Clan Castle donations MUST match request

How can this happen? Well, let's say I request and type "archer and wizards". Can't someone still give me those dreaded goblins, giants, and wall breakers, it might even be on accident, but it can still happen.

Back to the original question; when you request, instead of typing, it shows you all the troops (similar to the selection where you now donate the troops) so, you can select the troops you want in your clan castle. But you will not see any troops, to request, that will not fit in your clan castle capacity. There should also be an option for if you would like a specific amount of specific troops, so if you have a level two clan castle and someone gives you a healer because that is the troop you requested, then what would happen with that one extra space(you would not request the troops archers and healers because you might get fifteen archers)? Well, there would be a "pop-up" question for before you start selecting troops, such as, "Which Donation Type Would You Like To Request?" and have one button say "Basic" and the other say "Advanced. In the Basic Donation type you can request selected troops and get any amount of any of those troops. In the Advanced Donation type you may request a certain AMOUNT of troops of selected troops by tapping it the desired amount's times, so for a level two clan castle, you may request "one healer" by tapping the healer once, and "one archer" by tapping the archer once. You may request a larger sum of troops than what is in your clan castle to give a little variety among your troops, but you will not receive any more than your clan castle capacity. Now that you have seen everything from the requester's side of the plan, let's show you the donator's side of the plan.

When a donator taps the "Donate" button in the clan chat section, because all the other troops are either not on the screen, or blacked out, the only troops the donator is able to tap and donate is archers and wizards (referring to the first example). And when s/he donates the specific amount requested for an Advanced Donation type that troop will then black out, similar to what happens now when you run of out of THE troop to donate in your army camps.

Now, instead of typing "archers and wizards" and receiving goblins, giants, and wall breakers, you can select archers and wizards and receive only archers and wizards. Please tell me if you need another explanation, or if you have any tweaks to it!

This is a good idea! We absolutely need this!

Glad you like it!

Good idea, especially now with Clan Wars and people getting dumped rubbish they do not want by rogue members.

im happy to get what i ask for but of people have troops im happy to get abything

Even if you don't mind, you WILL mind at a higher level. And you still say you are happy to get what you want, why not get what you want all the time?

as I posted a few days ago, there must be a logs for those noobish donors.. so we can warn them to get what we requested. At this time, we can't see who donated what.

Exactly, there is a huge problem with troop donations and so many ways to solve it, so it should be solved soon!

I think this is an great idea, its good for both requests. Clan war or no clan war.

Yes I like this idea, but I think it should NOT show all the troops in the game, when " typing ". If you saw all the troops in the game, wouldn't everyone request for P.E.K.K.A.'s? What if your clan doesn't have P.E.K.K.A.'s? It should show everything up to the best barrack/dark barrack in your clan. That way it is possible. The problem with mine is inactivity... I don't know. Just if someone is inactive kick them :]