Thanks for all the positive support in my idea! So far, NINE PEOPLE LIKE JUNK IN THEIR CLAN CASTLE! I could be biased in my idea by saying that, but I don't mean to. They have a right to their opinion no matter how stupid or noobish it is.:p
Printable View
Thanks for all the positive support in my idea! So far, NINE PEOPLE LIKE JUNK IN THEIR CLAN CASTLE! I could be biased in my idea by saying that, but I don't mean to. They have a right to their opinion no matter how stupid or noobish it is.:p
Please tell your friends and clan members about this idea, maybe it will help the idea come out quicker!
During clan wars I saw what had been donated and all I had was level one barbs
Great idea
I would like this feature, but... Why do you have people in your clan that donate bad troops to clanmates?
This idea is amazing. It would solve so many issues within a clan! Especially war! I was going to make a forum about showing a logbook of who donates what troops specifically in war. But this idea is much better!
I think it would also work by putting what you DON'T want, so that way if u want anything BUT giants, gobs, wbs, etc. you can easily stop people from donating those troops and allowing people to donate anything else.
I believe there should be a way of finding out who the member is that donated the junk (like when you receive troops in general), but I feel that this idea isn't the way to go.
This could cause people to get no troops in their clan castle, as somebody might only request for dragons, but since nobody is going to create a dragon for one person, that person who requested that doesn't get anything. This becomes a problem for the whole clan, as now they have a member who doesn't have anything in their clan castle, one of the most important defense structures. This can be abused easily and cause you to lose the war.
I believe the way to go is to have a log of who donated what to each person, so you can weed out the junk-givers.
If this were to be implemented, I think donation requests should not be able to disappear from chat by being drowned out by a big clan conversation, and requests would only disappear once they were full with the troops requested. This would prevent requesting when nobody donates for a long while and your request is gone because it got drowned out and nobody has the chance to give you your troops anymore (unless you request again after 20mins)
Where else would they be?Quote:
Originally Posted by chummer1010