple in our clan who literally do not know how to attack. We have long term members in our clan that has never pushed before, but that should not be an excuse to use Jump Spell on Hog Riders or Heal Spell on Balloons that is getting utterly destroyed by Multi Inferno Towers.

It was unbelievable, the first 3 war went horribly wrong. We had to kick those members out and recruit people with master+ profile. Really sad but this must be done in order for us to win a single war.

Anyone else have Master+ profile as one of their requirements now?

Wouldn't it have been better to try and help the long term members get better rather than just kick them to the kerb?
I am really not liking what Clan Wars is doing to clans and long term friendships right now.. :(
April 28th, 2014
Kirky

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragonn

Jump Spell on Hog Riders

Is this Jump Spell/hog rider thing actually true. It sounds like one of those apocryphal stories.
April 28th, 2014
Kirky

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dolamite

Yep the clan war log exposes who the weak links are when it comes to attacking

True, but everyone can everyone has bad days. I wouldn't advise judging from a single raid.

I've 30ish stars in clan wars from the first 6 wars. In the 7th, I lost both raids. My BK was upgrading, but I made mistakes in both.
April 28th, 2014
smoggybowman

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kirky

Is this Jump Spell/hog rider thing actually true. It sounds like one of those apocryphal stories.

yep - there was a video around somewhere! sad but true lol.

I Wondered if wars would make all of the push and farm only clans rethink their recruitment/clan composition. . seems like it has!

we're lucky enough to be neither of these things I guess - we have quiet periods for looting and the odd race up the leagues but never specialised. We talk through wars and try to help anyone struggling to improve (there may be a boot if they're not interested in any help though) and so far we're 7-0 :)

I dont think that masters+ shows anything myself, it can be done with snipes and patience. I think keeping your members and helping them to take part and grow is the most sure way to get better at wars.. . who's to say that new members wont be equally as bad or hop off half way through prep day?
April 28th, 2014
Scorch

Unity still has no Sweet Victory requirements, but most of us have been to Masters anyway :)
April 28th, 2014
Kirky

Quote:

Originally Posted by smoggybowman

yep - there was a video around somewhere! sad but true lol.

sad but true, but serious? or a joke?
April 28th, 2014
AndyL

I agree....why take clan war so serious???

Quote:

Originally Posted by Terraist

Seems like a lot of you take CW way too seriously. Or the game in general.

We are a clan of TH4-TH10 with no requirements outside of vegan and adult members only... so no special game play achievements needed. We love being a wide mix of people as the lower players get great advice and troops and can develop faster. We have enough mid-high players to keep the donates good and everything equal as well. If you want to limit yourselves to only one category of player that is all well and good. Best of luck!

I totally 100% both hands and feet up, agree with terraist. Too many clashers are now taking clan war too overly serious in earning stars, that they resort to kicking, booting,...etc...if any members are poor at attacking and earning stars, the least, as a good and cohesive clan would do, is to coach and give them time to improve. If one war doesnt do it, the second, the third....just take wars for training and ey will improve. And most importantly...dont forget to have FUN! Its a game.....
April 28th, 2014
Godzilla86

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragonn

In our clan we recruit people based on their age, troop level, gold grab record and Town Hall level. Now we have added a new requirement which is master+ profile achievement.

We have peeple in our clan who literally do not know how to attack. We have long term members in our clan that has never pushed before, but that should not be an excuse to use Jump Spell on Hog Riders or Heal Spell on Balloons that is getting utterly destroyed by Multi Inferno Towers.

It was unbelievable, the first 3 war went horribly wrong. We had to kick those members out and recruit people with master+ profile. Really sad but this must be done in order for us to win a single war.

Anyone else have Master+ profile as one of their requirements now?

We raised all the requirements in all our clans recently but this has nothing to do with CW, we just wanted to raise our standards a bit.

It's not a problem if people aren't the best attackers for us, as long as they meet the other requirements and are active.

And even if our people would be really really bad in attacking, we would rather help them and give them tips on attacking (like we do now already) than giving them das boot.
April 28th, 2014
Justin2413

This is a requirement our clan recently added since clan wars as well.
April 28th, 2014
kmb08753

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragonn

It was unbelievable, the first 3 war went horribly wrong. We had to kick those members out

Wow. So instead of helping them with strategy, you kicked your long term players? Over a side game?

ok.

I have kicked people for sniping THs on players they should not be attacking, because it is selfish. But, I would offer to help people who are trying, not kick them.

Different strokes for different clans I guess.
April 28th, 2014
SpiderPig

Quote:

Originally Posted by AndyL

I totally 100% both hands and feet up, agree with terraist. Too many clashers are now taking clan war too overly serious in earning stars, that they resort to kicking, booting,...etc...if any members are poor at attacking and earning stars, the least, as a good and cohesive clan would do, is to coach and give them time to improve. If one war doesnt do it, the second, the third....just take wars for training and ey will improve. And most importantly...dont forget to have FUN! Its a game.....

Yes. The only clan war related kicks we've had were from people purposely stealing other people's attacks and causing fights about this. Besides that we take wars more or less casually.
April 28th, 2014
GameloverHD

Quote:

Originally Posted by CJH1X4X

Would love to be matched with these guys in our next war, nothin' wrong with taking an easy loot bonus...

I would love to see you fail against them. They might not be serious but they sure know how to work together;):cool: They have gotten the ultimate 150 stars in one of their wars and win consistently. Good luck bro:rolleyes:

All times are GMT. The time now is 10:29 PM.