The best bases for Clan wars

Im sure the best base for clan wars are a tie between
Transformer bases - Bases easily transformable between farming and trophy hunting mode
And
Trap bases- bases heavily reliant on traps.

Since clan war bases are saved permantly for that war when war day starts, these bases excel in what they normally would lack

Trap bases- Normally, when your traps are deactivated by a 39% attack (so no shield) your next attack will be an easy 3 star.
Trap rearming cost is a lot for upgraded traps. And you need to do it every raid.

For clan wars, these cons are negated completely. No need to rearm traps, they stay there even when activated.

Transformer base cons-

Doesnt excel in either category
No point if you dont have regular trophy pushes.

Now for clan wars, it doesnt matter if it doesnt excel in either category. Easily switching between farming and trophy hunting is such a powerul benefit. You can continue farming easily even during the war with a simple switch.

I prefer trap bases tbh. Capitalizing on my upgraded traps, showing their true power.

Im going to post two trap bases. One is a derp design made by me, its designed to be underestimated. People go for the exposed air defense with a giant healer because it LOOKS perfect for giant healer. In reality, it DESTROYS giant healer armies. While I hate how it gets stomped on by hogs or how it gets very iffy when they dont attack on the right side.

Link-https://www.dropbox.com/s/plyd30bkmx...%2041%20PM.png

Heres the moat- A base not made by me. It capitalizes on traps and really is the only viable hog base I've seen for TH8s. It also destroys giant healer strategies
Link-https://www.dropbox.com/s/id9j82qtgy...%2045%20PM.png

So what do you think? Are these two base concepts (transformer and trap) the BEST for clan wars?

And how are these two bases? Thanks for any input

There is a clan wars specific drawback to the trap base: After it wins its first attack it loses the element of surprise due to future attackers watching the replays.

Granted there are some that don't do this; I knocked out two hog packs with the same two giant bombs in the first clan wars battle, lol.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Discostallion

There is a clan wars specific drawback to the trap base: After it wins its first attack it loses the element of surprise due to future attackers watching the replays.

Granted there are some that don't do this; I knocked out two hog packs with the same two giant bombs in the first clan wars battle, lol.

Forgot that possibility!
Yes, but in my clan wars experience, many dont re-attack a base even if its been no starred. Id hate to say this, but i guess we gotta hope for the best, huh?