Clan Wars - Reward for Defending?

Sorry, if this has been mentioned before or just sounds silly. Also, I hope this is the best place to submit this idea as I see a million suggestions here.

One of our members asked if we get bonus loot for a successful defense and I said no, of course not.. but then something clicked and I said, well wait.. why not ??? Its a bit like sports where offenses are celebrated but defenses not so much despite being a very important part of the team and end result. Yes, offenses score and defenses don't but we're not talking about that. We're talking about reward.

Keeping the enemy from gaining 1-3 stars is great but after some thought, a reward of some sort would be greatly appreciated. I'm a farmer who is learning that trophy raiding is a much different skill from resource raiding. This new style of raiding (to me) is an art. So far, my attacks in 2 wars haven't gone so well (0, 1, 1, 2 stars) but my base has been fantastic (5 attacks - 0, 0, 0, 0, 2 stars). So my farming has done something good.

This could actually kill 2 birds with 1 stone for those who find the clan war bonus loot to be rather dismal despite all the hard work over 2 days. Also, it would benefit the low and medium-strength members of the clan as they are the ones who get attacked, possibly multiple times. Give them more loot, more encouragement, stay in the game longer ;)

Just a suggestion...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nesto

Sorry, if this has been mentioned before or just sounds silly. Also, I hope this is the best place to submit this idea as I see a million suggestions here.

One of our members asked if we get bonus loot for a successful defense and I said no, of course not.. but then something clicked and I said, well wait.. why not ??? Its a bit like sports where offenses are celebrated but defenses not so much despite being a very important part of the team and end result. Yes, offenses score and defenses don't but we're not talking about that. We're talking about reward.

Keeping the enemy from gaining 1-3 stars is great but after some thought, a reward of some sort would be greatly appreciated. I'm a farmer who is learning that trophy raiding is a much different skill from resource raiding. This new style of raiding (to me) is an art. So far, my attacks in 2 wars haven't gone so well (0, 1, 1, 2 stars) but my base has been fantastic (5 attacks - 0, 0, 0, 0, 2 stars). So my farming has done something good.

This could actually kill 2 birds with 1 stone for those who find the clan war bonus loot to be rather dismal despite all the hard work over 2 days. Also, it would benefit the low and medium-strength members of the clan as they are the ones who get attacked, possibly multiple times. Give them more loot, more encouragement, stay in the game longer ;)

Just a suggestion...

---

Yup that would be useful as in our first war a guy got attacked nearly 6 times (yup you heard that right) and won 5 and got one starred on the sixth. He would be so happy. The win bonus on him is huge

This is an awesome idea!

Good idea. Somehow the loot winning needs to be increased, I think from both winning and defending

bumpity bump

Great idea. in regular attacks we get trophies as a reward for defence. nothing here in war. make attacker loose star if defeated. or loot bonus

A small bonus, depending on your level, but yes... I like it!

This is a swell idea. I had two successful defenses in our current war and got 1 starred on my 3rd attack. I'd love to see a little bonus loot for my epicly awesome base. :)

Agree with this

I thought of this while drinking some hot chocolate but was too lazy to post it :P.

I agree, but instead of being based on your level it should be based on who attacked you and with what.