We, in our clan, do not like the actual looting system which gave the full loot to a player that does only one star in an attack. The system feels pretty UNFAIR to us.
We would like to see it a function of the destruction percentage for each attacked village.
This will prevent the unfairness of seeing two players, one having done 3 stars, one having done 1 stars, having the SAME loot on the same village. Worse, a player that have done 3 stars get a lower loot than an other one that does 1 star on a slightly harder village... this is clearly unfair.
20140429 - Update :
- The Town Hall should get a bonus, for the Loot to be in adequation to the "Stars" rating", let's say... 30% of the full loot.
Now about the 70 remaining percents, something like a power function should be adequate and better than linear (linear was the first idea),.
On the graph :
Horizontaly : Percentage of destruction
Vertically : Percentage of the Full Loot you get
- Grey : Linear (0.7*x)
- Red : x^1.5 (divided by 14.3 for the graph)
http://i61.tinypic.com/28tc3fq.png
The Linear is not good enought, the red seems good to me, it means that ... someone who does 20% will get more than twice than a player that does 10% on a village ... the more destruction you do, the more you get for each new percent.
Add to that the 30% of Full loot for a destructed TH.
Of course a 100% small village SHOULD not give you more than 50% on a real bigger village, i suppose the matchmarking GOT this information and should correctly decide on the Max loot for every village.
Comparison between Original and Tweaked
Ps : These are examples, this should be continuous.
Percentage of Full Loot won Stars Number Original Based on destruction percentage Only TH destroyed 1 100% 30% TH Destroyed + 25% destructed 1 100% 39% TH Destroyed + 50% destructed 2 100% 55% TH Destroyed +75% destructed 2 100% 75% Only 25% destructed 0 0% 9% Only 50% destructed 1 100% 25% Only 75% destructed 1 100% 45% Fully Destroyed 3 100% 100%
Based on this spreadsheet i would say that with the "Based on destruction method", the Full loot should be increased, between +50% and +100% to get the same average loot than the "Original" Method.
20140429 - Update 2 : Multiplier Factor
Calculus done, the multiplier factor should be 1.74, for a village with 200k loot (original), it should be increased to 200*1.74 = 340k
Ps : The sum of loot in the "Tweaked" column is different than in the "Original" one because these are only examples... On a continuous table with all destructions between 0 and 100% with and without TH ... sums are identical (or math error from me)
Total Loot Percentage destructed Stars 200k (Original Method) 340k (Tweaked Method) 10 0 0.0 7.7 25 0 0.0 30.5 50 1 200.0 86.1 75 1 200.0 158.2 TH+ 10 1 200.0 112.1 TH+ 25 1 200.0 134.9 TH+ 50 2 200.0 190.5 TH+ 75 2 200.0 262.6 TH+ 100 3 200.0 348.0
- As you can see a player that does between 1 and 49% of destruction (no TH) will get more loot with the tweaked method, people which try to get stars should be rewarded.
- A player that only does the TH will get less loot than in the original method.
- A player that does everything right, destroy everything, will get more loot than before.
PS2 : My apologies if there are mistakes in my english, it is not my native language.
