Giant WIPE?!

So y'all know about GO WIPE. Here's my attempt at making a cheaper version replacing the golems with giants. I'm a lvl 70 TH8. Attached are my three most recent battles with this composition. I tried this in silver one / gold three / trophy range 1300s.

What do y'all think? Am I fighting in too low of a trophy range to really test it? Has anyone else tried to replace golems in go wipe with giants?

Army composition:

2 Pekkas
8 wallbreakers
17 wizards
12 giants
6 archers

2 heal spells
1 rage spell

Basically drop an archer to set off any traps. Drop a Couple of giants to draw fire. Then as many wallers as necessary to break through. Then the rest of the giants. Then deploy wizards to clear out any outside buildings that might distract the pekkas. Then finally the pekkas. Heal & rage as needed.

P.S. I hate Pekkas that stray off on their own.

It would seem to me you would need to have an equal amount of hit points at the least from Giants to equal at least 2 Golems... and if my math isn't horrible, a rough guess would be around 20ish? Plus, splash damage will take out a lot more DPS then on two golems. Consider this, it will never be as effective, but i think this would definitely be a viable option in Gold at the least.