Defence in clan wars!!!!!! Must read! must vote!

Hey, I think that adding a reward for defense in the wars would add a greater edge for the new clan wars system. This would make ppl choose their attacks more carefully. This would make clan wars more exciting. I have two proposals

Proposal 1- players can win up to 3 stars for their clan depending how successful your defense was(what percent enemy was able to achieve)


0-17% 3 stars awarded to clan
18-34% 2 stars awarded to clan
35-49% 1 star awarded to clan






Proposal 2
1 star is awarded for every successful defense no matter what percentage

Stars for a successful defense... Could use work, but I kinda like it! Good thought.

It's an equalizer, and an effective one too.

I don't think proposal one is necessary because of the smaller guys in clans could catch napoleon fever and try to go for a strong guy and end up getting like 10%, you guys know where im coming from right? so I prefer proposal 2

Indirectly, you are al ready getting stars for successfil defenses by them not getting stars. You get a successful defense, they wasted an attack and get no stars, when they could have gotten up to three. You basically get 3 stars for your clan.

I'm all in :D

You should get one star for a successful defense and a quarter of the Loot they got for attacking you. (Win bonus)

But you're already getting a reward for a successful defense. If someone attacks me and I defend (0 stars), then the attacker's clan is getting no stars from that attack. That in and of itself is a reward. Consider the fact that you can only attack twice per war. If someone uses up one of their attacks unsuccessfully attacking me, and my enemy's clan gets 0 stars instead of 1-3, them not getting stars is essentially the same as my clan gaining stars.

Already there is a big incentive to choose your target carefully since you only have two attacks per war.

I love this idea generally. It equalizes the attack side and the defense side of the system.

However, I think proposal 1 is more usable and effective.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DOODYDUM

I love this idea generally. It equalizes the attack side and the defense side of the system.

However, I think proposal 1 is more usable and effective.

---

Exactly my point

Smart. Defense and Base Tactics should count towards you score. Vote yes

Needs some tweaks but I like it

I dont hate the idea but have to disagree if this is to be implemented in clan wars.

First of all, while the idea encourages players to have better defenses (thats a good thing) it also discourages attacking in clan war. An idea aiming to improve the player's defensive rewards should not discourage attacking even further, losing one of our two precious attacks with a failed assault is punishment enough IMO. No need to aggravate it by making your opponent gain one or more stars from your loss.

A lot of other issues could emerge if stars can be gained by winning defenses. People could delibarately sabotage a war by purposely losing and giving stars to the opponent. Countless of under-experienced players have been kicked out of clans because they are unable to win against opponents seemingly at their level, and this could make it worse.

If you already have decently upgraded defenses, you could just copy an awesome design for defense, but for offense, army composition is not enough, you need experience and confidence to use them against a good defense.

Rewarding defense is a great thing for clan wars, but further punishing offense is not agreeable by me.

Thank you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SargeantZeal

I dont hate the idea but have to disagree if this is to be implemented in clan wars.

First of all, while the idea encourages players to have better defenses (thats a good thing) it also discourages attacking in clan war. An idea aiming to improve the player's defensive rewards should not discourage attacking even further, losing one of our two precious attacks with a failed assault is punishment enough IMO. No need to aggravate it by making your opponent gain one or more stars from your loss.

A lot of other issues could emerge if stars can be gained by winning defenses. People could delibarately sabotage a war by purposely losing and giving stars to the opponent. Countless of under-experienced players have been kicked out of clans because they are unable to win against opponents seemingly at their level, and this could make it worse.

If you already have decently upgraded defenses, you could just copy an awesome design for defense, but for offense, army composition is not enough, you need experience and confidence to use them against a good defense.

Rewarding defense is a great thing for clan wars, but further punishing offense is not agreeable by me.

Thank you.

---

This is a great point thank you for your feedback, not all of my ideas are ment to come true lol

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Stuberstar

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SargeantZeal

I dont hate the idea but have to disagree if this is to be implemented in clan wars.

First of all, while the idea encourages players to have better defenses (thats a good thing) it also discourages attacking in clan war. An idea aiming to improve the player's defensive rewards should not discourage attacking even further, losing one of our two precious attacks with a failed assault is punishment enough IMO. No need to aggravate it by making your opponent gain one or more stars from your loss.


A lot of other issues could emerge if stars can be gained by winning defenses. People could delibarately sabotage a war by purposely losing and giving stars to the opponent. Countless of under-experienced players have been kicked out of clans because they are unable to win against opponents seemingly at their level, and this could make it worse.


If you already have decently upgraded defenses, you could just copy an awesome design for defense, but for offense, army composition is not enough, you need experience and confidence to use them against a good defense.


Rewarding defense is a great thing for clan wars, but further punishing offense is not agreeable by me.


Thank you.

---

This is a great point thank you for your feedback, not all of my ideas are ment to come true lol

---

No where in this world that all ideas will come true bro, I'm just stating the IF here, and what i think could happen. Its a good idea to give more incentives for defense in coc generally, not just for CW.

Thanks for your reply and Clash On!