Elder Status, Co-Leader Status, and Vote Kick.

Printable View

March 13th, 2013
Nephytitus

Elder Status, Co-Leader Status, and Vote Kick.

Changes to Elder Status, New Co-Leader Status and a Vote Kick

Elder(Old)
-Invite People
-Kick Members
-Promote Members to Elder

Elder(New)
-Invite People
-Start a Vote Kick

Elders should not have the right to promote others. Reason being is that sometimes a wrong promotion by Elders can lead to the destruction of a clan and i know a lot of people that has been through this. This also stop Elders from promoting their friends who doesn't deserve the promotion.

Co-Leader
-Invite People
-Kick Members without a Vote Kick
-Promote People to Elders
-Demote Elders to Members
-Change Clan Board

Sometimes the Leader of the clan can't always be on and or different time zone than most, we need a Co-Leader which can help maintain the law of the clan!

Vote Kick
-Needs 2 or 3 Elders to accept a kick
-Elders can start a Vote Kick

Vote Kick will stop a clan from being wiped out by a wrong promotion! This has always been an issue of a lot clans who doesn't promote everyone to elder status. This also helps wrongful kicks by elders.

These are just my 2 cents into it, just want to know what you guys think of it.
March 13th, 2013
rnzu

I like the vote to kick system for elders, very good suggestion!
March 13th, 2013
K3mpy86

Vote kick - great idea.

but a new rank system plz read the sticky...
March 13th, 2013
BlackDynomite

Think this is good... Kinda

If they choose to add co-leader.. How about if the clan leader can decide what powers people have. A menu that has all clan powers and what status you have to have to be able to use them. E.g a clan leader can set it so only leader and co-leader can kick, but not elder, or vice versa, or so that normal members are able to invite or not. List goes on.
March 13th, 2013
markgraaf

No

Quote:

Originally Posted by BlackDynomite

If they choose to add co-leader.. How about if the clan leader can decide what powers people have. A menu that has all clan powers and what status you have to have to be able to use them. E.g a clan leader can set it so only leader and co-leader can kick, but not elder, or vice versa, or so that normal members are able to invite or not. List goes on.

No That's not a smart idea, the game grepolis has got that already and it wil not be fun to let this game look like grepolis
March 13th, 2013
JtB

Posts like this are why they updated the wall breaker ai, people whining about something that does not need fixing. Elder is your co leader, it works fine the way it is.
March 14th, 2013
K3mpy86

Quote:

Originally Posted by JtB

Posts like this are why they updated the wall breaker ai, people whining about something that does not need fixing. Elder is your co leader, it works fine they way it is.

But u need to understand that alot of people want to reward players with a title and then every now and then u will have the troll come along and kick everyone. Sorry man but elder is not fine, your right elder is a co leader but the system needs to be looked at and supercell is aware of this and that is why its in the sticky and that is why people are constantly making requests for it to be discussed.

votekick- love it
March 14th, 2013
JtB

Quote:

Originally Posted by K3mpy86

But u need to understand that alot of people want to reward players with a title and then every now and then u will have the troll come along and kick everyone. Sorry man but elder is not fine, your right elder is a co leader but the system needs to be looked at and supercell is aware of this and that is why its in the forums.

votekick- love it

Make everybody elder and only the leader can kick, problem solved. See how easy that was?
March 14th, 2013
K3mpy86

Quote:

Originally Posted by JtB

Make everybody elder and only the leader can kick, problem solved. See how easy that was?

Than your just using elder as kick prevention (which what it currently is) and defeats the purpose of the title
March 14th, 2013
JtB

Quote:

Originally Posted by K3mpy86

Than your just using elder as kick prevention (which what it currently is) and defeats the purpose of the title

It's a solution to the dilemma that you raised. There are simple solutions to these problems, Supercell needs to address real problems that affect gameplay, not wasting their time on power trips within clans.
March 14th, 2013
K3mpy86

Quote:

Originally Posted by JtB

It's a solution to the dilemma that you raised. There are simple solutions to these problems, Supercell needs to address real problems that affect gameplay, not wasting their time on power trips within clans.

Power trips in clans is a problem that effects gameplay now thats a dilemma that you raised :eek:
Haha <3 u jtb
March 14th, 2013
JtB

Quote:

Originally Posted by K3mpy86

Power trips in clans is a problem that effects gameplay now thats a dilemma that you raised :eek:
Haha <3 u jtb

Co leader is advocated my children and poor leaders who don't know how to lead.
March 14th, 2013
Indecisive15

+1

I just posted a forum about the elder thing and then I see this. I hope this get put in the game. My clan is moving up to top 200 and this could save my clan
March 14th, 2013
Blackshadoo

Not A Good Solution.

Quote:

Originally Posted by JtB

It's a solution to the dilemma that you raised. There are simple solutions to these problems, Supercell needs to address real problems that affect gameplay, not wasting their time on power trips within clans.

If everyone is elder in a clan a lot can go wrong. You can have people who join and receive elder and then reject any and everyone who tries to join. You also allow people in the clan to troll and be as rude as they want (if you have restrictions against it) and nothing can be done about it. That one person who cannot be kicked may eventually push people to edge where they start leaving and other's follow all because one player (elder) could not be kicked. From that point on the clan slowly gets ruined until the leader finally comes on but by that time the damage is done. We need a new hierarchy system period.

Thanks,

Shady
March 14th, 2013
JtB

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blackshadoo

If everyone is elder in a clan a lot can go wrong. You can have people who join and receive elder and then reject any and everyone who tries to join. You also allow people in the clan to troll and be as rude as they want (if you have restrictions against it) and nothing can be done about it. That one person who cannot be kicked may eventually push people to edge where they start leaving and other's follow all because one player (elder) could not be kicked. From that point on the clan slowly gets ruined until the leader finally comes on but by that time the damage is done. We need a new hierarchy system period.

Thanks,

Shady

If an elder acts like that the clan leader simply kicks them, problem solved. If the leader is hardly on to lead their clan, they are not a very good leader.
March 17th, 2013
Nephytitus

Quote:

Originally Posted by JtB

It's a solution to the dilemma that you raised. There are simple solutions to these problems, Supercell needs to address real problems that affect gameplay, not wasting their time on power trips within clans.

It does affect gameplay when it results in killing a clan due to stupidity of others. Giving elder status is a reward system imo and not something to do with power trips. Elders are suppose to help you clan and give advice to new comers and lay down the law when needed.
March 17th, 2013
Breathtaking

Don't agree, very much depends on your clan and how careful you are at choosing the right people,
March 17th, 2013
Nephytitus

Quote:

Originally Posted by Breathtaking

Don't agree, very much depends on your clan and how careful you are at choosing the right people,

Some clans are careful, but a lot of starting clans aren't, this is just a way to protect them. Everyone makes mistakes and it only takes 1 to fk it all up.
March 17th, 2013
Moseszator

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ight=Terrorism

Already suggested here.
March 17th, 2013
Racoocrazy

Vote kick is looking amazing, I feel they should add that and co-leader would be awesome but probably not going to happen sorry
March 20th, 2013
Nephytitus

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moseszator

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ight=Terrorism

Already suggested here.

the thing we had in common was the co-leader status....
November 27th, 2014
Tellas32

I think

I think you should put the powers they have like this person has the power to kick and this one can promote
November 28th, 2014
Tiler

The only clans that seem to be having problems with kicking are those who don't promote properly. There's no need to vote in my clan because Elders don't kick unless someone explicitly breaks the clan rules. Leaders kick anyone they feel need to be kicked. It's a good system the way it is, it's user error that causes problems