Defence in clan wars!!!!!! Must read! must vote!

Hey, I think that adding a reward for defense in the wars would add a greater edge for the new clan wars system. This would make ppl choose their attacks more carefully. This would make clan wars more exciting. I have two proposals

Proposal 1- players can win up to 3 stars for their clan depending how successful your defense was(what percent enemy was able to achieve)


0-17% 3 stars awarded to clan
18-34% 2 stars awarded to clan
35-49% 1 star awarded to clan






Proposal 2
1 star is awarded for every successful defense no matter what percentage

Stars for a successful defense... Could use work, but I kinda like it! Good thought.

It's an equalizer, and an effective one too.

I don't think proposal one is necessary because of the smaller guys in clans could catch napoleon fever and try to go for a strong guy and end up getting like 10%, you guys know where im coming from right? so I prefer proposal 2

Indirectly, you are al ready getting stars for successfil defenses by them not getting stars. You get a successful defense, they wasted an attack and get no stars, when they could have gotten up to three. You basically get 3 stars for your clan.

I'm all in :D

You should get one star for a successful defense and a quarter of the Loot they got for attacking you. (Win bonus)

But you're already getting a reward for a successful defense. If someone attacks me and I defend (0 stars), then the attacker's clan is getting no stars from that attack. That in and of itself is a reward. Consider the fact that you can only attack twice per war. If someone uses up one of their attacks unsuccessfully attacking me, and my enemy's clan gets 0 stars instead of 1-3, them not getting stars is essentially the same as my clan gaining stars.

Already there is a big incentive to choose your target carefully since you only have two attacks per war.

I love this idea generally. It equalizes the attack side and the defense side of the system.

However, I think proposal 1 is more usable and effective.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DOODYDUM

I love this idea generally. It equalizes the attack side and the defense side of the system.

However, I think proposal 1 is more usable and effective.

---

Exactly my point