Printable View
So ive noticed that when we donate to other clan members on preperation day, the donations dont add to our other donations outside of the clan war, why is that? If i donated 10 dragons to my clan, then shouldnt i get 200 more donations added? So ya thats all.
I had the same feeling when cw started and posted a similar thread. A valid point was made that adding defence donations to your total donations and achievement donations could result in players mass donating giants to improve their donation stats and get achievements more quickly. In normal chats we can usually monitor this using the reporting of who donated when they donate. However, when donating defece troops in cw, there's no notification of who donates what, so there's no way to police it. Until that is changed, it's probably better that defence donations don't count.
With those troop counts not counting though, and no notification of who donated to you than wont that discourage other players from donatingto the clan war castles? I mean if i dont donate to someone becuase ill wont get anything in return then why would i? I know someone else will. I see your points about people donating giants to raise their donation count, but if supercell added a notification of who donated to the castle that would solve the problem.
Isn't the issue of players donating giants the same whether in the clan war or normal gameplay? The big difference is, no one can see who did it so you have to figure it out. I think players should get credit, defensive or not. They still cost elixer, take time to build, etc. so why no credit. We had leaders and co-leaders create our defense (with a few "rogue" donations) and its a real drain on resources with no credit. There should be some credit for the clan war donations!
Well said ddawgQuote:
Originally Posted by Ddawg
A supercell Employee said they won't be adding this anytime soon, Because it doesn't count as a donation, it's only a donation for help in a feature. If you know what I mean.
Where as the clan donation is much different. And it was there to see how many troops people donated in the Clan, not in Clan wars.
It could affect requirements.. I.e. 500 donations for Elder, "Hey look I'll give a troop which takes a lot of housing space, and donate it in Clan wars, but he didn't ask for that, But he won't know!" See? It could really affect quite a few things.